Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL says I'm excluding her

54 replies

Imtheproblemitsmeapparently · 22/07/2024 11:19

I invited MIL round for dinner a few months ago. She'd been having a tough time so I felt it was a nice thing to do. She was rude as hell all evening, snappy, standoffish, judgemental etc but I ignored it thinking she's just in a bad place and that was likely it. The evening ended when she snapped at my 3 year old and I pulled her up on it. I was polite but firm. She burst into tears, i apologised for upsetting her but she immediately left without saying a word to us.

Since then, I've messaged her to apologise again and explained why i was cross at the time. She sent a pithy, childish response along the lines of 'it's ok I just won't speak to him anymore then', so i've not responded.

She's since called DH in tears and said it's not about this incident, but that she feels like I don't invite her to places, I don't contact her etc etc. She then apologised to DH. She has not contacted me since her pithy message.

I work 5 days a week. DH works one day at the weekend and sometimes two so we have exactly 1 day a week as a family about twice a month. On those days, we like to go out to places together and this appears to be what she wants to be invited to. She's also upset we see more of my parents than her - baring in mind my parents ask all the time to see DS, come over to help us out regularly etc. She has never once in 2 years offered proactively to have DS, we always ask her to see him.

Anyway, since then I've stopped reminding DH to contact her and stopped contact with her myself. I've made it clear to DH that his relationship with his mother is now his responsibility, and if he'd like to invite her round that's absolutely fine, I'll cook, I'll be completely polite and act like nothing has ever happened but I absolutely won't be organising it or taking responsibility for her relationship with our DS.

Predictably, DH has not invited her round, asked her how she is, contacted her or asked to take DS to see her a single time without me prompting him. She has now told the entire family I'm 'keeping her DS and DGS from her' because all contact has stopped. SHe still hasnt apologised to me for not accepting my apology, and also has not proactively contacted DH or myself.

WIBU to continue putting the responsibility for the relationship in DH's hands and not accept that this is in any way my doing? If MIL wants to see her DS and DGS she just has to ask - equally DH isnt reaching out to her because he never does without me asking him to. I don't see how that's me 'keeping them away from her'.

Answers on a postcard, I'm more than happy to be told I'm wrong here and I need to pick the reigns back up, but I'm genuinely not sure I am.

OP posts:
Irridescantshimmmer · 20/08/2024 19:21

Your MIL snaps at your 3 year old, so you put her in her place and quite rightly so.

She's then blamed you for the consequences of her own actions OP. When it's not your fault, you defended and protected your child.

Your not the one who should apologise, she's manipulated you.

She should apologise for snapping at her grandson, she's a spoilt brat and needs to mature. Your 3 year old is more mature than she is.

Createausername1970 · 20/08/2024 19:36

We sorted out our own families with regards to visiting and presents.

My PILs lived quite close so DH visited at least once a week and would call between visits. He took care of their birthdays and Christmas most of the time, but because he always took the initiative I was happy to help out if needed. I would go round with him every third or fourth visit before DS. Once DS came along they very kindly offered to have him one afternoon a week, and I used to collect DS from them as DH wasn't usually home from work before bedtime.

Having said that, I rarely got involved with BIL or SIL's presents, apart from an occasional reminder. I did leave them up to him.

Dancingontheedge · 20/08/2024 20:39

Forty years together and OH has always been responsible for dealing with his relatives, maintaining contact, birthday and Christmas cards. As I have with mine. Yes, I signed birthday cards for his mum, but he bought the card and sent it. Yes, we had get togethers and visits, but we shared the work involved.
Why is it the woman’s responsibility to be proactive about his side of the family?
As long as you don’t block, or be nasty for no good reason, he’s just as capable of being a good child to his parents as you are to yours. He needs to be the connection.

Throughahedgebackwards · 20/08/2024 22:49

Laundryliar · 20/08/2024 17:38

So many women prioritise their own mum and dad over their in laws and don't see how unfair it is. OP you have a little boy. How will you feel when he's an adult and a parent if his wife sees her own parents all the time and you never get a look in with the grandkids...

Can't quite believe what i just read. How on earth is it unfair to prioritise your relationship with your own parents ? I am not responsible for facilitating a relationship between my partners' parents and his kids!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page