Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think life in England must be much easier

245 replies

Heatethelastwaffle · 02/08/2024 20:21

I’m British but live abroad.
We are struggling a lot financially at the moment, life is hard, although the sun shines.
Where we are, if you fall into a hole, you’re pretty much screwed. Benefits exist, but you have to be very much on the breadline and even then it’s not enough to survive. There is a national health service, but it’s not great, so I’m having to pay out of my own money for private consultations. I have a chronic illness but no benefits whatsoever exist, my Dd is potentially suffering from Pans/pandas, they haven’t heard of it where we are, I’ve been to three separate Drs who had no idea what I’m talking about, There’s no help with rent, with housing, with bills and so on if you fall on hard times.

I want to go home, it may be depressing in some ways in England but you’re secure.

OP posts:
SpaceRaiders · 03/08/2024 07:45

iamtheblcksheep · 03/08/2024 01:13

I am so sick of people like you. How many years have you not lived here? Why do you expect to come back and get help for your child when people that have paid into the system are waiting months for treatment.

Stay where you are and figure it out.

What a horrible thing to say to someone looking for a little reassurance!

XelaM · 03/08/2024 07:45

TartanJambo · 03/08/2024 07:19

Sorry to derail, but can I please ask when and why you moved back? I'm in Germany and wanting to get back to the UK, it's harder with my German husband because of Brexit.
I'm finding it very hard to make friends here and feel lonely. Moving back to be near family and friends is my main motivation. The safer and cleaner aspect is why I'm reluctant to leave. .

I grew up in Germany and my parents live there, so for me moving back to Germany would be moving near family and friends. I can see how it may be different for you. Do you speak German? I think it's difficult to fit in if you don't. In terms of standard of living, medical care and education Germany is far superior though.

Ace56 · 03/08/2024 07:49

InfoSecInTheCity · 02/08/2024 21:49

@Lilysgoneshopping "Unless you arrive at Dover in a dingy of course"

Where you will be blessed with:

  • hostel living, possibly on a docked ship in a cabin room smaller than a prison cell
  • a prohibition on being able to work and earn money
  • massive delays in being able to claim asylum and gain any kind of legal right to live and work in this country
  • a grand sum of £49.18 per week to fulfil all of your basic needs like food, hygiene products, clothing....

Don’t see the issue here - £50 a week is more than enough to buy food and toiletries for one person. This is very generous compared to other countries

pinkdelight · 03/08/2024 07:50

my Dd is potentially suffering from Pans/pandas, they haven’t heard of it where we are

I'm sorry to hear that but it's not especially better for that here. My friend has had to go private to get her DC the help she needs and it's still been an exhausting expensive ongoing battle.

Lopine · 03/08/2024 07:59

Before making any firm plans to move, look at where the UK centres of excellence are (if there are any) for researching / treating your child’s health condition.

Also, have a look for any clinical trials in your current country as well as the UK.
https://clinicaltrials.gov
There may be options in your current location that will help even if you eventually move.

https://clinicaltrials.gov

Jellycatspyjamas · 03/08/2024 08:00

Don’t see the issue here - £50 a week is more than enough to buy food and toiletries for one person. This is very generous compared to other countries

Food, toiletries, clothes, shoes, any household goods you might need (having arrived with nothing), any bus fares/transport costs, phone use (essential to have some access to internet given everything is online now). If you can do all that on £50 a week I take my hat off to you.

Destiny123 · 03/08/2024 08:08

Heatethelastwaffle · 02/08/2024 20:32

@Lovesgreen Is she British? Problems coming back, why? I’ve been abroad a long time

I dont know the great details but my nans mate moved to oz for 20ish years. Returned home and wasn't entitled to the nhs for many years, had to pay private for everything

Epicaricacy · 03/08/2024 08:08

Some countries are obviously worst - it's not news that the equivalent of the NHS doesn't exist everywhere for a start. There wouldn't be any refugiees if life wasn't easier and safer.

The UK is also a lot worst and people struggling a lot more than in other more modern and efficient countries. We pretend to be great, but we are an embarrassment. This country is designed for the super rich, and gives massive handouts to the ones on lower income or no income. Anyone in between is struggling.

It all depends where you are now. It might be easier for you.

Lemony3 · 03/08/2024 08:13

Benefits exist but obviously it depends on earnings and situation. To rent now in my area the cost is huge compared to a few years ago. Look on entitled to, to see if you would be better off benefit wise. NHS waiting lists are pretty big in certain areas too.

Readingallthetime · 03/08/2024 08:16

Why are so many people on this thread so mean and begrudging?

What happened to you in your lives to make you want to sneer at others, and take pleasure in them being worse off than you, to the extent that you'll go out of your way to make them feel bad? Were you the school bullies? Are you literally sniggering behind your screen?

You're embarrassing yourselves.

Geran4 · 03/08/2024 08:19

Readingallthetime · 03/08/2024 08:16

Why are so many people on this thread so mean and begrudging?

What happened to you in your lives to make you want to sneer at others, and take pleasure in them being worse off than you, to the extent that you'll go out of your way to make them feel bad? Were you the school bullies? Are you literally sniggering behind your screen?

You're embarrassing yourselves.

Edited

Very well said. Some absolutely shameful comments on here.

inamarina · 03/08/2024 08:25

Starjumpfifty · 02/08/2024 23:35

Would you even be British if you didn't complain? I grew up abroad and I can tell you, all the expats complain about things like this at times. As pp said, it's difficult for somebody to understand if they haven't experienced living abroad. My parents lost their business in the 2008 recession, we had to leave our entire lives there and come back to the UK. There were no safety nets to utilise to sustain the family like those that exist in the UK if anything goes wrong, so it is an important thing to consider, especially with health issues involved.

Saying that, OP, I wouldn't come back if you didn't have to. I'd give anything to go back abroad, however it's not as easy for me now to go back. If you're financially secure there atm, I wouldn't choose to come back unless circumstances change, although I'm not clued up on Pans/panda.

Agree. There’s a rather large group on FB dedicated entirely to expat grumps.
It’s quite active too.
People decide to move abroad for different reasons, that doesn’t mean that they can never complain or regret their decision.

HappilyContentTheseDays · 03/08/2024 08:26

I understand OP. For a while I lived in Scandinavia, absolutely wonderful countries and lovely places to live, but it wasn't the same as in UK.
There was definitely help but not the same as in UK, and I realised from that experience that - for all the problems we experience in Britain - there is a safety net here which underpins everything which doesn't exist in other countries.

I came back and don't regret it.
However, do be realistic about returning. There are problems as others have said. Rentals are high and currently the NHS and education are going through a touch patch. You may find problems with accessing specialist help for your child, you will have to accept that it will be a slow process getting it sorted out.

Oh and cost of living has risen but it's still nothing like it was in Scandinavia!!

LlynTegid · 03/08/2024 08:29

You probably by returning to the UK will be nearer to some of your relatives, but please don't expect it to be as good as when you left.

GettingStuffed · 03/08/2024 08:30

Epicaricacy · 03/08/2024 08:08

Some countries are obviously worst - it's not news that the equivalent of the NHS doesn't exist everywhere for a start. There wouldn't be any refugiees if life wasn't easier and safer.

The UK is also a lot worst and people struggling a lot more than in other more modern and efficient countries. We pretend to be great, but we are an embarrassment. This country is designed for the super rich, and gives massive handouts to the ones on lower income or no income. Anyone in between is struggling.

It all depends where you are now. It might be easier for you.

Massive handouts? If I left DH and rented my daughter's grotty old flat, after housing costs, I'd have £30 per month for everything else. Yes I did say £30. Benefits aren't generous.

Scarletrunner · 03/08/2024 08:33

Snacksgalore · 02/08/2024 22:08

  • poverty not policy.

That’s a 1/3 of children who not have adequate food, clothing or housing.

Why aren't they entitled to benefits.

SpaceRaiders · 03/08/2024 08:39

This country is designed for the super rich, and gives massive handouts to the ones on lower income or no income. Anyone in between is struggling.

Punch up, that’s where all the issues lie.

gizatwirl · 03/08/2024 08:40

ForGreyKoala · 03/08/2024 06:32

I'm pleased to hear that you have had such great treatment, but why do you think you would be dead if you lived anywhere else? Lots of other countries have good health systems. Why do people in the UK think there is only the NHS or the US system?

This is very true. I've lived in one of the Gulf countries for ten years now and the NHS equivalent system here is truly amazing. Same day GP appointments at the time of your choosing,consultant appointments with no waiting lists so you're seen to straight away,even major surgery scheduled pretty much at your convenience. My DH who is self employed here is able to access all of this for us for a tiny payment each month,around 10GBP. Also all prescriptions are free. When we return to live in UK the first thing we'll do is get private health cover which will no doubt cost a fortune.

Hummingbird75 · 03/08/2024 08:44

I lived overseas for a few years op, and I know exactly what you mean. Much of Europe live in poverty, but because people fly in and fly out of lovely hotels and sparkling swimming pools and they simply do not see the reality behind the sunny climate.

