Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL won’t give me my baby even when she’s crying for me with outstretched arms

72 replies

ILikeEggsAnd · 09/05/2024 13:12

Hi here’s a bit of background details. I went to Croatia with my four month old DD so she could meet my MIL. She already has three other grandkid’s from her daughter who stays locally. I understand she was excited to meet my DD but she wouldn’t give me my DD even when she had outstretched arms and was crying for me. MIL would make me sit in the front seat of the car and she would sit behind with DD (DH would drive). Again even though my DD would cry, MIL wanted to see that DD should smile seeing her! My DH just said it’s only 10 days that his mom will see her so she can cry and then I will get her back! For the record, my MIL and I don’t speak the same language.

It’s been four months since this family holiday and I feel so upset at myself for not standing up for my DD. I’m also so worried that DDs birthday is around the corner and MIL will again try to do something like that. What’s worst is my DH won’t say anything.

My parents are first time grandparents and as excited as they are, they never try to keep my DD away from me when she cries for me so I don’t think my MIL is acting normally. They too stay abroad and don’t get to meet her regularly so the self entitlement of my MIL to hold her all the time doesn’t make sense. Even my parents don’t meet DD so often. Is my MIL going overboard? She was getting upset and taking DD away if she even smiled at MIL’s dad! Basically it felt like she was competing for my DDs love! Really come on MIL, don’t take it personally if she won’t smile at you especially if you won’t give her back to me when she’s visibly crying.

How do I stop this from happening next time? I tried to use BF and nappy change as an excuse but she would be taken from me right after. I sat behind in the car with my DD and my MIL looked all upset for me stealing away those moments from her. I honestly want to tell her to back off and that she can hold DD but not every minute of the day especially when she’s crying out for me. Besides, she wasn’t even interacting with DD, just shushing her!

If I’d even take my DD and she’s turn quiet and happy my MIL would take her away the next second. Stop your silly competition MIL!

MIL you’ve had your turn in raising kids and you have local grandkid’s. You are just my MIL. Stop hogging my baby for every second you visit us, just because you get to meet her so little doesn’t mean you hold onto her even when she is desperately crying for me! Am I being unreasonable?

PS Don’t tell me DH should speak. He has never stood up for me to the point that his sisters family are racist towards me and he’s quiet. I have cut my SIL from my life since DH won’t speak up and no, leaving him isn’t an option.

Also, meeting up oftener is not an option. Not after how she is behaving. The audacity of my MIL to do this. And my DH never standing up to my racist SIL means I want to have very reduced contact with them and I don’t think any grandparent is entitled to their grandkid if they can’t respect their grandkid’s needs i.e. outstretched arms wanting mummy.

OP posts:
FiatEarth · 09/05/2024 18:02

Original thread.

Bizarre that the op has reposted -

MIL self inviting herself to baby’s first birthday http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/5067429-mil-self-inviting-herself-to-babys-first-birthday?msgid=-5067429#-5067429

Frangipanyoul8r · 09/05/2024 19:12

Either he backs you up and explains you need to hold your baby, or you don’t see MIL at all. That’s the ultimatum.

Nicole1111 · 09/05/2024 19:49

What are you hoping to gain from posting the same questions again? If none of the answers on the other post were to your liking have you considered that part of the problem is your inability to take guidance on board and actually implement things like boundaries in your life?

Cherrysoup · 09/05/2024 19:56

Why have you posted the exact same thing twice? You were advised last time to take your baby back, grow a spine etc. Do you think the advice will change?

FineWordsButterNoParsnips · 10/05/2024 17:13

@ILikeEggsAnd ? Do you not find your threads helpful?

Phoenixfire1988 · 12/05/2024 11:40

How do women stay with such spineless men I couldn't imagine anything less attractive and if anyone refused to hand over my baby they wouldn't know what hit them

cerisepanther73 · 12/05/2024 12:21

@ILikeEggsAnd

You have got the ability to be emotionally strong 💪 and put in the much needed boundary when needed,

As you stood up to your Arsehole of sister in law,

But there something about your mother in law or and about her relationship to your husband,
that's a stumbling block barrier for you

I think you are much more stronger than you realised and definitely more than your sorry excuse of your husband who should have had your back in the first place,
Who should have had his prioritises in the right place in regards of dealing with his sister emotionally pschological attitudes towards you,

Is there something about your mother in law reminds you of authority figure such as headmistress etc?

