Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be tired of the narrative that women can't be prejudiced?

29 replies

darwin301 · 13/06/2020 21:42

With everything that has been happening, I keep seeing posts on mumsnet and other social media implying that women can't be racist and have other prejudices like homophobia, islamophobia etc.

I know this narrative is not new and perhaps it serves as another way for society to infantilise women and prove they have a "moral superiority". But, it's really strange to hear supposedly well-informed people spout this nonsense.

OP posts:
Groupsofwomenormenscareme · 14/06/2020 02:48

YANBU OP. It's not so much that I've seen those sweeping statements, it's what's often implied when yet another poster comes a-whinging about men, that everything bad that happens to a woman is automatically the men's fault. Women can't defend themselves because the big bad man is too big and scary and we are weakling and powerless against him.

Men get a walloping here with no mercy and no one bothers to separate the good from the bad. The same women complain when black people generalise about white women. Doesn't feel so nice, does it?

darwin301 · 14/06/2020 08:52

This narrative is far from explicit, I don't think anyone will actually say women are free from prejudice but in reality it is implied to be so. After the 2016 American elections, so many people were shocked that a large percentage of Trump voters were white women because women are assumed to be more left-leaning.

On the George Floyd thread, some posters made remarks like, "It's just male violence" ignoring the fact that female police officers in the US can also be racist which leads to police brutality. On the thread about the wives of the neo-nazis "protecting" the cenotaph, many posters are implying that the wives are being abused or are to ignorant to realise their husbands are terrible, ignoring the obvious reason that they too are probably neo- nazis as well.

As I said, it's not just on mumsnet, it's also in popular media. The controversial movie "Green Book", portrays the wife as a reluctant racist. She is never explicitly racist, like her husband, and seems to just go along with it to keep the peace.

There is even this undercurrent that if women are racist, it's far less harmful compared to men being racist. Racism from women is seen as "racism-light" which makes sense as women are generally unlikely to be in positions of power. However, this idea no longer applies in 2020 when more and more women are finally becoming more equal in society.

I haven't experienced this narrative that "white women are the worst" or they are "punching bags" for everyone, white women are not n-word of the world, that title belongs to black people. I also believe all non-black people harbour unconscious anti-black prejudice, and some black people can even internalise this. So I'm not saying only white women are racist ( I didn't include white in my post).

I do accept that women are held to a higher standard than men when it comes to social justice issues because racism often comes with sexism so a woman voting in a racist is voting against her own interests imo.

OP posts:
Groupsofwomenormenscareme · 14/06/2020 11:01

I agree @OP

Xenia · 14/06/2020 11:06

I have never seen that ever said by anyone actually and of course it must be untrue just as people who are black can be racist and sexist. Some people are discriminatory in all kinds of groups and categories.

I do think sexism affects more people in the UK than racism not least because the UK is 50% female and only 12% non white (and I think only 3% black) so if you want a cause that serves more people in the UK then sexism is a better one but it is not a competition. So 50% v 3% in a sense if we are talking about women and comparing that with number of black people in the UK. I have always called out racism when it is safe to do so and other discriminations which are against the law. Class (nor Indian caste) discrimination is not illegal in the UK and arguably a bigger barrier for some than the colour of their skin or even gender actually.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread