Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Relationship advice - two different cultures?

54 replies

DenimOtter · 09/04/2024 15:17

Hi, hoping your thoughts on some relationship issues as have found this thread very insightful before

We're a relationship between Indian F & English M, both mid-late twenties. The relationship has been ongoing for 2.5 years & has generally been going great. Indian F moved to UK for work reasons shortly before the relationship began & since then we've always lived in UK. This was Indian F's first time living outside India; English M has never lived outside UK.

We've visited India together once - English M has met Indian F's immediate family but wasn't introduced to elderly relatives due to cultural traditions. He enjoyed the trip but seemed to find it difficult not having the independence he used to & not being introduced to family members. He hasn't made any real efforts to learn Hindi, although has joined cultural celebrations in UK when invited.

Frictions have emerged in the last few months when we've started to discuss the future. Indian F is keen to preserve her heritage in her future family. She's happy to live in UK for the time-being, although wants significant milestones (e.g. pregnancy/childbirth) to be in India, as well as her kids to experience Indian schooling for a few years. English M said he would be reluctant for to disrupt kids' education for things like this. Indian F also worries that English M isn't particularly close to her family, especially how close she is to his - she sees them quite often.

Indian F is also keen to retire in India in order to manage a family business she'll eventually inherit. Clearly this is a long way away, but English M wants to stay in UK & doesn't want to move to India due to work reasons, being away from family and difficulty integrating with culture.

Is anyone being unreasonable here or is it just a tricky situation? Are there any other multicultural couples out there who've faced similar challenges? Do you have any advice on what to do? Is it resolvable? Thank you!

OP posts:
ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 09/04/2024 18:53

It's not going to work.

The lady in this relationship met this man because she is in the UK.

The man was probably happy with life in the UK as he didn't leave.

That's always the risk that the partner from overseas will want to return and the other will never want to leave.

Neither are wrong. It's just incompatibility.

Purplecatshopaholic · 09/04/2024 19:00

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 09/04/2024 18:53

It's not going to work.

The lady in this relationship met this man because she is in the UK.

The man was probably happy with life in the UK as he didn't leave.

That's always the risk that the partner from overseas will want to return and the other will never want to leave.

Neither are wrong. It's just incompatibility.

This. Dont stay together. And defo don’t have kids! This isn’t going to work long term.

tarheelbaby · 09/04/2024 19:01

Agree with pp's that this is a v. complicated scenario and seems like it cannot succeed.
Also agree that there is a huge expectation on English M. He seems reasonable but he is not in a relationship with you because he wanted a British-Indian alliance.
I married an English M and moved to England. But ... I am a native English speaker and knew some of what to expect. All the same, moving to UK was tough. I love 'foreigners' and was v. happy to be in a mixed culture relationship but I would find moving to India daunting: distance, language, culture.
Having moved to my DH's country and experienced not having my family around me, I would never ask him to do the same.
Also, have you looked into rules about children's nationality/citizenship. Many English + other culture couples I know made sure to have the baby born in UK to give it full UK citizenship.

howrudeforme · 09/04/2024 19:07

Don’t think you’re compatible.

i have Indian mother and English father and I’m old. The fact you’re even having this debate in your head tells me you shouldn’t be in a mixed relationship and your children would be conflicted.

he didn’t meet most of your family due to cultural traditions? Are you ashamed of him not being Indian? Or are your family racist?

meet someone who won’t make you challenge/compromise your heritage. Much easier.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page