Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil moving an hour away!

60 replies

Username3092997 · 23/01/2022 17:01

Mil is planning to move just over an hour away to a different area (38 miles ish on crappy a&b roads). The area is slightly cheaper and she wants to free up some £££ selling her house and also to be closer to to her partners place of work which is a bit mad in itself as he's been doing the same job for years and he's close to retirement age now. He drives for a living, so it's just close to his depot so to me makes little difference as he's often in Scotland hundreds of miles away. Entirely their choice of course. I wish them well.

But she's expecting us to visit all the time, I just don't think we can go every week or two like she expects. Why can't she come here?! We could visit maybe once a month. She thinks we will love to visit all the time as it's a nice area but so is the area we live!

I appreciate many families live much further than an hour away and an hour doesn't seem that far but we aren't used to it. Currently she lives 10 minutes away. We don't see them more than once a week now, she and her partner work full time, dp works long hours, I am a sahp/carer to both children who have sen and have busy lifestyles. We don't see her that much really. . Maybe once every 1-2 weeks. Sometimes dc will go their for dinner after school. Often Dp will pop in to see her after work for a cuppa as she lives just down the road from his place of work, I think he will struggle with that more than anything. We don't rely on her for anything like childcare etc so her move isn't going to cause us any issues like that.

After a conversation today, she's fully expecting us to visit every week. Aibu to think hell no? We don't always see her every week now.

I just don't think it will work. Dp works Monday - Saturday. That only leaves sundays. Do we want to travel 2 hours on a Sunday plus a couple hours there? I'm not sure I do! Sunday is our only day as a family. Living close by we can see her during the week after school or on a Sunday for an hour (not every Sunday). I just don't think We can commit.

Dp doesn't want to do it either. He doesn't want to be travelling for 2 hours out of county on his only day off!! I don't really like driving.

Plus both dc both have sen. Sometimes even the shortest journeys are stressful! They need frequent stops etc. We really don't travel far as a family and tend to stay local.

Our lives are pretty local. My family live 15 miles away and we don't even get chance to see them much!! Once a month max usually!

Aibu to think that she can't move and expect us to still see her all the time? She could come here? Or will have to be once every month or so?

I just don't think I'll look forward to sundays if I feel like we have to get up and travel! Dp can't take the kids alone due to their sen, neither of us would manage a long trip like that with them on our own. 10 minutes max we are alone with them 😅 so we would all have to go!!

How often do you visit your relatives who live quite far away?!

OP posts:
SecretKeeper1 · 23/01/2022 19:20

All our parents live an hour away and we see them on average every 6 weeks or so. Combination of us going there, them coming here, meeting half way for lunch or a walk/cafe.

Absolutely not a chance I’d go every week, especially if it’s your only free day as a family. Monthly is fine, they can visit you in between.

Do you have other things to do on Sundays? As in “sorry can’t do next week as we have visitors / going shopping / meal out with friends” etc etc

Nsky · 23/01/2022 19:20

My youngest son lives 20 mins away, tho chooses not see me,melded son 2 hrs away.
Brothers, Spain ,Italy and Lincoln so south east for me.
Trains or planes for me, and I hate motorways

MogsBestestFurball · 23/01/2022 19:28

Be honest with her now before she commits financially to a move, just tell her you are concerned her ideas about the amount you will visit are unrealistic - no need to explain why.

We had a similar situation with an older relative becoming very bitter that she did not have enough visits to her lovely house in the country that was a 3 hour drive. She was long retired and had no concept of how unrealistic it was for us to have long visits every weekend.

Knittedfairies · 23/01/2022 19:51

Visit her - or not - on your terms. If you do go monthly, don't always go on the second Sunday or whatever, because it would hard to change that - mix it up.

percypigwig · 23/01/2022 19:57

My PIL now live best part of 5 hours away, moving to be closer to BIL and his family. They expect us to visit most holidays-Easter, Christmas, summer hols. Expect us to put one of our dogs in kennels at our expense. Well not anymore! We've had a bit of a falling out with twat of a BIL and his wife acting like a spoilt princess. They owe us £100s, calling us favourites of PIL (not true by any stretch of the imagination!), not contacting DH when he was unwell... I could go on. We've helped them quite a lot and it hurts. PIL pander to them, always have enabled them and we are sick of it. So we won't be venturing to see any of them anytime soon...needed to get that off my chest!

andweallsingalong · 23/01/2022 20:13

@Chocolateis1ofyour5aday

If she's moving an hour away and her DP is away 3 or 4 nights a week she'll be on her own a lot. Maybe that's why she's suggesting you visit weekly? Is she saying that to all her own DCs? You should show her your current schedule and how the weekly travelling doesn't work for your family and reset her expectations before she puts her house on the market and regrets the move!
Agree with this YANBU, but I feel you have to be very blunt with her that you will not be visiting on Sundays, at all. Its your one family day and time as a nuclear family is essential. The kids won't cope with all the driving so she needs to come to you.

Yes, it will be hard for her to hear, but she needs to take off the rose coloured specs and make the right decision for her before she's taken any big steps.

ivykaty44 · 23/01/2022 20:13

just keep saying

when you visit us, after you move

if she queries this in any way - well we won't have time to do 2 hour round trip of an evening, thinly day would be Sunday with dh working 6 days a week, I doubt we will get to you much more than xmas or easter

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 23/01/2022 20:27

Massively overthinking. Just go when kg suits you, she hasn’t even moved yet. Calm down.

Totalwasteofpaper · 23/01/2022 20:35

@NumberTheory

Agree with Aquamarine. You sound a bit over involved in the whole process. Just say “MiL, there’s no way we’ll be getting in the car with DCs to drive all that way that often. We’re going to really miss you but if you think it’s a better place for you to live, I think it’s great you have the opportunity to move there.”

Don’t make promises about how often (frankly even once a month with 2 DCs who don’t travel well and only one day of family time a week sounds too much). Just say, “We’ll have to see how it goes, but you know we don’t have much family time and the kids don’t travel well, so it won’t be often.”

It’s her choice to move. Let her make it. It’s your choice how often you visit. Don’t be emotionally blackmailed into going when you don’t want to.

Agree that you can't dictate where she loves but you do not need to be crystal clear.

This post gives solid advice. I would commit to nothing and make it clear things will change and she will need to travel if she wants to see you. Then stop and leave her to it

Totalwasteofpaper · 23/01/2022 20:36

🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

*Agree that you can't dictate where she lives but you do need to be crystal clear.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page