I 🤔 think there is something about being a new mother with a baby can give you identity low self esteem crisis especially compounded ,
if you have a weak 💩 crap partner and inadequate support system around you,
Just not enough general family support ect...

get as much of the necessary support you need from elsewhere too,
such as relevant charties organisations that can be beneficial to you and your family in some ways,

Brats4kid · 12/05/2024 15:01

That's awful... I hate when people do that! 😔

DeeCeeCherry · 12/05/2024 15:12

Again?

You have no backbone and that'll do neither you or your DD any good

Your racist husband and his racist family don't respect you. Which you already know.

Your MIL is a problem, but she's not the only problem is she?

Nosygirl01 · 12/05/2024 15:24

Get a grip and speak up. It is your child. If you want her you take her.

pinkyredrose · 12/05/2024 15:28

PS Don’t tell me DH should speak. He has never stood up for me to the point that his sisters family are racist towards me and he’s quiet. I have cut my SIL from my life since DH won’t speak up and no, leaving him isn’t an option.

Why isn't it an option?

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 12/05/2024 15:35

labracadabras · 09/05/2024 13:15

Say pass me my baby back now please - if she doesn’t repeat it loudly and tell her You need to hand me my baby immediately.
if you have to ask more than once after you have him back just say - no you can’t hold him - you don’t give him back when asked I’m his mother.

First post nailed it.
I honestly want to tell her to back off and that she can hold DD but not every minute of the day especially when she’s crying out for me. Besides, she wasn’t even interacting with DD, just shushing her!

Tell her exactly that then!

It ought to be DP issue, but since he's doing nothing, its up to you to advocate for your DD. Stand up for yourself.
You may feel like this is being rude. Your MIL might be (most certainly will be) offended by you telling her she is not to carry on doing what she is doing.
She is the one being rude to you by treating you this way.
Stick to your guns
Explain to your DH what acceptable behaviour towards you and the baby is and that you expect him to support you in sticking to those guidelines.

DiddyPumpkin · 12/05/2024 20:19

Sounds like you need to put all of that in google translate and message her before the next visit

StarbucksQueen1 · 12/05/2024 20:23

If leaving your prick of a DH who can’t stick up for you isn’t an option then you’ll have to put up with it. I couldn’t tolerate this.

webs1991 · 12/05/2024 22:33

Just take your child back off you don’t you are allowing this to keep happening you have to do what you’re comfortable with and stand up for yourself you don’t need excuses like bf or nappy change just take her your baby is crying and wants you full stop. I’d personally not go to Croatia again tbh the whole situation sounds like hell and your MIL has no right

Ifyoucouldreadmymindlove · 13/05/2024 06:36

Leave your husband. Going by your other threads, he’s a nasty piece of work.

RhiannonTheRed · 13/05/2024 11:13

"PS Don’t tell me DH should speak. He has never stood up for me to the point that his sisters family are racist towards me and he’s quiet. I have cut my SIL from my life since DH won’t speak up and no, leaving him isn’t an option."

Then leave. If your husband won't advocate for you, he won't advocate for your daughter, and what sort of example is that to a young child? Take your child, leave that awful family who have 0% respect for you and don't look back.

NIClaire · 13/05/2024 22:24

You are not being unreasonable being mad at your MIL keeping your baby from you. But you are being unreasonable if you think your husband shouldn't be the one sorting his family out. And unreasonable if you think you can't leave him. If he sits back and watches his family be racist and mean toward you, he doesn't have much respect or care for you. YOU are the one teaching him, and them, that they can treat you like crap and get away with it.

Edenmum2 · 13/05/2024 22:30

It's fine, you were shocked last time. This time just take her back, confidently and firmly. If your MIL resists then your husband needs to step up,

Bordesleyhills · 14/05/2024 07:05

Spend a few days and then you three go off for a holiday leaving MIL and FIL at home

LadyEloise1 · 14/05/2024 07:35

ACynicalDad · 09/05/2024 16:19

How did your husband co-create a child when he lacks balls.

😂

Dragonsmother · 15/05/2024 19:33

This is a DP issue. You said: ”leaving him isn’t an option

This is a huge red flag. I am sorry but if you “want” to leave him, then you should be able to.

Do you feel safe with DH? Are you in this relationship because you want to be in it or are you being forced to stay in the relationship?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread