Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Costco just isn't that cheap?

63 replies

SlightlyCheesedOff · 02/10/2020 12:02

I know you can buy stuff there you can't get elsewhere, but with the rise of shops like Home Bargains and B and M, a lot of the items just don't seem that cheap anymore...I usually come out with next to nothing.

OP posts:
Marmite27 · 02/10/2020 14:15

25p per tin for Branston beans last time we were there (last week). It’s £2 for 4 at Asda.

Yesterdayforgotten · 02/10/2020 14:16

Haha ShivD I will google and see if can find it cheaper to justify my bulk buy purchase, always get a bit gutted if i do find it cheaper and reluctantly put it back on the shelf, it just feels vetter when you know you have the absolute best deal. ..Blush

Yesterdayforgotten · 02/10/2020 14:16

better^

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 02/10/2020 14:23

My parents are serial Costco shoppers. They love the idea that they are somehow getting special low prices not available to everyone, because they are "members". On occasion I've shown them that including the VAT added at the till, much of the stuff is basically priced the same as in sainsburys. Their response to this is to insist the quality is better so they are of course getting a bargain. I've tried the stuff. It's reasonable, but not noticeably better than sainsbury's etc.

You dont get something for nothing.

PerditaNitt · 02/10/2020 14:24

Certain (branded) things are only worth buying when they are on Costco special offer, otherwise they are the same price as if you shop around in supermarkets.

Overall, the own brand quality is very good (eg their tissue boxes have over 160 very soft good quality tissues in each compared to about 70 in a Kleenex box). Their bin liners are very thick and strong (but only worth buying on special offer). Another example is their double sided Christmas wrapping paper is wonderful, but seems expensive on the face of it but the roll goes on forever.

Their homewares (eg towels, duvets) are very good quality and their returns policy is excellent.

I’ve never left the shop having spent less than £50, it is dangerous in there and I only go once every 2 months max so I don’t get tempted to buy stuff I don’t need

BexR · 02/10/2020 14:27

I joined and was excited about it for first couple of months then realised it wasnt cheaper and I was buying random shit I didnt need.

I still buy random shit I dont need. But in B&M so it's cheap.

PleasantVille · 02/10/2020 14:30

@BigBadVoodooHat

I honestly think it's much better value. Some things can be bought for a similar price elsewhere, but I honestly can't see how things like trays of tinned tomatoes for £3.79 or a 16kg sack of rice £8-ish is better value in standard food shops.

Are you looking at the ticket price of things, or taking account of the cost by weight/unit?

Do you know the brand of rice that is £8 for 16kg, my local Costco never has anything that cheap, I buy a lot of rice and I'd be really interested to know so I can see if they could stock it. There's never any less than about £1 a kilo when I go.
PleasantVille · 02/10/2020 14:33

@ShivD

I have my online shopping app open to check the deals when I’m there Blush
Doesn't everyone? I assumed that was standard practice although annoying at the back corner of mine where's there's no reception Grin
Mylittlesandwich · 02/10/2020 14:35

We don't do our weekly shop in there but some things work out much cheaper. You just have to use a bit of common sense.

ktp100 · 02/10/2020 14:48

Depends what you're buying, really.

I always stock up on toothpaste, nescafe capuccinos, toilet rolls and sandwich bags then look for whatever else is on offer.

I literally never leave without a full trolley, though!

Their birthday cakes are incredible value and really delicious. Plus I've bought some high end items at great prices (eg a classic 4 slice Dualit toaster for £150) but they're not all year round.

It's all worth it for the cheap Pizza slices and ice cream in the cafe!

newtb · 02/10/2020 15:05

I joined before DD was born and she's nearly 23. It helped that I worked for Littlewoods and they owned a 25% stake in Costco at the time. We all got free go and see cards. At first we didn't join, and then we did.

We always bought
Loch fyne smoked salmon, at the time £10/pack, when £17 in the shops, which we used to freeze when on offer
The fresh salmon fillet, also frozen
Bradon rost, a sort of hot smoked salmon, but not too often.
The massive chunks of Parmesan we used to cut up and freeze.
The dried cat food, own brand, the cat sitter, a local veterinary nurse, reckoned it was Iams from the look of it.

I can remember Kitchen Aids for £160, including VAT. I dithered for a couple of years, and then decided to buy. They stopped it.

The tyres were sold more cheaply, including fitting, tracking and balancing than my local, not expensive, garage could buy them.

When they had the Gazetta lamps at £160, I bought 3 with a Christmas cheque, a local lighting shop had them at £600 each. Followed by 2 table lamps.

DD had Oshkosh dungarees for £10/time for several years. Too expensive for my budget, but used to take them to a children's clothes dress agency.

Glasses - wear varilux and frames, lenses last time was £250. Where I live each lens costs me 500€.

The deals from time to time on mattresses and rugs are good, even if the product is expensive.

They used to sell a range of oak dining furniture. I knew several stores in the Cheetham Hill/Ancoats area, and when I asked the price, they were horrified at Costco prices, as they were selling them more cheaply than they paid wholesale.

However, the longer the store is open, the more limited the options for the store manager. Each store is a stand alone unit, and each store is responsible for funding the very generous staff bonuses. So, literally, each sq ft has to pay its way, and that is more critical as time goes on.

The card is valid in any Costco, in any country. So, useful for anyone planning a self catering holiday in the US for example.

I live in France, a long way from Paris, and I knew about the plans to open about 10 years before they found a maire prepared to give them planning permission. I did it leaving early one morning, got there about midday, shopped, but about 9pm, just couldn't do the last 50 miles home. I'm mad, but not that mad! Even with the tolls and diesel, I saved money. HOwever the price of regional specialities from the SW made me laugh, they were horrendously high, compared to local.

Good to browse expensive cookery books, to see if you really think it might be worth buying. Got Jamie's American one, half the price it sold at, which was ok, as I've only used 1 recipe, which is now available everywhere.

There are 2 in Spain, so, it might be worth going to Spain with a friend, sharing driving and tolls, to stay a couple of nights, and do a big shop.

In the past I've complained about prices being higher than supermarkets, and got a concerned reply ie Lurpak 500g unsalted was cheaper in Tesco than there. John Lewis told me rather snootily they didn't do price match with shopping clubs, but their never knowingly undersold policy is a bit of a con. Yes, they'll give you the difference if you can prove it, but they won't reduce the price generally across the partnership for everyone.

Rummikub · 02/10/2020 15:15

I go to Costco excited about bargains but leave with barely anything. I can buy a lot of the stuff for same or cheaper in home bargains.
Storage is also a problem. I bought a tray of sweetcorn once and had to put then in random places as my kitchen is low on cupboard space.
Petrol is cheaper though.

lyralalala · 02/10/2020 15:23

I think Costco is only worth it if you have the cash, and storage space, to really take advantage of offers.

It saves me a fortune as we have a big family (household of 9 before the 3 teens went back/away to uni recently), but I'm lucky enough to have a massive cupboard I can fill when certain things are on offer.

Soft drinks, pizza, beans, tinned tomatoes, ketchup, spring rolls, cat litter, cat biscuits, rice, toilet roll, soap powder and cooking oil are my staples. We buy less meat now that we have a really good local butcher. Baby wipes and nappies also used to be regular buys.

Their birthday cakes are also great.

Titsywoo · 02/10/2020 15:27

We go to costco every 3-4 months to buy toilet roll, liquitabs, dishwasher tabs, kitchen roll, bin bags etc. That is all much cheaper to buy in bulk and we have room to store it. I don't buy huge amounts of the food but lots of the food is great (lasagne, cottage pie etc in the fridge section). We get stuff like paddling pools there as they are always cheaper than Amazon or other shops.

It's not comparible to somewhere like B&M at all - that's just cheap tat generally.

notso · 02/10/2020 15:29

For us it's the quality, the bin bags for example are brilliant, I haven't found any anywhere else which are as good.
It saves us money in that we always have certain stuff in so we cut down on top up shops.
Yes I can and do get cheap stuff in B&M etc but I tend to get what I need and spend another £15-£20 on stuff I didn't know I needed like Caramilks, random flavour crisps, baskets and cheap Parker pens!

BogRollBOGOF · 02/10/2020 15:39

I'm not sure how much of a financial saving it is over all, but the stuff is good quality and it's easier buying many things in bulk and streamling the weekly shopping so there's savings of time and effort too.

FedUpAtHomeTroels · 02/10/2020 15:45

We always had a card since the 90's in the US, really good quality and they took returns no questions asked. Not sure they do so now.
I've had a vacuum that broke after 3 month and they took it with no reciept, they look it up on your account and they gave me a new one.
I've had lap tops and car tyres all great.
We really like Kirkland brand stuff, we got nuts, laundry detergent, all sorts each month.
Now in the UK we only get a few things. Baked beans, Kirkland Tuna, giant bottles of Lea and Perrins, Containers of Kenco instant latte, Jelly beans. Odd things, and a cake for birthdays.
I really like the meat, but you need freezer space to split the packs and freeze it.

Ponoka7 · 02/10/2020 15:48

My DD shops for me. She buys the trays of cans, nowhere else does rio etc. We split her petrol costs and still save, so it's worth it for us. I like to shop in person and they get Christmas decorations and the like that you don't see anywhere else.

nozzel · 02/10/2020 15:53

I am a massive Costco advocate, been members for years and we go every month and do a monthly shop, we bulk buy the fresh meat which is fantastic quality. We are exec members, So we get 2% cash back on whatever we spend each month, which pays for our annual membership.

We also have bought all our tvs from there, they have a 5 year warranty. Our lounge tv suddenly stopped working in Feb this year and it was 4 years old, it was taken and inspected and told the parts aren't available any longer so we took it back to the store and was given the full amount back no quibble. Love Costco.

Titsywoo · 02/10/2020 16:08

Oh and we buy cans of coke there - £11 for 30 cans. You'll rarely get them that cheap in shops.

Coquohvan · 02/10/2020 16:17

I look out for their sales/hot ticket items. Recently bought a gazebo from them. Including shipping to France saved £££ buying from elsewhere.

Derbee · 02/10/2020 16:17

A lot of stuff is much cheaper than supermarkets. A lot of the time when things are the same price, it’s actually a larger size at Costco. We have certain things that we always buy (deodorant, sugar, laundry detergent) that are less than half price compared to Tesco.

Derbee · 02/10/2020 16:18

Kirkland brand stuff is amazing (especially the Port 😋)

AdoreTheBeach · 02/10/2020 16:22

I think you’re confusing good value and cheap. These mean different things.

keeprocking · 02/10/2020 16:22

PLaces like Costco and Makro have never been cheap for normal sizes, where they score is on buying bulk sizes.