Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep my wedding secret

76 replies

ItsAllAboutTheParsley · 23/04/2021 23:44

I’m in my 50s and have been with DP for a year. He comes from a large close extended family, I have a small family but we are pretty close.

My issue is - we are getting married in August, first time for both of us. Registry office booked, me, my best friend, him, his brother. That’s it. Lunch booked afterwards, nothing else. We want to be married, not have a big day. It’s just the minimum legal event needed, it is what we want.

His family are mostly in another country and so we thought we’d have a blessing and party there when we can, so my close friends/rellies (10 probably) can come (it’s Europe, cheap flights etc) and all of his (50+) can be there but because of international travel issues we can’t commit to a date.

We don’t want to wait til whenever we can travel to get married but neither do we want this to turn into a big drama and god I know it will.

My mum is sliding into dementia and by Aug may not know who I am, his DPs will want to run the whole thing, my DSis will have ‘opinions’ and expect to be a MoH, etc etc. He’s not dead keen on the religious side of it all and his DM in particular will want all the bells and smells.

So we’re just going to do it, then tell them about the blessing etc and make that the ‘wedding’ they can all have their tuppence worth about. We’ve decided what we want for that and planned most of it, so we’re in a difficult position of some people knowing, but our parents, my siblings etc not.

I’ve had a huge amount of stress over my mum’s health, she’s had cancer then this confusion so every time I think I’ll just tell her she goes off into a delusion. It’s relentless and she can’t cope with change so I’ve not wanted to start talking about how I want to get married at this point in my life especially as she’s got a bit disinhibited and fancies my DP. A very vocal lot. My DSis hasn’t been able to be much practical help but has opinions on what’s to be done for her, as does my aunt - everyone’s a backseat driver.

DP’s had a lot of family drama over a relative and his business, his DM’s low opinion of me, his relocation and career changes and again, everyone’s got a view which they are determined to share - whilst leaving him to do the heavy lifting.

Are we being unreasonable to just want to get married and not worry about mum, my interfering family and his interfering family being there and just have this day for us? I’d rather deal with the fall out after rather than before. Is that fair?

OP posts:
Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 05:50

That’s a fair point

Gumbo · 24/04/2021 05:56

I voted YANBU because we eloped and it's somehing I've never regretted.

However... we only invited the neighbours to be witnesses the night before, no family at all and we didn't tell anyone else beforehand. I think by your DP inviting a brother you're opening a can of worms. If you're not going to invite family I think that's absolutely fine, but be careful of selectively only inviting one or two or it'll cause massive resentment. (We offended the whole lot all at once, so at least there were no bad feelings or jealousy Grin

Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 06:00

I don’t think it’s so much about the inviting as the hiding it

MyOtherProfile · 24/04/2021 06:01

Two people have commented asking why you want to get married so quickly. Do people really think a year is quick? I don't.

Anyway I would do it but I would let everyone know you were just doing the legal part very low key and will have the big wedding party once covid makes it all easier. Lots of people have done that this past year because they couldn't have the wedding they wanted. They're not to know that you ARE having the wedding you want with just you four!

Cuntryhouse · 24/04/2021 06:07

I think especially this year it's quick, but also as you get older you may be very financially stable and obviously getting married could significantly reduce that stability. Also sometimes when there's problems with families it's because there are issues with the chosen partner. Obviously we don't know all the ins and outs, but it was just something to consider.

TableSetting · 24/04/2021 06:07

We eloped years ago and told nobody beforehand. Our families were absolutely fine with it - We told them a few hours after the wedding and they were all over the moon. We also explained that we’d booked a restaurant close to them a few weeks later for us to celebrate with the family.
It is your wedding day so do it the way you want.
In some ways Covid makes that easier.

Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 06:10

But they are including some of the family and that is likely to cause problems

starrynight21 · 24/04/2021 06:10

I wouldn't tell anyone. Telling some and not telling others is a recipe for disaster imho. If you don't want drama, tell nobody and just do it with a couple of random witnesses.

Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 06:11

This

Dozer · 24/04/2021 06:17

V sorry about your Mum.

It’s likely your sister will be very hurt about not being told / invited. She may ‘have opinions’, be rude about sharing those opinions, and want X,Y and Z, but you and DP are taking all the decisions and could inform / invite her and still do the wedding however you want. Not inviting her is likely to have consequences for your future relationship - fine if you don’t like her much, I guess!

The ‘blessing’ and party in DP’s country sounds a bad plan. If his mother dislikes you, hasn’t been good to you why pander to your DP’s parents? That sounds like the primary reason to do it.

Sounds like you could both do to work through your stance and handling with your respective families, and agree how to manage the challenges they present as a couple.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 24/04/2021 08:18

I’d be really hurt if my children excluded me from their wedding. I get it when people are NC but not otherwise.

I agree a year of dating, especially more so given the last year of lockdowns, is very quick to be contemplating vows. I can’t imagine knowing someone well enough after such a short time to make that decision.

imaginethemdragons · 24/04/2021 08:25

We did this.
Didn’t tell anyone until about a week before.
Same as you, a small group of people (about 10) we told before because they were who we love and who we wanted to be with us.
Everyone else it was the week before.