The standard of living is extremely basic, health care is way behind what we would expect here, and schooling too in some places. There is real hand to mouth living and benefits and your housing is your problem, living on the breadline in 40c heat is no fun let me tell you.

People moan here, but we offer housing, healthcare, schooling, benefits and an incredible array of support but it is all taken for granted.

Hummingbird75 · 03/08/2024 08:46

gizatwirl · 03/08/2024 08:40

This is very true. I've lived in one of the Gulf countries for ten years now and the NHS equivalent system here is truly amazing. Same day GP appointments at the time of your choosing,consultant appointments with no waiting lists so you're seen to straight away,even major surgery scheduled pretty much at your convenience. My DH who is self employed here is able to access all of this for us for a tiny payment each month,around 10GBP. Also all prescriptions are free. When we return to live in UK the first thing we'll do is get private health cover which will no doubt cost a fortune.

But you overlook the disgraceful way the Gulf countries treat their workers and women in general? The confiscation of passports and freedom when they arrive? The very poor standard of living for those that are not wealthy western ex pats. You are painting a very one sided picture of a place that has sky high death rates amongst construction workers for example...

inamarina · 03/08/2024 08:48

XelaM · 03/08/2024 05:44

I moved to the UK from Germany and I think Germany is a much nicer and safer (in terms of financial security) place to live. I'm only staying here until my daughter finishes her GCSEs. Then I'm moving (whether back to Germany or somewhere sunny remains to be seen).

The UK is miserable. The weather is awful, everything is insanely expensive, medical care leaves a lot to be desired, taxes are huge, the education system is terrible. There are much nicer places out there.

Well, that’s your experience, but I do think you’re generalising a bit.
I’ve lived in Germany before. The weather where I am in the UK is much better than where I was in Germany.
Taxes are similar in both places, at least in our case.
Prices have gone up in Germany in the last couple of years, as they have in many places. Some things (like alcohol) are more expensive in the UK, both not the general food shop in my experience.
What I did find better though was healthcare provision and how affordable childcare was.

iamtheblcksheep · 03/08/2024 08:50

Frogpole · 03/08/2024 03:47

Tell me, where are you finding all of these ex-pats who are about to return to the United Kingdom? I mean there must be an absolute shitload of them for you to be this angry about it, right? You're clearly distressed about the tens of thousands of British citizens returning to Great Britain to steal your job universal credit, but how come you're the only person in the Kingdom who's aware of this travesty?

My universal credit? Good one. I don’t have a job. I do run several companies though if that’s good enough for you to allow me to have my own opinion. I do after all pay rather a lot of income and corporation tax.

You should not be allowed to use out NHS if you have not paid into our system. This is the OPs clear intention. I don’t give a toss. My universal credit you think I’m getting, also known as multiple income streams from my businesses allows me private health insurance, education…Anything I want I can skip the queue. For many this is unfortunately not the case. You might want to think before you insult someone again.

EI12 · 03/08/2024 08:50

Gillypie23 · 02/08/2024 21:25

You've not lived in the UK for years . Not paid into the system. You want to come back to claim benefits. Cheek of it.

Sorry. My former Bulgarian sister-in-law has not paid a penny into the system. She then imported her sister and parents to the UK, where they immediately applied and got NHS treatment. All with proud 'Brits are allowed to seek treatment in Bulgaria, we have a treaty' nonsense spouted. And you are questioning the right of a native to come back? Beyond strange.

Baital · 03/08/2024 08:57

Destiny123 · 03/08/2024 08:08

I dont know the great details but my nans mate moved to oz for 20ish years. Returned home and wasn't entitled to the nhs for many years, had to pay private for everything

There is a residency requirement to claim benefits.

If you are a UK citizen you can use the NHS from day 1 if you return permanently

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/08/2024 08:57

SpaceRaiders · 02/08/2024 21:32

I know years back quite a number of countries wouldn’t allow dual citizenship therefore expats would need to renounce their British citizenship before being granted citizenship there. It’s not straightforward coming back and you have to go through a fairly long expensive process to regain citizenship. My brother is going through this atm.

Op there’s no shame in returning if things haven’t worked out as well as you’d have hoped. But in all honesty life here isn’t any better. Your children will likely have better long term prospects abroad than here.

Edited

In theory the US doesn’t allow it, or certainly didn’t, but my sister who took out US citizenship some 20 years ago (it meant less tax to pay after her dh died) still has her British passport and was even told by the official at the citizenship ceremony that they knew that many people certainly didn’t renounce their former citizenship.