Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find it ridiculous how only now is my opinion received without being accused of jealousy

54 replies

HelloBambinos · 08/10/2022 09:23

After seeing a thread regarding the ideal gender of your DC and people's perception it got me thinking.

Why am I suddenly allowed an opinion just because I've now had a daughter...My opinion has never changed and I feel strongly about it so why is it seen differently now despite my previous protests.

I have two wonderful sons (aged 7&4) and of course people just loved saying the whole "Oh I'm (as in them) lucky because I have both genders" even through pregnancy and when my youngest son was first born I got "Oh how disappointing" and "I feel sorry for you but it's not your fault you had a second son, some are just more lucky than others" Seriously!? This caused a lot of upset and felt like people were trying to force gender disappointment on me. These comments were made by many different people so not just a one off, it was constant and became exhausting. I've always been very much of the mindset that I adored my boys, loved having two sons and felt incredibly lucky. We were ecstatic, my husband always wanted a brother and it was amazing but people never believed I could possibly be happy about it...they just gave that pitying look like I was just trying to put on a brave face and even said as much "Well you HAVE to say that" like I was inferior and just making the best of it. It frustrated the hell out of me and still does. I accepted their subjective perception of luck but somehow I wasn't allowed to be happy or consider myself lucky!? It's not about caring what they think, it was more exhausting and something I definitely could have done without especially as I was suffering with HG throughout the entire pregnancy. I could never even have an opinion that I felt lucky and was happy with my boys without being shut down and met with "Oh you're just saying that because you're jealous" and "You just don't understand because you aren't as lucky to have both genders" It was just crazy talk.

However, all of a sudden, now I had my daughter 7 months ago I suddenly am allowed to have that opinion without having nasty digs being made at me and being called jealous. Now it's suddenly obvious that each child and situation is different and feeling 'lucky' is subjective. Now my boys being close in age is understood as my version of 'lucky' and that's okay...now...Why is it only now i'm believed when I've stated I feel very lucky that I have my wonderful boys close in age all along!? Of course I love my daughter beyond belief as well but it's the whole response to myself feeling lucky about my boys that has suddenly changed... ridiculous.

Has anyone else experienced this? I just find it very odd how people react now when I say that as opposed to how they did prior to my daughter's birth.

OP posts:
HelloBambinos · 08/10/2022 20:59

Darbs76 · 08/10/2022 20:02

I had 2 sons first (then a DD) and I definitely got those comments and I know many who did too from being on certain forums. People really should keep any comments about sex of babies to themselves, either way, whether mum is happy or wanting two of same gender or whether she’s upset about it. Comments don’t help at all

Absolutely agree. I've never made a comment to any parent ever about what the sex of their child is because that doesn't determine who they are, I just say 'how lovely' because it is! Also I knew exactly how these comments felt when people said ridiculous things about my baby and how I apparently 'needed' the opposite sex. When in fact I just needed my baby to be healthy and I love having them but for some reason it's only now my happiness is accepted as genuine and that's awful. I'm not so ignorant to believe that GD doesn't exist for some but I don't judge them, that's their feelings and their journey and it's not for anyone else to force it further upon them with ignorant comments.

OP posts:
saturdaymorningbored · 08/10/2022 21:36

HighlandPony · 08/10/2022 09:39

Because as a woman we’re supposed to be all “girls are wonderful an lovely and nice etc etc etc and aren’t boys a handful” because that’s how most women see the world but actually there’s plenty women out there who don’t mind the handful, who like the mess and the shite jokes and fart noises and general chaos but can’t stand the overly emotional huff that comes with girls. Have zero interest in celeb culture or fashion or YouTube sodding makeup tutorials.

I’d have had ten boys if I could. Really hoping my lass will be a mini me and like the boys.

Jesus, not generalising much there.
This attitude is why the op gets the comments she is getting

Branleuse · 08/10/2022 21:40

I strongly relate. I had 2 boys and a girl and I remember feeling like everyone was acting as if boys were some sort of booby prize

HelloBambinos · 08/10/2022 21:54

Branleuse · 08/10/2022 21:40

I strongly relate. I had 2 boys and a girl and I remember feeling like everyone was acting as if boys were some sort of booby prize

Yep! It drives me crazy, I actually became very protective of my youngest son, I had awful PPD after I gave birth to him thinking something was going to happen to him that I had let him down and wasn't a good mother and comments from people saying how disappointed they were for me certainly didn't help even a 'friend' who knew I was suffering with PPD and the horrible comments people had made decided to join in as she had just had a scan confirming her second child was the opposite sex of her first and told me that "Its not your fault you had a boy again, I'm just lucky I can experience both genders, it's a different kind of love, you wouldn't understand" (I'm quoting her exactly) He was my perfect, beautiful baby and it hurt that he was put into a box based on what was between his legs and not celebrated as much...in laws didn't even bother coming to meet him...they finally met him when he was 2 years old 😥

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page