It was fantastic.
No fuss, no interference, no stress.

Registry office, a week day, then lunch then met everyone that wanted to come in the pub we had lunch in.
The registry office was packed actually, surprised us both. With a weeks notice and folk still came. Same at the pub that evening, packed.

20 years on, I don’t recall anyone falling out with us about it, if they did, it’s had zero impact on our lives!
Go for it, I highly recommend it.

sunflowertulip · 24/04/2021 08:38

@PatrickBatemann we never fell out about it or anything. I guess we are not as close as friendships evolve in different ways. I am open and honest with my very good friends and don't have big secrets, my closest friends are similar. Our conversations in the lead up felt, in retrospect, a bit deceitful.

I wouldn't have minded not going if they just wanted it to be just them and their witnesses (I would have minded not going for my sister though).

CalaminePink · 24/04/2021 08:49

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

I’d be really hurt if my children excluded me from their wedding. I get it when people are NC but not otherwise.

I agree a year of dating, especially more so given the last year of lockdowns, is very quick to be contemplating vows. I can’t imagine knowing someone well enough after such a short time to make that decision.

So, if your child actually wanted a casual wedding with two witnesses off the street, you’d think you were entitled to make him or her have a wedding they explicitly didn’t want because you wanted to attend?
Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 08:59

No... I think the comment op made was that they would be really hurt if their children excluded them from the wedding.

Nothing there about making them have the wedding they didn’t want

CalaminePink · 24/04/2021 09:02

@Jamboree01

No... I think the comment op made was that they would be really hurt if their children excluded them from the wedding.

Nothing there about making them have the wedding they didn’t want

I’m not responding to the specifics of the OP, I’m responding to those who say they’d be hurt if ‘excluded’ from their children’s weddings.

If their children want something no-fuss and casual with two security or back room staff from the register office as witnesses, then complaining about that is certainly implying you think they should have a different kind of wedding that includes you.

DDiva · 24/04/2021 09:06

I can completely see why you're doing this. Doing it this way and just saying the legal bits done and you will have a blessing / celebration at a later date sounds ideal in the situation.

I do think you have to be careful choosing a person each to attend, some close family (in particular your sister) will Im sure be hurt to not be chosen.

Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 09:08

Semantics but yes... people should have a different kind of wedding which includes parents if they have contact with them, respect them and love them.

Gatehouse77 · 24/04/2021 09:13

We didn't tell anyone about our legal marriage. I invited a friend to be my witness and she knew. DH invited his best friend but didn't tell him what or why we were meeting and he didn't twig until we walked into the registry office.

We'd previously thought about just having my mum and DH's parents but one of my brothers said he'd want to be there too and we didn't want that day to be the focus as it was purely for the legalities. (Pared down it took about 5 minutes!)

So we ditched that plan altogether. Our 'wedding' was on a different day and that was shared with everyone and the more traditional event. Neither parents were upset because the exchanging of our own vows, rings, etc. was done with them and reflected what we wanted.

Llamadramasheepface · 24/04/2021 09:13

We had a tiny wedding and only invited a small number of close friends. Wedding party was 14 including us and our DC. We didn't invite family as we both have large and rather dysfunctional families and it was just too complicated to invited some with out others. We didn't keep it a secret and it did cause some upset but they quickly got over it.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 24/04/2021 09:28

I know that my parents and DH’s parents would have been really hurt not to be included in our wedding. It’s possible to have a small wedding with just parents. I know that you have concerns over your mum’s health though Flowers

DH and I had a big wedding because that’s what we wanted. We don’t have dysfunctional families though. If people had opinions, they kept them to themselves.

CalaminePink · 24/04/2021 10:10

@Jamboree01

Semantics but yes... people should have a different kind of wedding which includes parents if they have contact with them, respect them and love them.
Nonsense. DH and I both love our parents, but we didn’t regard getting married as some huge deal, and we wanted it quick, quiet and casual, because we were about to move countries (being married smoothed the visa). Both sets of (elderly) parents were living in our home country, and would have needed to be flown in, picked up from the airport, found a hotel (we had a one-bed London flat), looked after and entertained, and both mothers, in particular, would have thought it was ‘a shame’ that we didn’t have flowers, rings, music, 200 people and me in a big white dress in a church. We love them, but really didn’t need the hassle.

And to do them justice, they’ve always been completely fine about it.

Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 10:18

Nonsense. If marriage is not a ‘big deal’ why bother?

You clearly didn’t read what I said.

Who said including parents meant flowers, rings, music and 200 people??!

Including parents means just telling them that it’s going to happen before it happens

Jamboree01 · 24/04/2021 10:23

Yes being married ‘smoothed the visa’.

Well there you go.

CalaminePink · 24/04/2021 10:33

@Jamboree01

Yes being married ‘smoothed the visa’.

Well there you go.

Im not sure why you’re getting so exercised, @Jamboree01. You may choose to think of marriage as some huge deal, while for some of us it’s purely a legal contract. I’ve been very happily with, and entirely committed to, the same man — unmarried and married — for almost 30 years, so not having a view of marriage that accords with yours isn’t actually proving detrimental to the relationship.