For one more perspective (anecdata for the win!) here’s a conversation I had a few years ago with my DF, who is the head of a very large organization and is quite passionate about supporting mothers in the workplace (on far more occasions than just this).
DF: crazy day… I had FOUR interviews for the new VP position
Me: wait, didn’t you just hire a new VP?
DF: yes, but she’s pregnant. I need someone who can take over from her in a few months
Me: ouch, that must be frustrating
DF: I mean, the interviewing component is, but I’m very happy in general
Me: are you?
DF: yes, of course! A baby is always lovely news. This is her first, so it’s just so exciting.
She told me she felt terrible leaving us in the lurch, but honestly, this has happened on my teams a number of times before and it doesn’t upset me one bit. What I’ve noticed is that, on the whole, this sort of situation is entirely positive. Ive found that women who come back from Mat Leave having felt fully supported during their pregnancy and leave are happier, more productive, and easier to retain long-term than the average employee, frankly. They have a lot going on at home, so they tend to be ruthless in their prioritization at work, which is a terrific skill. And at least stereotypically, women with young children tend to choose to “stay put” in roles for longer than some of their peers who career-hop every 2-4 years. I’ve seen young mothers build incredible things over the longer tenures they’ve held in their positions - there can be more of a “builder’s mindset” and great long-term thinking.
Mat leave cover is not a giant investment to make for someone who ultimately is likely to be a highly effective long-term employee. A woman who is pregnant now signals to me that she’s planning on being in the role at least long enough to not have to repay her mat Leave top-up, which is not a reassurance I can ever get from the average new employee! And realistically, what difference does it make to me NOW finding cover for her than if she chose to wait a year or two? Arranging cover is arranging cover, any way you cut it. I’ve gone back to a few earlier-round candidates from when I was hiring her. It’s actually rather convenient, in a funny way.
In any event, I obviously didn’t tell her all that, but I could tell her with complete honesty that I was thrilled for her, and not to feel guilty about it for even a second.