I prefer this photo!
I do have a bit of a thing for very good barristers generally, it has to be said (lawyer, I'm not up in court regularly!).
Starmer comes across as intelligent, thoughtful, precise, compassionate and generally a good bloke (see his pro bono cases etc). What's not to like, personality-wise?
I don't find him wooden or nasally, and he's certainly not posh (odd that a Tory would use posh as an insult, mind you!).
As for who scores better at PMQs? It's not blustering BoZo, that's for sure!