Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

About half of British workers earn under £15 hour - new Living Wage?

242 replies

Melisha · 09/07/2024 00:20

At the moment about half of the workforce earns under £15 an hour. We need to increase national minimum wage to £15 an hour, lifting many of the workforce out of poverty.
Do you agree NMW should be £15 an hour?

OP posts:
MidnightMeltdown · 10/07/2024 17:16

justasking111 · 09/07/2024 11:17

When people complain about shareholders they need to realise that it's not individuals holding all these shares. Pension funds, where do you think that money comes from?

So it's ok for people to work full time and not be able to afford to live, just so long as their labour is funding other peoples pensions?

Most of these poor sods probably can't even afford to pay into a pension.

MintsPi · 10/07/2024 17:48

FloatyBoaty · 10/07/2024 08:26

This has been super interesting.

Feels like lots of people think “some people just need to be badly paid/ poor” (“as long as it’s not me!”)

Im interested to know, of all the posters who say NMW shouldn’t be raised (and presumably believe that the state shouldn’t be topping up salaries with UC)- are you prepared to pay increased tax as a middle or high income earner, so that the poorest paid can have access to the best state provided housing, health and social care, education, public leisure facilities, libraries, parks, and so on, possible, and that they deserve?

This is surely the only possible compensation for these people who are taking those jobs that nobody else wants, that are keeping them trapped in a cycle of poverty, and that ultimately are leaving them with no opportunity to build assets and generational wealth, surely?

The fact is people need others to clean their offices, deliver their shopping, look after their elderly relatives etc etc but they don't actually care how these people live as long as the jobs they need them to do get done.

People don't want to pay for benefits and they are concerned about price rises if wages go up so therefore the only alternative is low earners live in poverty. A just reward for 'not working hard enough' perhaps?

How quickly everyone has forgotten the key workers that worked during Covid....

JenniferBooth · 10/07/2024 18:27

MintsPi · 10/07/2024 17:48

The fact is people need others to clean their offices, deliver their shopping, look after their elderly relatives etc etc but they don't actually care how these people live as long as the jobs they need them to do get done.

People don't want to pay for benefits and they are concerned about price rises if wages go up so therefore the only alternative is low earners live in poverty. A just reward for 'not working hard enough' perhaps?

How quickly everyone has forgotten the key workers that worked during Covid....

I point this out every time there is a thread on here rubbishing social housing tenants. Where the fuck do they think those on low pay who delivered them their shit during Covid live.

carrythecan · 10/07/2024 19:14

80% of the working population have a workplace pension, so we don't really want these big corporations to stop paying out to the shareholders.

There isn't a simple answer to increase workers out of low pay. I do agree that the gap between the lowest paid and those in higher pay brackets is too large, but the problem is not going to be easily solved.

There are other much more worrying issues that need fixing in order to allow wages to rise. Currently productivity growth is very low, whereas state spending and taxation levels are high. Too many successive governments have failed to address these issues.

Melisha · 10/07/2024 19:16

Most of that 80% will have a tiny pension. Most would be better being paid £15 an hour.

OP posts:
carrythecan · 10/07/2024 20:13

So the pensions are mainly tiny, but enough money is given to them (via the shareholder profits) to be taken and instead used to give over half the UK workforce a 30% pay rise?

ForGreyKoala · 10/07/2024 22:16

carrythecan · 10/07/2024 09:21

I don’t think anybody wants people to be badly paid but the answer to reduce poverty is not a simple ‘put up minimum wage’.

Using the Tesco example, while the profit looks enormous, it’s only about a 2.5% net profit on its turnover. If it increased the pay to the vast majority of its workers without passing on the costs then it goes bust.

Companies also have to make enough profit to have sufficient cash flow to pay wages, taxes, utilities and suppliers etc as well as invest in maintenance of their buildings and equipment. Tesco are not just sat on piles of cash and running their hands together.

So many people on this thread seem to have a very naive view of economics. All they can see is a raising of wages (which I totally agree with, but there are ways of doing it to minimise overall harm to the economy) and not the flow on effect.

Opinionwontchangeluv · 11/07/2024 01:10

Agree and retail or fast food workers need more money they take to much crap off people. I'm not one of these workers but I see the attitude they get

Maverickess · 11/07/2024 01:36

MintsPi · 10/07/2024 17:48

The fact is people need others to clean their offices, deliver their shopping, look after their elderly relatives etc etc but they don't actually care how these people live as long as the jobs they need them to do get done.

People don't want to pay for benefits and they are concerned about price rises if wages go up so therefore the only alternative is low earners live in poverty. A just reward for 'not working hard enough' perhaps?

How quickly everyone has forgotten the key workers that worked during Covid....

And people moan 'the service in this country is shit' well it's hardly surprising when the people delivering it are paid too little to live on, are vilified for doing the job they do because of the low wages and any top ups that may be needed (subsidised by the poor old squeezed middle who gets nothing in Return!) and how they should get better jobs if they want to afford to live or woe betide have a little treat now and again, who gets complained at because the service is shit, because there aren't enough people doing it because of said conditions, get abused to the point high street shops have given staff body cams and generally expected to serve their betters, be grateful for the opportunity and shut up about being poor so the £100k doesn't go very far in London crowd can moan and say they pay for everything and shouldn't be resented, despite resenting the people who deliver the services that mean they can earn, and then enjoy their higher income.

I tell you, being treated like that, knocks any shits you could have given about giving good service right out of you given long enough.

Sosorryliver · 11/07/2024 02:25

Melisha · 10/07/2024 16:37

Supermarkets are cutting staff all the time and pocketing the savings.

That’s true. I’m forever scanning my own shopping whilst one member of staff watches over 8 self serve tills. I think you have to remember the average corporation doesn’t give a toss about its staff. They are all replaceable. They probably should be made to pay staff more/ properly. It’s just funding those rises in the short -medium term.

PocketSand · 12/07/2024 14:16

Put simply a minimum wage is not to allow average people to have increased wealth and better their lives (same for in work benefits) - it's to allow the continuation of exorbitant rents, low wages to qualified staff, high cost of living - food, gas, electricity, water etc - so that the already rich can increase their wealth at the cost of the poor and needy.

That said it's also a heads up to the strivers who have gained professional qualifications in the public sector as to how little they have been valued under the tories. I hope that labour address the way that the public sector has been ideologically and financially punished for over a decade and the negative impact this has had on public services.

Sunsetboater · 12/07/2024 15:59

User2460177 · 09/07/2024 22:57

There’s one CEO and you need the best. Like it or not many of the staff at the bottom are low skilled and interchangeable. If you start paying them a lot more then they will be replaced by technology.

Also the existing minimum wage is enough to live on. But it depends on your circumstances how good your life will be

So.. let them eat cake 🙄

Twizzlelolly · 05/08/2024 21:00

Onedaystronger · 09/07/2024 02:05

Steady on OP! If those on a low wage get an increase to £15 per hour they may edge towards being able to save for a house deposit so that they can buy instead of renting.

They would, of course then pay less pcm on a mortgage than on rent, but what about all the landorrds who rely on rental income to maintain their lifestyle and pay off their mortgages?

On a more serious note I despise people who won't acknowledge the brutal unfairness of a set up where the lowest earners can't buy a home and instead pay a higher monthly payment to rent than they would on a mortgage. All whilst working their asses off doing a valuable job and pouring most of their income into renting and lining the pocket of someone else. Ugh.

Well said. What hope have people got?

Wishitwasstraightforward · 06/08/2024 19:57

Melisha · 09/07/2024 00:20

At the moment about half of the workforce earns under £15 an hour. We need to increase national minimum wage to £15 an hour, lifting many of the workforce out of poverty.
Do you agree NMW should be £15 an hour?

@Melisha apologies if I've missed it (have read the thread) but pls can you point me towards a source for this info..

I don't doubt it for a moment but a source would help me personally for an unrelated issue that I won't derail the thread with- unless you'd like some context before sharing...

caringcarer · 06/08/2024 23:34

I don't think it's realistic to go from about £10.50 to £15 but it should rise slowly maybe by £1 extra each year.

PizzaFecker · 07/08/2024 02:03

The nhs pays 11.45 for band 2. They are the absolute work horses of the nhs

Hurryupretirement · 04/03/2025 18:41

Well its great in principle but in reality theres no way on earth I will continue doing my highly stressful NHS nursing job ( qualified 28 years, acute mental health,very very demanding) for £5 an hour more than someone working as a cinema attendant or a librarian or a person serving coffee. I will do one of those jobs instead thanks!!!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page