Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Private schools are performing better during Covid?

130 replies

Hoolieannabanana · 30/01/2021 21:26

I know private schools perform better than state schools but are they actually better just now or is there just a perception that they are as they are having more live lessons? What makes them better just now in particular?

OP posts:
HamAndButterSandwich · 31/01/2021 22:36

@AlexaShutUp lol I don't think any private schools are doing a full hour of zoom lessons. They're doing it like a normal lesson (and as lots of state schools are doing too). They explain, have some discussion then the students go and do the set work with the teacher available on the google meet/zoom if the student has questions. Work is submitted they get detailed feedback.

The problems come with some of the students I'm teaching who haven't had any interaction with teachers except via email. They watch a video then they understand it or don't if they don't they can't do the work and that subject is just lost.

BigWoollyJumpers · 31/01/2021 22:47

[quote HamAndButterSandwich]@AlexaShutUp lol I don't think any private schools are doing a full hour of zoom lessons. They're doing it like a normal lesson (and as lots of state schools are doing too). They explain, have some discussion then the students go and do the set work with the teacher available on the google meet/zoom if the student has questions. Work is submitted they get detailed feedback.

The problems come with some of the students I'm teaching who haven't had any interaction with teachers except via email. They watch a video then they understand it or don't if they don't they can't do the work and that subject is just lost.[/quote]
Of course they are. You have full lessons, on zoom, teaching and discussion. The follow on work is done as homework after school hours. Just like normal. Tutorials, form time, assemblies, all on zoom, and you have to be on camera all the time.

TheLetterZ · 01/02/2021 08:14

[quote HamAndButterSandwich]@AlexaShutUp lol I don't think any private schools are doing a full hour of zoom lessons. They're doing it like a normal lesson (and as lots of state schools are doing too). They explain, have some discussion then the students go and do the set work with the teacher available on the google meet/zoom if the student has questions. Work is submitted they get detailed feedback.

The problems come with some of the students I'm teaching who haven't had any interaction with teachers except via email. They watch a video then they understand it or don't if they don't they can't do the work and that subject is just lost.[/quote]
Quite a lot of my lessons are full on live for the whole 45 minutes (reduced from 50 to give a 10 minute break between lessons).

Starter of 5 quick questions (2 on topic 3 recall)
Worth through the lesson, watch some videos, answer questions, annotate diagrams , use breakout rooms to have class discussions).

About a quarter, possibly less, are as you describe. Normally catch up time or practise a particular skill or online quiz so I can assess where they are.

As an aside there is nothing wrong with didactic teaching, it is a useful tool along with all the others. What ofsted is looking for and what is a good lesson is not always the same thing! I can recommend The Power of Explicit Teaching and Direct Instruction, if you are interested.

notanothertakeaway · 01/02/2021 15:27

@Eleganz

Are you seriously asking what makes wealthy, well-resourced private schools better in a crisis than under-resourced state schools?

If that isn't totally obvious to you then... Wow 😳

@Eleganz

I'm happy to accept that some private schools will be performing better than typical state schools

It's the blanket assertion that all private schools are better than a typical state school that I take issue with

Frodont · 01/02/2021 17:13

It's the blanket assertion that all private schools are better than a typical state school that I take issue with
I would say most private secondaries would have performed better than secondaries in so far as they will have provided more online teaching sooner otherwise they risk losing fees

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread