Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To spend 10x more on my parents than ILs xmas presents?

62 replies

babybrain77 · 16/12/2019 20:11

My family has always 'done' Christmas. There was always a big pile of presents under the tree and now that we are adults, we each spend a decent amount on each other. We don't do birthdays - at most we give each other a card.

DHs family are more reserved - they give each other one or two little things and the same at birthdays. Some of it is different financial means, but it's more just a different approach.

Last year (first year we were married) - I said to DH we should spend roughly equal amounts on our immediate families. I toned back my spend and we were a bit more generous than DH would normally be with his family. It didnt really work. On my side it was fine, but on his side it was awkward although DH had laid foundations with his family.

So this year, we decided we would go back to the historical norm. We have got his parents some small bits and bobs (probably £50 value each still). For my dad, I wanted to replace a sentimental item of my late grandmothers which was stolen in a burglary earlier this year. It was costly.

My sister has been round and we discussed presents and she said it was unfair to spend so much more on our parents than ILs. FIL is joining for xmas lunch but it will be after my parents have been round to exchange gifts, so I don't anticipate weirdness there. But AIBU?

OP posts:
runwithme · 16/12/2019 21:43

Massive strikethrough fails....

MoreSparrowThanHawk · 16/12/2019 21:44

To me Christmas is about the enjoyment of the gift, not money.

I couldn't even tell you which of my DC had more spent on them tbh, I do know 100% they will each love their gifts though.

babybrain77 · 16/12/2019 21:45

@FAQs yes, thank you, I agree. The item lost is not particularly valuable in the sense of precious metal or jewels, it's just something old and rare so was difficult to find and expensive to replace. I'm actually really nervous in case my dad doesn't like it - he was gutted when the original got stolen, but obviously the replacement isn't the actual thing given to him by his mum.

OP posts:
elmosducks · 16/12/2019 21:56

I agree with you. My parents love to really think about gifts and are generous. I'm the same. My IL's like to just swap vouchers with each other, I don't see the point and find it soulless but that is how they do it. I get DH to take care is it as I just can't bear it.

CactusAndCacti · 16/12/2019 22:08

We spend different, not that hugely but there is a difference.

We spend very little on mil. There is very little she wants and I have had too many presents returned after a few months to expand much energy (or money) Her birthday is a few days before Christmas as well, just to make it harder.

My parents are slightly harder as I don't like buying them 'stuff' so it has to be something they can use and dispose of (food); something they really need (new saucepans) or money for an activity (going to the cinema)

ANiceLuxury · 16/12/2019 22:53

We spend unequal amounts. We rarely see in-laws and the kids have never received a gift or card from them.

Dh chooses to give his mum £200 at Christmas. I have spent £480 on my mum (no dad to buy for).

But I see my mum 3-4 times a week

StarlingsInSummer · 17/12/2019 15:52

@babybrain77 I’m sure he’ll be touched and pleased that you went to all that effort and value it because his daughter gave it to him, even though it’s not the same one.

thecatsthecats · 17/12/2019 16:07

I am the one who buys less in my marriage.

My parents give us a single lump sum of cash for birthdays and Christmas (both have birthdays two weeks either side), plus an assortment of second hand items (books and small antiques) that come to somewhere about £30 altogether and some home-flavoured booze.

I buy them what they want - second hand charity items, charity donations and a DVD. Costs around £40 altogether.

My ILs do a big song and dance about getting and exchanging expensive items. We have to come up with a list, they provide a list. DH has to spend big and do a lot of work but then we receive a lot also.

Since I receive from both sides, it's win win!

PicaK · 17/12/2019 16:15

I can't see any problems. My parents are the token-present-only types who like specific practical gifts they've requested.
My Inlaws are splurging, revel in a bit of luxury types. So consequently we spend twice as much on them.
We get the same sort of gifts back. I quite like having both types of present exchange. The sense of satisfaction from getting something you really want and the buzz of getting something you didn't know you needed but you actually really like.

JaJoJe · 17/12/2019 17:45

I dont do 'even' at all, I get my parents/siblings between 3 and 5 gifts and spend 10x as much as I do for IL's because they are my family and raised and sacrificed for me... DH can do what he wants with his family and gifting.

My IL aren't big on gifts either but my family are and I'm a big giver like my family but I just get IL's token gifts linked to what I know they like (since I dont know them as well as my own family).

thiscouldbethehill · 17/12/2019 18:15

I think it’s fine. I spend more on my parents than the in-laws. To be fair my parents spend more on us. My mum spends more on DH than his own mum does and my parents have helped us out financially a lot in the past (mortgage down payment etc) so I like to spoil them a bit now we are pretty comfortable financially. We open presents with my parents before the in-laws arrive so it’s not in their face.

redappleandaquamarinebow1987 · 17/12/2019 22:43

@JaJoJe I guess that makes sense if you gift separately. It does become an issue once it is joined presents from you and DH together etc

New posts on this thread. Refresh page