Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sil issue

70 replies

ruby4ever · 18/11/2020 01:24

I've name changed for this

So my sil, dh sister. We've never been overly close, she's a very very private person, but we get along and are civil with each other. (We've been in each other's life for a decade)
I don't want to drip feed, so in the past, am talking like 3-4 years ago, we did have some issues, which actually I didn't want a big deal made out of it, but others thought her behaviour was unacceptable and called her out for it. We talked it out and everything was fine,

When I go to mils, I see her, Everything seems fine, she asks about me, what I've got up to etc, just normal chit chat.

Anyways the last time I saw her was in July. I went away for the summer, and when I came back, few day later I visited the mil house, sil was upstairs. I sent her a text saying the kids would love to see her, she replied she's coming downstairs. We were there for couple of hours, she didn't come down and then we left. I thought nothing of it, she must've just been busy, not feeling well whatever.

Anyways we tend to go to mils once a week, everytime we go, she is upstairs and doesn't come down at all the whole duration we are there, her child is downstairs. Mil will just make passing comments about what is sil doing upstairs and then ignore it.
I don't care that I haven't seen her, or she hasn't seen me, but she hasn't seen my children since July! Those kids are her brothers children, her flesh and blood. How do you after all them years of showing them affection just avoid them like they don't exist?? I don't get it.

Since that last mssg of her saying she's coming downstairs, she hasn't mssgd me or even her brother to say she missed and hopes to see us another time, or just that everytime we've come she's been busy and perhaps come on xyz day so she can see the kids, or that she will round to ours. I don't want to act desperate by trying to force her to come downstairs, interact with myself and my kids.

I was there for her in her most dire need, it's funny how people forget the good you do for them.
Am just feeling really annoyed, I keep trying to ignore the situation but everyday it pops in my head.
A few time when dh has gone on his own, she's been around, and asked him nothing about myself or the kids considering she hasn't seen us in almost 4 months, it's like we don't exist to her.

I just don't know what I could've done, everything was perfectly fine the last time I saw her, I don't post anything on social media for her to be offended by.

I really don't know what am trying to gain by posting this, am so so tired and needed to write this down, half of it probably doesn't make sense so I apologise.

OP posts:
liveitwell · 18/11/2020 17:11

I know it's frustrating when someone blows cold for no apparent reason but I'm struggling to see why you're as hurt as you are.

  • It's only been 4 months.
  • you're not close anyway
  • your kids probably don't care if you're not all that close.
  • it's unlikely to be anything personal given you've done nothing wrong. It's more likely something personal she's going through that she doesn't feel able to share.

I would send her a text, saying it's been a while since you've seen her and you hope she's doing ok. And leave it at that.

StripyTigerTail · 18/11/2020 17:13

Does she live with your MIL? Just thinking you could probably plan not to go when she's there if it's awkward. Although, that doesn't help if you want her to interact with your dcs.

Venicelover · 18/11/2020 17:15

I suspect she may have depression or anxiety. It can be crippling. I have a friend with it and she posts some very interesting and explanative stuff on FB about it. Actions such as you describe seem quite common.

I would ask MIL (very gently) and see if she can shed any light on it.

WineNotTheLabel · 18/11/2020 17:18

It sounds to me like you are the issue. It is unkind of you to expect her to be beholden to you forever.

Your SIL probably could hear you, there was no need for you to text her to come down.

I've never asked my ILs after their DC and DGC. Ever.

I have not seen a lot of my family since March!!! I am being very careful because of COVID and so probably won't see them over Christmas either.

BeanieB2020 · 18/11/2020 17:19

She lives with MIL? Perhaps she's annoyed that you and your kids are coming over to socialize indoors during a lockdown.

OneForMeToo · 18/11/2020 17:20

I don’t get why you think it’s a big issue about not seeing nieces or nephews. Maybes that’s exactly why she’s staying away because she cnba with them.

Coronawireless · 18/11/2020 17:23

It’s rude. There may be reasons but still so rude not to say hello for 5 minutes or send the odd text if she really really can’t.
I have little in common with SiLs but we are all civil and courteous for the sake of our mutual small relations.
You’re her child’s aunt and cousins and yes she does owe her child the courtesy of maintaining the most basic relationship with you.

WineNotTheLabel · 18/11/2020 17:23

This is all about you and your children. What about your flesh and blood dn. You have said you don't have a close relationship. This relationship doesn't have to be on your terms. If CIVOD rules allow, ask your MIL to visit you and leave her be

You sound like hard work.

Coronawireless · 18/11/2020 17:25

As long as you’re not calling over every 5 mins to what is her home?
Or Covid might be a reason maybe.

Hoppinggreen · 18/11/2020 17:25

I haven’t seen any of my Nieces or nephews in well over a year, I’m not too bothered

WhatKatyDidNxt · 18/11/2020 17:27

I would literally do nothing. She has the chance to see your children / her nieces + nephews but can’t be bothered. Sounds like she has poor manners and / or excessively lazy. Reminds me of my ex BIL

ecuse · 18/11/2020 17:28

Do you think it could be COVID anxiety? I would be avoiding you too, obvs whether you going round breaks the rules depends on where you live but I imagine almost anywhere people might be worried about it, but perhaps feel a bit awkay about saying and appearing to make a fuss?

Coronawireless · 18/11/2020 17:28

@Hoppinggreen

I haven’t seen any of my Nieces or nephews in well over a year, I’m not too bothered
They’re probably not bothered either. But if you have DCs it’s nice for them to know their cousins.
Mittens030869 · 18/11/2020 17:29

@Coronawireless

I agree that it’s rude. I would never completely avoid coming downstairs to greet visitors and spending a short time chatting with them before excusing myself. It’s a case of making a little effort.

I think it’s more telling that the SIL is the same with her brother. This suggests to me that it’s MH issues rather than her not liking the OP.

Why doesn’t the OP’s DH ask after his sister? He must be concerned about her.

howtobe · 18/11/2020 17:30

Ffs Mumsnet is a weird place 😂😂

Aye it’s weird OP.

Why would someone sit up stairs when your in for going on 5 months? It’s WEIRD and would definitely be considered odd behaviour in the outside world.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 18/11/2020 17:34

I don’t think this is odd in a pandemic...

ChronicallyCurious · 18/11/2020 17:36

Maybe she’s anxious about COVID? What’s stopping you going knocking on the door and saying “hey you okay”?

I think ultimately she doesn’t owe you anything and you can’t force a relationship.

Yes they are her brothers flesh and blood but I’ve found a lot of other people don’t really care about any children other children than their own. My nieces and nephews are nice but I don’t class them as my immediate family or anything, they’re just my brothers kids.

ecuse · 18/11/2020 17:37

Totally agree it would be weird in non-pandemic times.

30mph · 18/11/2020 17:52

Could she actually be mentally ill..? Is really down to your DH to ask what is going on.

Staffy1 · 18/11/2020 17:57

@howtobe

Ffs Mumsnet is a weird place 😂😂

Aye it’s weird OP.

Why would someone sit up stairs when your in for going on 5 months? It’s WEIRD and would definitely be considered odd behaviour in the outside world.

I agree, it's odd behaviour. Also agree MN certainly is a weird place. The majority of the responses to quite a few threads lately have made me feel like I've stumbled into a parallel universe of weirdness.
MatildaTheCat · 18/11/2020 17:59

Does anyone remember when Tracy Barlow got sent upstairs by Deirdre? She was up there for about five years and when she reappeared she had a different head.

Maybe she’s not upstairs at all?

CurryForever · 18/11/2020 18:30

FFS. Maybe she just doesn't like you 🤷‍♀️

rorosemary · 18/11/2020 18:33

Depending on how old your children are I'd be tempted to bring them over next time with a brand new toy drum and a toy trumpet and tell them to go upstairs and say hi to auntie with the noise making stuff when you're there Grin.

But I might not be the nicest person when being ignored.

Coronawireless · 18/11/2020 18:38

@CurryForever

FFS. Maybe she just doesn't like you 🤷‍♀️
Not an excuse to be rude to her children’s relatives. I don’t like lots of people. Colleagues, neighbours, relatives. But I, like most people, am polite to those I have to see regularly for the sake of the wider community. It’s called emotional maturity or “being an adult” and it oils the wheels of civilisation.
Pinkyxx · 18/11/2020 18:52

@ruby4ever Really sorry to read your post. I have a similar issue with my SIL, I was pleasant when my brother introduced us but we never really hit it off and truthfully I don't know her that well - even 15 years later! My brother and I used to be very close - meet up every few month or so to catch etc. Our relationship changed when they got serious; as she seemed put out by his spending time with his little sis vs her. I withdrew as I felt it was only right (with no resentment I might add), and now I only see my brother at family events. The tricky thing is she quite obviously can't stand me and really struggles to hide it. I've literally no idea why. Christmas etc is very awkward as it makes the entire family feel uncomfortable. i make myself scarce during these times we are all together as it's easier for everyone - my DC will be downstairs with family, and I upstairs. Truthfully it sails over my head as I know I've done nothing to deserve it - she barely knows me or anything about my life so it's all very strange.

Where it does upset me from time to time is the children. Whilst she owes no one a relationship.. she and her children spend a lot of time with her siblings' children. I always make an effort with their children on the occasions we are together whereas she virtually ignores my DC and will not get the children outside of formal events (christmas etc). They they have no real relationship as a result.. All very sad in my view as I had (still have) wonderful relationships with my cousins.. today is perhaps a different world and maybe my expectations were not realistic?

Best advice I can offer is don't waste any space in your head on this. She has her reasons and you can't change how she views these things.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread