Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Husband hit me because what I said about his mum

170 replies

Amiinthewrong23 · 10/11/2021 17:02

I have really be struggling mentally at the moment,I have severe depression and anxiety and I have 2 young kids. I have been trying to get my husband to listen to me for days,my husband is a born Pakistani and he just doesn’t understand mental health at all. I was crying to him for over 1hour this morning and I thought I’d finally got through to him, he said he would change his habits etc and spend more time with me and the kids. He said this afternoon he would come home to spend time with us,he came home after I picked the kids up from school and he just got into bed and started watching cricket. Because of how his mum taught him,his mum always fed them chapati and curry when they got home from school.. I don’t,because if I feed my kids that when they get home from school they won’t eat their dinner, they always ask for something like a cheese sandwich which I give them as soon as they get home along with a piece of fruit, I have tried giving them chapati and curry before when we have got home from school but they don’t want to wait for me to cook the chapatis,as my daughter has a Quran class which literally starts a few minutes after we get home so it’s physically not possible because the teacher can only teach her at that time, as well as the sand which they also stay in their uniform until after my daughter has finished her class ( as I physically just don’t have enough time to get them both changed in between picking them up from school, getting them home and my daughters class) my husband knows all this, yet when his mum who lives in Pakistan video called at this time, she asked my husband and my son why he was eating a sandwich,she told my husband that I should be feeding them chapati and curry not sandwiches, that I should give them proper food as soon as I get them home. She also then went on to ask my son why he was still in his uniform, why mummy hasn’t changed him yet. My husband just sat there and let her say all this, when he knows my situation. After he ended the video call with her I got upset because he went back to work, and he’d just spent all that time he promised to sit down and talk to me and spend time with us watching cricket and talking to his mum. I asked him why he did this and he shouted at me and told me that I am “ making the environment in this house horrible and to sort myself out, give me time give me time, what give me time? Look after your kids, feed them, get them changed” I said “ so now once again you’ve heard your mum say all this you are telling me I should look after my kids, when you know why they eat what they do and why they aren’t changed yet” I then went on to tell him, as he has applied for his mums visit visa “ i know as soon as your mum gets here that this is my life, being told I am a bad mum, so this, do this, constantly without being able to say anything to her” and he went on to hit me repeatedly. He then went out the door and went back to work.

I don’t understand what I’ve done so wrong, I do everything for this man, everything for my kids. I am struggling mentality waiting for my prescription of antidepressants and he let his mum sit their and say what she did and said nothing to her and didn’t put her in her place, let her walk on me when I am already down and then even worse he went against me and told me I should be looking after my kids.

I am sorry for the long post, but aibu ? Did I say the wrong thing about his mum? This is constant, with anything I do if she says something,that’s how it is and I’m not allowed to say anything.

OP posts:
Thehouseofmarvels · 10/11/2021 22:42

@DroopyClemetis you can private message ! My family is very happy and stable so I do try to learn about disfunctional family stuff from Mumsnet in order to better support my other half. So always useful to talk.

MoveAhoy · 10/11/2021 23:03

There is no magic pill to guarantee the violence doesn't happen again.
No amount of understanding what you did wrong will ensure this will never happen again.

The violence spiral has begun. You can stop it by walking away or you can perpetuate it by trying to maintain the peace to save your marriage.

It's easy from the sidelines to see that these are your only options. When you are in the thick of it, there's always a glimmer of hope of another way.

Hopefully the façade falls away quickly so that you can make an informed choice eventually. Good luck.

Imaybeacat · 10/11/2021 23:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Thomasina79 · 10/11/2021 23:23

You poor love. If you can write here and treat it as a safe place to vent your feelings and for support and advice, that would be good.

You deserve so much more than this bully x

Boredoutmymind · 11/11/2021 00:58

This is ABUSE.
In his culture it is ok for husband to hit wife and kids. Please leave ASAP with your kids. As he will do this again.
There are many charities that can help.

Also be cautious when talking to the muslim community or mosque as word spreads fast and they will tell him. Or they may try to get you to stay with him.

I have heard bad stories about this and seen it first hand within the muslim community. Please take everyones advise and leave ASAP.
Take important documents/medicines with you.

Report to police and to GP.

Contact the council domestic helpline, apply for housing with the council.

urbanbuddha · 11/11/2021 01:12

You are the victim of domestic abuse.

Contact
Women's Aid for advice.

Refuge have a Freephone 24 hour National Domestic Abuse Helpline: 0808 2000 247.

You need to leave. It will escalate.

CaptainMyCaptain · 11/11/2021 07:16

@Boredoutmymind

This is ABUSE. In his culture it is ok for husband to hit wife and kids. Please leave ASAP with your kids. As he will do this again. There are many charities that can help.

Also be cautious when talking to the muslim community or mosque as word spreads fast and they will tell him. Or they may try to get you to stay with him.

I have heard bad stories about this and seen it first hand within the muslim community. Please take everyones advise and leave ASAP.
Take important documents/medicines with you.

Report to police and to GP.

Contact the council domestic helpline, apply for housing with the council.

There have been several women of Pakistani origin on this thread who have said it is not OK for him to hit her in their culture. They also agreed that the OP should leave her husband.
LadyMaid · 11/11/2021 08:03

So he basically was expecting to replace his mum with you.

Get out of there before his abuse extends to the kids.

LadyMaid · 11/11/2021 08:06

@Boredoutmymind

This is ABUSE. In his culture it is ok for husband to hit wife and kids. Please leave ASAP with your kids. As he will do this again. There are many charities that can help.

Also be cautious when talking to the muslim community or mosque as word spreads fast and they will tell him. Or they may try to get you to stay with him.

I have heard bad stories about this and seen it first hand within the muslim community. Please take everyones advise and leave ASAP.
Take important documents/medicines with you.

Report to police and to GP.

Contact the council domestic helpline, apply for housing with the council.

No it is not OK in Pakistani culture to hit your wife and kids.

Or any culture.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 11/11/2021 08:34

You didn't do anything wrong whatsoever. Nothing that you have done justifies his behaviour.

Can you contact Women's Aid or similar? I don't know what your heritage is but there are some resources listed here

www.britishpakistanfoundation.com/resources/resources-for-women/

LakieLady · 11/11/2021 08:43

I really hope you and the children are somewhere safe now, OP.

Spidey66 · 11/11/2021 08:51

The OP hasn't come back.....i really hope she is ok.

Scirocco · 11/11/2021 12:51

@Boredoutmymind

This is ABUSE. In his culture it is ok for husband to hit wife and kids. Please leave ASAP with your kids. As he will do this again. There are many charities that can help.

Also be cautious when talking to the muslim community or mosque as word spreads fast and they will tell him. Or they may try to get you to stay with him.

I have heard bad stories about this and seen it first hand within the muslim community. Please take everyones advise and leave ASAP.
Take important documents/medicines with you.

Report to police and to GP.

Contact the council domestic helpline, apply for housing with the council.

Islam absolutely does NOT consider it acceptable for domestic abuse to take place. Some people may be brought up in cultures which condone unacceptable behaviour, misogyny and abuse, but these have no place in Islam. Regardless of a person's culture of origin, if they consider themselves a practising Muslim then they should condemn these things.

There are many Islamic organisations available to support people experiencing abuse. Like any community, it's important to seek help from the right people. Some people in a community might not understand abuse, or might apply their own cultural or personal biases - it's still common for people from many backgrounds to think a person should give an abuser another chance, to not understand that violence within a relationship is wrong, or to prioritise staying together "for the kids", etc. This isn't a problem with Islam, it's a problem with people.

lentilsforever · 11/11/2021 15:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

BashfulClam · 11/11/2021 16:03

Leave please. He will do it again and your kids will see it. Do you want your son and daughter to think it is ok for a partner to be abusive? He may start on them. If you calm the police you can be somewhere safe by tonight.

LadyMaid · 11/11/2021 16:15

@lentilsforever

It’s one thing to say that the word of Islam does not permit this

It’s another re what goes on in reality within that culture

Islam isn't a culture. It is a religion.
lentilsforever · 11/11/2021 16:24

Exactly so those saying Islam teaches xyz

There’s no escaping that the culture of those that follow Islam is one where this kind of situation is unusual

frazzledasarock · 11/11/2021 17:26

There are abusive men in all cultures and religions. Just take a read of the relationships section on MN.

The Mufti who conducted my marriage ceremony immediately granted me a divorce and told me to keep my bride gift as ex was abusive. He advised my parents to ensure I got a legal divorce and exhorted them to take care of me and my children and treat me with love and kindness.
He insisted there not be any attempt at reconciliation as ex was violent and having heard about the abuse he was sure I would be at risk of significant harm.

He over rode my mother cultural practices. She had no come back after he said that.
And also my uncles and extended family were all horrified and furious I had been harmed by ex.

It is not Islamic.

Male violence is worldwide problem.

Scirocco · 11/11/2021 18:28

@lentilsforever

Religion and culture are not the same. There is no single culture of people who follow Islam, any more than there is a single culture of people who follow Christianity.

Regardless of this man's background and upbringing and culture of origin, his actions here are abhorrent and contrary to Islamic values and teaching.

urbanbuddha · 11/11/2021 20:07

It's got nothing to do with Islam.
Domestic abuse is misogynistic, not cultural or religious.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page