Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mothers preference of SIL

59 replies

CarrotsPlease · 18/08/2023 15:41

A little background first, I have one brother we are both in our 40s he is older. Our lives have been very different, I’ve been with my DH for 22 years, married 16, 2 kids, 12 and 10. Ive worked my whole life as has my DH, my parents helped us fund Indy schools for our kids.
My brother has been in and and out of relationships most of his life, generally he never wanted to commit, as soon as the moving in/marriage convo came up he was out the door quicker than you could say boo. Until he met his now wife, he was 40 she is 20 years younger. He went from mr ew not marriage to engaged in 18 months, married 18 months after that and his wife was pregnant with twins soon after. They’ve been together 8 years now. She is a stay at home mum, he makes a ridiculous amount each year.
My mother is quite shallow, thinks looks and money are the be all and end all. I never met up to her wishes for a daughter, I’m not conventionally attractive, could really give two hoots about make-up and clothes and was thrilled to have two boys who would rather be out with the dogs in the forest than anything else. I earn a good amount as does my DH but my brother alone earns more than us combined. I’d say we try to live a modest life, I can’t be bothered with anything flashy.
On the flip, my SIL is young, very attractive, blonde (this is a big thing for my mother she seems to think blondes are the most beautiful people on earth), always well groomed (frankly why wouldn’t she be, she’s a SAHM, kids in nursery/school, they have a cleaner etc.), hair and nails always done, you get the picture, she’s a bit of a ‘Range Rover mummy’.
My mother is obsessed with my SIL, they meet up for lunch once a week, she’s forever telling people how beautiful her daughter in law and granddaughters are (two blonde little girls, just what my mother always wanted). I take my mother shopping once a week and it is all I hear, SIL this and SIL that. She hardly asks about my boys now, frankly they don’t fit her image. She is on my back about me not putting the effort in, buying ‘cheap’ clothes (M&S).
My DH thinks I should ignore it, she’s probably just happy my brother has settled down, but they have been married 5 years!
I know that in reality she’s finally got the daughter and granddaughters she always wanted, and can’t help the excitement but it is beginning to cause me some upset. I feel resentful that my mother has a better relationship with SIL than me and seems to care about my nieces more than my son.
I want to say something but I don’t know how to go about it without causing a fall out. WIBU to bring it up to her? What should I say?

OP posts:
continentallentil · 18/08/2023 19:31

CarrotsPlease · 18/08/2023 15:51

I think he is pretentious and shallow in all honesty but that isn’t the point is it.

It IS quite a lot of the point OP.

You think your mother, brother and SIL are pretentious and shallow.

You don’t like them. It may well be true they don’t much like you. Or maybe they just find you as bewildering as you find them.

Given your mum has funded your children’s private education and you meet for lunch once a week she clearly loves you and has SOME reasonable amount of interest in you and the kids, but probably prefers to spend time with your SIL because they have more in common.

It’s not nice to be the different one in a family, but given your feelings about them I don’t think they are deliberately hurting your feelings, you are just very different people.

i wouldn’t bring it up in a big way - I think it might get explosive and frankly if you’re relying on your mum for school fees that wouldn’t be wise. You can start arriving at lunch with news to share and bluntly steer he back to you and the boys when she diverts to your SIL.

It sounds like there are some childhood hurts at play here so investigate that if you need to. Otherwise try and appreciate what you have - two good jobs, two healthy kids and parents who help with school fees - and build up your life outside of your immediate family of people who get you.

SmellsLikeTeenSpirits · 18/08/2023 19:33

What would you say though? And to what end? Your DM loves you but likes your SIL more because they are more aligned. Are you happy with your DH and DS and your life/style? That's enough.

applesandmares · 18/08/2023 19:37

Honestly it just sounds like you value different things to your mother and brother so it's no wonder that they click in a way that you might not. Instead of being accepting of each other, it sounds like you judge each other. Hardly a great foundation for a loving relationship. Neither of you are right or wrong, you're just different!

If you want to improve the relationship with your mum maybe find something you can do/talk about that is mutually interesting? I think you need to focus on your relationship with her, rather than her relationship with everyone else.

HamBone · 18/08/2023 19:55

nillionaire · 18/08/2023 18:48

I have a 20-year old dd. I’d be horrified if she met a 40-year old man who would want to go out with someone that young tbh.

Yes, it’s off topic, but I’d also find it grim if DD (18) started seeing a 40-year-old in a couple of years.

Honeychickpea · 18/08/2023 20:02

HamBone · 18/08/2023 19:55

Yes, it’s off topic, but I’d also find it grim if DD (18) started seeing a 40-year-old in a couple of years.

It's simply the age old trade of youth and beauty for money and an easy life. I don't judge for it, to each their own.

HamBone · 18/08/2023 20:10

Honeychickpea · 18/08/2023 20:02

It's simply the age old trade of youth and beauty for money and an easy life. I don't judge for it, to each their own.

Yes, I know, @Honeychickpea , it’s the lack of life experience that bothers me when someone’s just out of their teens. 30 and 50, fine.

ChristmasCrumpet · 18/08/2023 20:27

GrumpyPanda · 18/08/2023 17:59

I don't get the pile-on on OP going on in this thread. What really stood out to me was how her mother and SIL regularly play ladies who lunch together, yet OP's the one who gets asked to take her shopping. Smacks of favouritism.

Yeah, she only pays £30k for OP's kids to go to school. She eats a lunch once a week with the other one.

And OP that should even be asked, let alone actually have to help her own mother shopping once a week whilst receiving the £30k for her kids schooling that's she's obviously merely entitled too? Appalling for OP. What favouritism to her lunch partner.

Backmarkermoth · 22/08/2023 00:41

Your mother needs a serious word to. If she raises the topic of SIL again tell her to shut it and that you're sick to death of being inundated with how wonderful she is. Tell her that's all she talks about, her, her daughters and their supposed magnificence. Thank her for having no interest in her or her grandsons then walk off and stop going to lunch. Family is not the be all and end all. Make yourself busy. And don't go to family do's. Pull out of everything. She no doubt talks about you behind your back if she's sprouting how wonderful the SIL is if she doesn't give you and sons much chop. So give up. I would. I did on other fronts. Rarely go to things. Never regretted it at all. You won't either. She will though. Let your sons know the truth as well.

Honeychickpea · 22/08/2023 00:47

Backmarkermoth · 22/08/2023 00:41

Your mother needs a serious word to. If she raises the topic of SIL again tell her to shut it and that you're sick to death of being inundated with how wonderful she is. Tell her that's all she talks about, her, her daughters and their supposed magnificence. Thank her for having no interest in her or her grandsons then walk off and stop going to lunch. Family is not the be all and end all. Make yourself busy. And don't go to family do's. Pull out of everything. She no doubt talks about you behind your back if she's sprouting how wonderful the SIL is if she doesn't give you and sons much chop. So give up. I would. I did on other fronts. Rarely go to things. Never regretted it at all. You won't either. She will though. Let your sons know the truth as well.

And pay your own private school fees. That will show her!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread