Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - people need to stop enabling her horrid behaviour

65 replies

PeoniesGinandBags · 31/07/2020 09:57

My sister is and her husband live a pretty closed off life... lovely home, he has a good job and they pretty much do everything together. Their social lives don't really exclude each other from any aspect. That wouldn't be for me, my DH like to do things together but also separate to each other (!) and have our own groups of friends. Just mentioning this for context as it's one of the things my sister thinks is 'odd'.

Recently my work has changed so that, like most people, I'm working remotely. I was furloughed for 6 weeks but since then it's been as full on as usual. DH works away so with having my daughter at home (6) it's been really busy for me trying to juggle.

Sister does not have children and is currently not working (her choice, they can absolutely afford for her not to) while she decided "what she wants to do next". She's applied for a few jobs and each time, she's asked me for help with her application which I've done, even though it's been tricky as I've been ridiculously busy.

Whenever I have asked sister to help with childcare at all. She always says no and does have an excuse. I know this might be plausible but it's literally every time. I don't ask a lot, just because she makes it so awkward. Think perhaps 4 times over the last year. During my working-from-home, I asked her to help one morning, she said no, and I've not asked since. BTW she's an ex-primary school teacher so it isn't as though she'd feel out of her depth etc.

Sister has a history of making really shitty comments to me and other family members, which everyone excuses as "she's in her own little bubble" and "that's just how she is". Things about my weight, personality, things Nan buys for her home being a waste of money etc etc. She's really upset people a few times but no-one challenges her on it.

Earlier this week she messaged to ask if I was around that day and I said yes but I was working (it was 9:30am). She then sent me a really shitty reply about not taking any time to see her, I was selfish etc etc. I told her it was 9:30am on a Tuesday and so like most people, I was working. She replied with some barbed comment about a commitment she knew I'd made with another family member for later in the week (I'd arranged to go for tea with an aunty that's been experiencing some poor mental health).

I replied that I'd made the arrangements last week, needed notice etc etc. Trying to appease her as everyone always does.

Today my Dad let it slip that sister had been to his house and told him that I "couldn't possibly be at work" as "everything is closed".,... making our like I'm some kind of bloody liar! As usual. he's then said "oh just ignore her. You know what's she's like" etc.

So, am I being unreasonable to now be at a point where I say that enough is enough? Surely the fact we're all pussy footing around her is contributing to her feeling that it's okay to be like this?

OP posts:
Shamoo · 31/07/2020 13:09

Some of the responses on here are really bizarre. I don’t have children, and wasn’t even thinking about them when my sister had hers. But jeez if I lived 2 mins from the school and she had a rare emergency it wouldn’t even cross my mind to not pick the kid up for 30 mins. I can’t believe the number of people suggesting it’s reasonable for her to say no to this when she was at home and could do it - her saying no either means she doesn’t consider you important to her or she is very, very selfish.

Whichever it is - you should stop doing anything for her, especially when it puts you out, unless you are willing to live with the complete unequalness. Next time she asks for help with her CV just say no, and that you are busy. If she challenges you, just keep repeating you are too busy to help. If she gets nasty, ignore her.

You can’t change other people’s behaviour but your dad shouldn’t share her bitching about you - when he starts to do that just say you don’t want to hear it!

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 31/07/2020 13:10

Ugh she sounds tedious. Employ the mn favourite phrase: no that doesnt work for me. And just dont ask her for help either. Take her off the mental list of people you can ask - although it sounds as if you already have.

Phineyj · 31/07/2020 13:15

I have a sister a bit like this. I can't even mention work in passing to her because she's got so many issues and hang ups. I've looked at CVs too. And while she does very occasionally look after my child, she's conveniently forgotten all the babysitting I did for her back in the day! Just step right back and expect nothing. Don't involve your Dad. Possibly your relationship will even improve.

Jux · 31/07/2020 13:52

Ignore her.
Stop helping her.

See her at family gatherings; pretend she's a distant relative whom you don't know very well and lives quite far away.

Crankley · 31/07/2020 14:22

From your posts it appears that you don't like her much and the feeling is probably mutual. You don't approve of how she lives, don't like that you work and she currently doesn't, are pissed off when she says no to looking after your children. I wonder, if asked, what she would post about you?

Seems the best idea is for you to live your life and for her to live hers.

fuckinghellapeacock · 31/07/2020 14:26

Stop helping her., Start rolling your eyes at her ridiculous demands and say "That's horrible, why are you so nasty?" when she makes unkind comments. Why are you pandering to her?

Magicbabywaves · 31/07/2020 14:32

It seems amazing someone who lived 2 minutes away from the school wouldn’t go and pick up their niece. Unbelievable in fact, although on MN there’s plenty of people saying you’re BU. I’d cool it with her and I certainly wouldn’t help with a CV.

Leaannb · 31/07/2020 15:39

@Shamoo

Some of the responses on here are really bizarre. I don’t have children, and wasn’t even thinking about them when my sister had hers. But jeez if I lived 2 mins from the school and she had a rare emergency it wouldn’t even cross my mind to not pick the kid up for 30 mins. I can’t believe the number of people suggesting it’s reasonable for her to say no to this when she was at home and could do it - her saying no either means she doesn’t consider you important to her or she is very, very selfish.

Whichever it is - you should stop doing anything for her, especially when it puts you out, unless you are willing to live with the complete unequalness. Next time she asks for help with her CV just say no, and that you are busy. If she challenges you, just keep repeating you are too busy to help. If she gets nasty, ignore her.

You can’t change other people’s behaviour but your dad shouldn’t share her bitching about you - when he starts to do that just say you don’t want to hear it!

Why wouldn't it be reasonable to say no. No one is entitled to free childcare for any reason emergency or not. I don't babysit. Not for anyone or for any reason EXCEPT true emergency meaning they in the hospital dying. That does not make me selfish. That means I have boundaries. I also don't expect anyone else to babysit for me either. It's fine to ask for help but don't be an add when you are told no
longwayoff · 31/07/2020 16:05

YABU as she's obviously got no interest in your children, don't fob them off on someone who doesn't want them. Other than that YANBU, she's a pain, ignore her and leave her to her fascinating life.

timeisnotaline · 31/07/2020 16:07

Next time she wants a cv done, say you are really busy this week but could do it if she can take the kids for an hour Saturday so you can get the other stuff done.
And if she just wants to meet up during the day, I’d say beats me why you’re looking for a job, you seem to have completely forgotten how they work. I can’t meet then, I’m working. Do you do this to your husband or is it different when it’s your bills his income pays?

PeoniesGinandBags · 31/07/2020 20:25

@EatsShootsAndRuns

I was worried about missing after school club pick-up so called sister to ask if she'd be able to get daughter for me

Would the after school club have let an unknown person waltz in and collect your child though? I know when my daughter was in after school clubs they would definitely have not released her to someone that wasn't on the list. This was 20 years ago. If I had to add someone new to the list they needed 24 hours notice. So maybe it's not your sister being awkward it's her maybe knowing the rules.

We have to nominate a few people who they can call on in an emergency and she agreed, when she moved close, for me to add her name. At the time, daughter had just gone into reception class. Also, daughter's teacher is sister's next door neighbour so they know who she is etc
OP posts:
PeoniesGinandBags · 31/07/2020 20:26

@StrictlyAFemaleFemale

Ugh she sounds tedious. Employ the mn favourite phrase: no that doesnt work for me. And just dont ask her for help either. Take her off the mental list of people you can ask - although it sounds as if you already have.
Ooh yes - good quote to use!
OP posts:
Ukholidaysaregreat · 31/07/2020 20:34

She is a twat.

MeridianB · 31/07/2020 20:43

You sound very angry with/at her. Can you take a long break from seeing her and see if it helps?

PeoniesGinandBags · 31/07/2020 20:46

Thanks to everyone for taking the time to reply xx

I am going to just keep her at arms length I think and, when she inevitably asks why, I'll be firm but fair. Her behaviour IS ridiculous. And I understand all the comments about childcare etc and appreciate this is a sore point for lots of people but I think there's a difference between helping out once in a while (it's not a once every 3 months as someone seemed to think.... I was giving a rough average so you got the idea!!!) However, it really isn't dumping my kid on her. It's in an absolute emergency and we ask if we feel we're really stuck. Just like we'd ask a neighbour if they could take a delivery in for us or we'd ask a friend to water our plants if we're away. I looked after my friend's kitten for the day and night last weekend and managed to do it without lecturing her about choosing to get a cat and not looking after it. We all get stuck from time to time....I do think we're at risk of lumping anyone that dares to mention children and needing a helping hand from time to time in some 'cheeky f*er' category unfairly.

I don't know, I just kinda think that if you can help someone, you should do. I think that's why I've been trying to help with these different job application letters, even though it's been a tight squeeze for me time-wise. However, there's helping and her being a CF (which I think she is so I'll own it!)

Have a great weekend x

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread