Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to ask something small, that you wish you could ask your late Mum (or other loved one) from when you were a child?

74 replies

WeLovetoBoogieonaSaturdayNight · 12/06/2020 11:35

(So, just a little diversion from all the turmoil lately.)

There was a perfume of my mother's, that I can still recall, even "smell" in my mind, from my earliest memories when I was a child.
The bottle was not on my mum's dresser, after I was old enough to become aware of her collection. And she never wore it again.
I remember and know all of the fragrances that were there, from when I was six or so.
This particular one, though, was a lovely fragrance she must've had from when I was an infant or toddler. It was still detectable (to me) on some of her scarves, when I was around five years old.
Recently, after a couple of years of searching, I think I've finally found what it was (!), but I can't confirm it with my mum.
Or my dad.
(I'm pretty sure my father would have bought it for her.)
My Mum died three years ago; and my Dad, five years ago.
So, it's something I'll never know
...and really wish I did!
Of course there are many other larger things that I wish I could ask them...
but for starters, I wish I knew this.
What is your small thing that you wish you could ask your Mum, or other loved one, about a memory from your childhood?

OP posts:
WeLovetoBoogieonaSaturdayNight · 12/06/2020 14:50

Really lovely stories! Thank you.
Flowers Flowers Flowers for us all.
Been feeling melancholy lately, so I appreciate reading these.
And many are very similar to some other things that have crossed my mind, over the past few years.

And I love the photo!
More photos, please, everyone!
(I wish I could post one, but don't have any on my iPad.)

OP posts:
EssexGurl · 12/06/2020 15:18

I would like to ask her if she was happy. I always had the feeling she wasn’t and had “settled” for my Dad.

Then after she died and I had to do some legal stuff for her estate I found some information that my solicitor suggested rang alarm bells, and her solicitor at the time (probate for my grans estate) put in place legal measures to protect her. It would take too long to explain but it has made me look at my Dad and their relationship very differently. She was the loveliest person and I hate to think she didn’t have the life she deserved.

MariaDingbat · 12/06/2020 15:34

I'd ask my mum what her pregnancies were like and what I was like as a baby. My parents died decades ago and I'm 3 months pregnant now and I wish I could share it with them, get some advice and guidance.

My mum made an amazing potato soup with German sausage in it that I adored as a child, I'd love to know how to make it but she never wrote it down.

jokolo · 12/06/2020 15:38

I would have liked to know what her parents sounded like -- their accents and voices. They were not from this country and I'm curious.

mrssunshinexxx · 12/06/2020 15:42

@PsuedoSatisfactionBaby
How did you cope ?
I've lost my mum 6 weeks ago suddenly she was only 63 and my best friend in the world I am due my first baby in 8 days and I am in so much pain and so scared for the future without her

ChazP · 12/06/2020 15:43

Her chocolate peppermint slice recipe.
She had a box file full of recipes which my dad and/or new wife threw out when they moved house. I’m gutted that all those treasures my mum wrote out or tore out of magazines are gone forever.

callmeadoctor · 12/06/2020 15:48

I would love to know why she put up with our horrible dad for so long and why we had to visit her mum (our grandmother) every weekend who seemed to hate all of us............................

AnnaBanana333 · 12/06/2020 15:52

I wish I'd asked my nan more about her childhood. She was evacuated in WWII but I never asked about it. When she was 18 she saw a man walking in the street and decided she was going to marry him. He was my grandfather, who died before I was born. I never asked about their relationship.

My family isn't very open and that seemed normal in my childhood, but now I would love to know.

My mum is still alive and I really want to know why she and my father split (I was a baby). Maybe one day I'll ask.

Chubbykneesstubbytoes · 12/06/2020 16:48

I'd love my dads recipes, he was an amazing cook. I'd love him to meet my DS, he's my greatest achievement and they would just adore each other. I'd want to tell him that he could never be forgotten and he possibly manages to bring more meaning to my life in death than in life, that all the things we did when I was young I do now with my son. Oh and how did he tie the double bunny ears because I just can't get them right 😁

I'm not sure I could have him here for just a moment. Don't think I'd be able to give him up again.

TooGood2BeFalse · 12/06/2020 16:53

I'd love to ask her to show me the exact amount of butter/salt/pepper she put in her incredible Cornish pasties.I'm 32 now, I still can't get it right.It's either Bland City or Salty Central.

TooGood2BeFalse · 12/06/2020 16:53

*It's either

AdaColeman · 12/06/2020 17:16

Though my Mother has been dead for many years, I still think of her frequently, how we would have laughed at something together or what song or show she would have enjoyed.
I keep a couple of little bottles of her favourite perfumes, and give myself a dab of them, on special days like her birthday. She was a very gifted needlewoman and I've got some things she made for me as a child, and the christening gown she made for DS (he's grown up now).

I'd like to ask her more about her childhood. She was left handed but at school was forced to write with her right hand which must have been awful, she was a member of a famous choir that I'd like to know more about too.

Oh yes, and just how did she make that egg sauce for poached chicken!

AdaColeman · 12/06/2020 17:19

@mrssunshinexxx
Kindest thoughts to you, I hope all goes well for you and your new baby. Thanks Thanks

Guttersnipe · 12/06/2020 17:25

Not so much my mother, though I am sure there are some things I wish I could ask her, but @TooGood2BeFalse, your question is just the one I was thinking this morning I wish I had asked my grandmother before she died: her authentic (she was Cornish) Cornish pasty recipe. Particularly the pastry. No Cornish pasty I have ever eaten (and I have eaten many from Cornish bakeries) has ever tasted as good as Grandma's.

eggandonion · 12/06/2020 17:26

It's hard having a baby when you have no mum, best wishes to anyone in that position. Aside from the deep and meaningful questions, and the cookery - when I was small we used to go to a mill village near us, like Last of the Summer Wine place, where various families were related to my dad. I can't work out who they are, and there is nobody to ask.

EarringsandLipstick · 12/06/2020 17:36

Lovely thread. 💔 posts here.

💐 for you all.

Like a PP, I'd like to have another conversation with my dad. I'd love to talk to him about work, as we worked in a similar sector & he loved all those conversations. He died nearly 2 years ago. I still can't believe it. He had a progressive illness but died suddenly (& sadly in great pain, until just before the end, which I can't bear to think about) in the end. I didn't know the last conversation with him was going to be the one I had, where he was in great pain & distress, as they were moving him to another hospital. It was awful. It was the last time I'd see him conscious & I just wish it was a different memory. 😔

PsuedoSatisfactionBaby · 12/06/2020 17:51

@mrssunshinexxx I’m so sorry you are going through this. I’ll not lie, it was tough but I talked to my newborn baby about her grandma from the moment she was born and kept her memory alive. Sometimes when my eldest is playing now she will smile up the sky and shout “did you see that grandma psuedosatisfaction?” and it makes my heart melt a little bit...because I know she did and I know she would be chuckling merrily away at my daughter.
It will get easier in time. My mum was my best friend too and I still miss her terribly but I see her living through my children and that is comforting.

Please take care of yourself. Flowers

mrssunshinexxx · 12/06/2020 18:10

@PsuedoSatisfactionBaby thanks for replying it's an unbearable thought right now to live the rest of my life without her
I hope I can cope with the baby Hope I find my strength again as I am so like she was and she was so tough and brave but I don't feel like that now x

Toothsil · 12/06/2020 18:27

I'd love to ask my granny for her biscuit recipe. She never wrote it down.

PsuedoSatisfactionBaby · 12/06/2020 20:22

@mrssunshinexxx you’ll be an amazing mum. You’ve clearly had a super role model and that will help immensely. Your baby needs you and I actually found that having my own new little person to concentrate on keeping alive helped me fight through the dark days. I cried buckets of course...joy, exhaustion and grief were not a good combo...but I made it through and so will you. I wish you all the best for your new arrival. You can do this. Flowers

Lifeisgenerallyfun · 12/06/2020 20:37

My grandma was a spiritualist medium, she died when I was fairly young I’d love to ask her about it.

EmeraldShamrock · 12/06/2020 21:14

@mrssunshinexxx I lost my DM recently. I had my babies years ago so I know it's different for you.
One thing that hit me when I had my first was the fascination to realise wow this is how much my DM loved me when I was a newborn.
You'll get to experience all the lovely things she felt with you when you were a newborn. Your pain will turn to admiration all the thing's she taught you will kick in along with instinct.
Best of luck. ❤

TheMandalorian · 12/06/2020 21:25

I have loads of questions for my mum. Family history. What I was like as a baby. My Dad. She always deflects or talks about my brother as a baby. Must try harder next time we visit.

WeLovetoBoogieonaSaturdayNight · 13/06/2020 01:53

OK, sorry -- I had started replying earlier, but was sidelined by a splitting headache, so now just getting back to it:

@labazsisgoingmad
〜 was it Coty airspun powder, by any chance?
And, I quite understand - I am only now beginning to drag myself out of the deep pit of crushing guilt. Even though we had a great relationship, and she knew I loved her (we said it to each other all the time) -- I don't think she knew just how much I loved her! And it is excruciating, to feel that way.

I am getting close to 62 myself. My mum was 85.)

@EmeraldShamrock
〜 Me too! One good (bittersweet) thing is, I occasionally have dreams in which my mum is still alive. It's lovely. Also sad. But lovely.

@Di11y
〜 yes that is very fitting here - I'm interested in all the questions. PhD in bioscience is very cool, btw.

Not the same, but, I often think back, and wonder why I didn't take my mum out to lunch more often, years ago, when we had worked just down the street from each other. Little regrets.

@Cadent
〜 Do you, or does your DSis remember what the bottle looked like? If you describe it, I might be able to come up with it for you! I've done a lot of "research", and am an unqualified expert now. Smile I'd be happy to go on a "mission" for you. Smile

@sunshinepasta
〜 Oh, 23 awfully young to lose your Mum. And not have her for parenting tips is indeed sad. I do know a bit about my mum's earlier life, but wish I knew more. After she died, I became obsessed with wanting to visit her childhood home, and walk the route she walked to school; things like that. I haven't done that yet, but will do eventually. Possibly next year.

@GoodbyePorpoiseSpit 〜 (Muriel, is that you? I lurve that movie!)
〜 My mum performed amature Gilbert & Sullivan every year for several years. I often asked her why she had so many kids (I'm youngest of six) as I think she would've preferred theatre life rather than motherhood. And yy on the war, my father served in WWII, and he never spoke of it, either. I do recall a medal he had, and have no idea where that is now. I did actually ask him about his service just a couple of years before he died. So glad I did. (Naval ship in Okinawa.)

@Ginkypig
〜 Awww, I love that! He was the Prince of Pancakes! My dad worked long hours, and traveled a lot, but would always make up for it at Christmas! BIG Christmases we had. I was fortunate that as an adult, I did get to know him. As (I mentioned earlier) with my mum's home and school, etc, I had become somewhat obssessed with where my dad worked, when I was young. I never visited his office back then, and I've since moved, so did a goole map, and street-view, and imagined where he parked, and seeing the door he walked through, to go into work every day. That area is a bit derelict now, so made it kind of sad, but it was also comforting, somehow.

@Spied
〜 Yes! Me too! Loads of fabulous old photos, and although I know they are grand-grand relatives, I have no idea who they are. My mum got the photos after my Grandma (Mum's mum) passed, and she was unsure about some of them herself. One day, I'd love to delve into it all, but I probably will never actually get it done.

~~~*~
OK, so I'll send this for now -- before this single post gets too huge.
But I will continue to reply, even if it takes me all week!
These are such lovely heartfelt stories, and I feel a connection to all of them in one way or another.
And, not to sound too corny, but each one is individually special in this world.
Truly.
Flowers Flowers Flowers

OP posts:
WeLovetoBoogieonaSaturdayNight · 13/06/2020 01:57

Yikes that was long! Sorry.
Will just send a few at a time next time....

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread