Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to separate twin DC (5) in school after Easter?

53 replies

Ontheperiphery79 · 25/03/2023 08:59

My twins (5) are in YR in the same small class (only one class per year) in a lovely, but small school.
I've often regretted starting them together, as Twin 2 really clings to Twin 1, despite trying to support Twin 2 to give Twin 1 space and for Twin 1 to be able to tell Twin 2 when she needs space. Both are ND, as am I, so they both have different needs and communication differences/difficulties.
It's become increasingly apparent just how much Twin 1 dislikes being with Twin 2, and how much Twin 2 feels they 'need' Twin 1.
They have a close bond, but we have had a long, difficult few years, which has had wide ranging effects on them, so I am loathe to cause either further 'trauma', but it's really impacting their relationship and spending too much time together is making home feel like increasingly like a war zone.
A school across town has space for Twin 2 after Easter and it's a MUCH better fit for her. Their current school is perfect for Twin 1. No school has space for both in separate classes and there are extensive waiting lists within this area,
AIBVU to move Twin 2 after Easter, when I know that in the short term, it could cause her a lot of stress? Twin 1 is delighted by any thought of not being with Twin 2 in class (although they do not yet know this is a distinct possibility), although she loves Twin 2 to pieces and has said before how she'd like to just be with her during non-school time.
I've had really strong opposing views with the twins' father (who sees them 1 weekend a month and has never be involved in nor interested in their education and from the lady who is to all intents and purposes my Mum (we speak daily, but we haven’t actually seen her for 2 years). Really strong, negative views! Other friends and our network have been fully supportive.
Would really welcome thoughts and perspectives, even from non twin parents or those with NT DC.
And, any suggestions around how to best support both twins (but especially Twin 2) through this transition.

OP posts:
Oodieandacuppatonightplease · 25/03/2023 19:05

I think Tamba recommend twins are kept together for the reception year, as separation can be traumatic, but you are close to the end of this academic year. Might be worth contacting them to see if they have experience of these difficulties, in part with nd twins. Good luck and hope tonight isn’t sleep deprived.

itsjustnotok · 25/03/2023 19:16

OP if you can make it work logistically then do it. It’s not fair on your twins if one is having to be more responsible for the other, particularly if it’s causing issues. You have the opportunity to give them a chance to be individuals in their own right. It may well not be the easiest of times while everyone adjusts but ultimately it sounds like something needs to change.

Ontheperiphery79 · 25/03/2023 20:25

@Choconut, thanks for your ideas around how to frame it with her.
I'm really worn down at the moment, so didn't explain myself. I haven't and wouldn't say her that I'm trying to support them by separating. I've gently planted the seed that a space has come up in a school that has more play space, outdoor time, time to do more of the stuff she enjoys (not even a white lie, as there is a more activities based pathway she will start on!
So, she knows a teacher is inviting her to have a play with some chidren on Monday and we'll have some time together without Twin 1 being around.
She does already feel that there is something intrinsically wrong with her, as she has said her friends at school don't lash out and get 'fizzy' like she does and she knows from experience how upset and angry Twin 1 gets when she (Twin 2) won't leave her alone.
Her new school actively support an EHCP assessment or similar asap and are open to working with me and my knowledge/experience.
I'm not going in with false hope or expectations and all I can do is know I've poured my heart and soul into exploring options and there is no win-win scenario.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page