Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The difference between cancer life as a royal and as a "lesser mortal"

703 replies

sixtyandsomething · 16/06/2024 12:40

not to derail other threads..

I have nothing against the Princess of Wales, I am sure she is a lovely person and I wish her well. however, let's not pretend she is facing the same struggles as the rest of us.

I bet you £10 she hasn't had to deal with any of these! (feel free to add your own)

-40+ calls to DWP, often being left on hold for 2 hours or more
-many months delay in benefits being processed, leaving you without any income at all
-DWP advising you to "find a food bank"
-struggle up the hill on crutches to get a bus to chemo
-appointments delayed and cancelled, blood tests lost and repeated, regular system "crashes" leaving medical staff with no access to your notes.
-never seeing the same medical professionals twice.
-consultant appointments cancelled when you have already travelled several hours to the hospital
-telephone appointments you have to sit and wait by the phone for, for the whole day
-worry on crammed full bus when you are CEV
-getting off bus because it is too full
-getting of bus because you are vomiting
-sitting on the pavement for 3-4 hours after chemo in the dark and rain, because you are CEV and don't want to get back on a crammed bus in the rush hour
-commuters swearing at you because you move too slowly
-commuter kicking you out of the way because you move to slowly, and doing it with an air of indignation, like they feel seriously injured by having to touch something so disgusting with their foot
-minimum 18 hour wait in A and E before being admitted with infection - once it was 28 hours
-further many hour wait in ER before being admitted to wards.
-spending night on chair in corridor, after being admitted to a ward
-being asked to vacate chair in corridor so doctor can perform ECG on patient who is currently standing up with nowhere to sit
-being warned by hospital staff to sleep in your glasses so they are not stolen
-having to buy a constant stream of new clothes, and having to go to charity shops - on steroids? go up two sizes, no chemo? go down 3- surgery? get front opening everything, in a range of sizes.
-not being able have a clean the house, wash up, open the window even, without calling a friend to come and help.
-council refusing to empty your bins because you are not capable of moving them to the right place at the right time
-giving away your pets because you can't take care of them, or afford them
-being told the waiting list to see a physiotherapist is around a year

I could go on

I am so grateful for the treatment I have had, and I hope the Princess of Wales does well and recovers, but the two situations are not the same, even slightly, even if the disease is.

OP posts:
Dentistlakes · 16/06/2024 18:47

YANBU, your experiences show how unbelievably difficult falling seriously ill is for the average person. The added stress of trying to keep afloat financially and family life running can’t help recovery. The NHS needs to be completely overhauled. It’s not just a matter of throwing more money at it either. The whole system needs to be looked at. It runs incredibly inefficiently.

LadyKenya · 16/06/2024 18:48

Allison Pearson was the reason I stopped buying the DM years ago. The foolish woman, was always writing a load of tosh, afaiac. Looking back, she did me a favour. Seems like nothing much has changed.

willWillSmithsmith · 16/06/2024 18:48

AcrossthePond55 · 16/06/2024 16:35

I'm in the US so no 'socialized medicine' or Royal Family.

The 'Cancer Road' each person travels is different, but not because of a person's 'status', but because of money.

Kate's journey would still be the same (IMO) because her family is rich. Not RF rich, but enough money that she would still have been able to 'go private', hire household help, etc. Yes, I know there's a debate on the fact that the RF is 'publicly funded', but that's a different issue than the level of care available for rich vs 'poor'. Her royal status isn't the reason she gets the level of care she gets, the money is, whether it's RF or Middleton money. That much is the same pretty much worldwide. Those with the resources (and/or medical insurance) are able to get probably better, or at least more options and more accessible care. The only difference is that Kate is in the public eye, even more so than a run of the mill celebrity would be. Would the outcry be the same if it were a film star or a footballer getting the same care that Kate is? They, too, can afford live in help and private care.

Of course it's different here because we don't have an NHS. But we do have Medicaid for low income people. Would they have many of the care options that DH could have chosen when he was diagnosed? No, they wouldn't because not all facilities or practitioners take Medicaid (the same I suppose as 'private' care in the UK) and our good insurance meant that we had lots of options. But in the end we chose a university medical center than also serves the medically needy community. Why? Because it had the best and most up to date staff and facilities. And those are available to all, Medicaid or private insurance.

I was thinking this yesterday when reading comments about how she’s able to take limitless time off because she’s royal and privileged. I thought no matter who she married (or never married) she would always be able to have as much time off as she wanted and top notch health care because her upbringing was very wealthy and her circle equally so. She would probably have married an aristocrat or a very rich financier. She was never going to be on an NHS waiting list regardless of the RF.

Blah12345678999 · 16/06/2024 18:49

fiddlesticksohyeah · 16/06/2024 12:47

You could give a negative comparison about anything really, but so what? The NHS decline is down to the tories.

Will ppl keep voting for them though or reform 😣 although the only realistic alternative doesn’t seem great either

Italianita · 16/06/2024 18:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Glassfullofdreams · 16/06/2024 18:53

I've had my own cancer journey and I can honestly say I experienced nothing you listed. Does that mean I had an easy journey? Absolutely not. Just because Catherine hasn't experienced anything you've listed, does that mean she's having an easier journey? No.

No one even knows what type of cancer she has. We don't know what surgery she had. We don't know how it has affected her, or how it might continue to affect her every day.

Yes, you've had a terrible time, but so has Catherine and every other person who has received a cancer diagnosis. Has your journey been worse than Catherine's? Who knows. You're really not in an position to know what any other person with cancer goes through. It's quite possible that Catherine has experienced a lot of terrible things that you didn't.

Kitte321 · 16/06/2024 18:56

theeyeofdoe · 16/06/2024 18:32

No it’s yours which is offensive. She’s a relatively young woman with cancer.

100%. How would anyone want someone’s situation to be worse just so it’s ‘fair’? It’s bloody unfair she has cancer at all - many many of us at her age don’t.
It’s not a race to the bottom. We should all wish she receives the very best of care just in the same way we would want this for our own loved ones.

ShowerOfShites · 16/06/2024 18:57

Onand · 16/06/2024 18:43

I think she presented herself remarkably well for someone who has been off work sick for the last 6 months and is still undergoing treatment. It is often not the case for so many cancer patients and that struggle is very real and life changing in more ways than one. I just feel the optics of the balcony scene insinuates that all is well and it’s business as usual when it most likely isn’t and may not be for some time.

I understand the RFs stoicism when it comes to these matters but for those going through cancer treatment right now is it not placing an unreasonable expectation to spring back to normality, because Kate did?

I understand the RFs stoicism when it comes to these matters but for those going through cancer treatment right now is it not placing an unreasonable expectation to spring back to normality, because Kate did?

So are you saying she shouldn't have gone back to work incase it upsets other people?

Despair1 · 16/06/2024 18:58

OP, I wish you the very best in your treatment journey. Take care

Italianita · 16/06/2024 18:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

crumblingschools · 16/06/2024 18:59

A poster talked about her experience under the French healthcare system which you have to pay insurance for.

How many people in this country are fighting against something like that being introduced here. The NHS is not fit for purpose, something has to be done and not just throw money at it without looking at how we need to move forward and gave a proper system in place. If we had something like the French system then inequalities would not be so marked. But people have to accept that the NHS needs a radical reform

MyQuaintDog · 16/06/2024 19:00

This thread is because of media coverage. It is offensive to claim anyone wants Catherine's life to be harder. We just want the press to stop pretending Catherine is having a harder time than ordinary people who get cancer.
The coverage of Charles is fine.

PilgorTheGoat · 16/06/2024 19:00

The fear and worry must be the same regardless of your life situation but I agree. The PoW experience of cancer will be so different to that of the rest of us.

MyQuaintDog · 16/06/2024 19:01

We also want people to stop pretending that access to lots of money does not have an impact on outcomes from cancer. Of course it does. Many of us have lost people who might have lived if they had been given the best treatment that money can buy.

MyQuaintDog · 16/06/2024 19:03

@crumblingschools The NHS in 2010 was judged to be the most efficient healthcare system in the world. As soon as you introduce insurance, the costs increase by an average of 10%. You need people to sell insurance, to process insurance claims or turn them down, to detect fraud, and to collect co pays or pursue people through the courts for debts.

Italianita · 16/06/2024 19:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

diddl · 16/06/2024 19:10

I just feel the optics of the balcony scene insinuates that all is well and it’s business as usual when it most likely isn’t and may not be for some time.

It was just a few hours.

She has hardly "gone back to work" in any sense of the word has she?

I don't think that the optics showed anything other than her wanting to be there for her FIL.

TheKoalaWhoCould · 16/06/2024 19:10

It’s not a race to the bottom - there’s no good way to have cancer. She doesn’t have to do that, but you aren’t having to go through it with millions of people scrutinising your every move and tearing apart everything you say, do or wear. Your experiences are different but if I had to choose between 40 calls to the DWP and having the entirety of the world’s press trying to photograph me on the school run when I’m in the middle of chemo, I know which I’d pick…..

I’m sorry things are so hard for both of you tbh.

TheOccupier · 16/06/2024 19:11

sixtyandsomething · 16/06/2024 12:40

not to derail other threads..

I have nothing against the Princess of Wales, I am sure she is a lovely person and I wish her well. however, let's not pretend she is facing the same struggles as the rest of us.

I bet you £10 she hasn't had to deal with any of these! (feel free to add your own)

-40+ calls to DWP, often being left on hold for 2 hours or more
-many months delay in benefits being processed, leaving you without any income at all
-DWP advising you to "find a food bank"
-struggle up the hill on crutches to get a bus to chemo
-appointments delayed and cancelled, blood tests lost and repeated, regular system "crashes" leaving medical staff with no access to your notes.
-never seeing the same medical professionals twice.
-consultant appointments cancelled when you have already travelled several hours to the hospital
-telephone appointments you have to sit and wait by the phone for, for the whole day
-worry on crammed full bus when you are CEV
-getting off bus because it is too full
-getting of bus because you are vomiting
-sitting on the pavement for 3-4 hours after chemo in the dark and rain, because you are CEV and don't want to get back on a crammed bus in the rush hour
-commuters swearing at you because you move too slowly
-commuter kicking you out of the way because you move to slowly, and doing it with an air of indignation, like they feel seriously injured by having to touch something so disgusting with their foot
-minimum 18 hour wait in A and E before being admitted with infection - once it was 28 hours
-further many hour wait in ER before being admitted to wards.
-spending night on chair in corridor, after being admitted to a ward
-being asked to vacate chair in corridor so doctor can perform ECG on patient who is currently standing up with nowhere to sit
-being warned by hospital staff to sleep in your glasses so they are not stolen
-having to buy a constant stream of new clothes, and having to go to charity shops - on steroids? go up two sizes, no chemo? go down 3- surgery? get front opening everything, in a range of sizes.
-not being able have a clean the house, wash up, open the window even, without calling a friend to come and help.
-council refusing to empty your bins because you are not capable of moving them to the right place at the right time
-giving away your pets because you can't take care of them, or afford them
-being told the waiting list to see a physiotherapist is around a year

I could go on

I am so grateful for the treatment I have had, and I hope the Princess of Wales does well and recovers, but the two situations are not the same, even slightly, even if the disease is.

This thread is in incredibly poor taste and makes you sound small and bitter. None of the list of complaints you've posted matters the tiniest bit compared to the fear of dying while your children are very young.

crumblingschools · 16/06/2024 19:11

@MyQuaintDog I think a lot has happened since 2010

AnnaCBi · 16/06/2024 19:12

GoodAfternoonGoodEveningAndGoodnight · 16/06/2024 12:43

It's not a competition.
So sorry you have suffered too, but just because she's rich and Royal doesn't mean she's having it any easier, she's still a young mum with kids.

That’s definitely what the OP was acknowledging, it’s awful for the PoW too… it’s just the journo who referred to ‘lesser mortals’ who don’t deal with cancer as well as Kate has… they’re the ones who have so many other knock on effects of cancer and the cancer treatment.

klobbs · 16/06/2024 19:12

MyQuaintDog · 16/06/2024 19:03

@crumblingschools The NHS in 2010 was judged to be the most efficient healthcare system in the world. As soon as you introduce insurance, the costs increase by an average of 10%. You need people to sell insurance, to process insurance claims or turn them down, to detect fraud, and to collect co pays or pursue people through the courts for debts.

Take a look at the Dutch system. I believe the costs (to the system) are extremely high per capita, but it is certainly more equitable than the NHS.

JenniferBooth · 16/06/2024 19:13

TheKoalaWhoCould · 16/06/2024 19:10

It’s not a race to the bottom - there’s no good way to have cancer. She doesn’t have to do that, but you aren’t having to go through it with millions of people scrutinising your every move and tearing apart everything you say, do or wear. Your experiences are different but if I had to choose between 40 calls to the DWP and having the entirety of the world’s press trying to photograph me on the school run when I’m in the middle of chemo, I know which I’d pick…..

I’m sorry things are so hard for both of you tbh.

Yep Sure you would!

https://inews.co.uk/news/terminally-ill-cancer-patient-universal-credit-dwp-benefits-died-penniless-244565

Cancer patient paid benefits day after he died following 8-week wait

Mark Scholfield, who had advanced mouth cancer, had to have fitness to work interview despite him not being able to talk.

https://inews.co.uk/news/terminally-ill-cancer-patient-universal-credit-dwp-benefits-died-penniless-244565

YourOldAirPurifier · 16/06/2024 19:15

TheOccupier · 16/06/2024 19:11

This thread is in incredibly poor taste and makes you sound small and bitter. None of the list of complaints you've posted matters the tiniest bit compared to the fear of dying while your children are very young.

You are really out of order telling someone their pets don’t matter. And I doubt you have cancer. You don’t know what it’s like.

crumblingschools · 16/06/2024 19:17

@MyQuaintDog and if our system is so great why has the OP suffered so much