Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to want to be a glutton at Christmas?

39 replies

Swimtobreathe · 07/11/2019 09:42

Bit of backstory: been with DH since early twenties, am low/no contact with my own family and his parents have kindly included me in their family Christmas' since we got together. He has two siblings, everyone lives in different parts of the country - drivable, but not local enough to visit anyone without an overnight stay. As the years progressed all the siblings have taken in turns to host, as well as parents hosting, we've done the last two.

The two siblings now have young families and realistically will be doing their own thing for Xmas for the foreseeable future. PILs are at an age where traveling and being away from home feels quite stressful, and they have said they want to go back to having Xmas at theirs. I've said to DH that I'm happy for us to do the travelling as it's only going to get harder for them as they get older (they're both in reasonable health but fil is mid seventies). Just to be clear this isn't about hosting, it's about spending time with them - we stay in a local hotel, in the past we've done the food order and cooking at theirs etc.

Now my AIBU - PILs are at an age where they don't eat much, their portion sizes have shrunk. Understandable. They also have started to worry about the environment, and waste. This year MIL has said not to order food for Xmas dinner as it's a waste, especially as there won't be children there in Xmas day, instead she'll just do a chicken dinner.
I've been to PILs for dinner before and chicken dinner would be chicken, maybe three potatoes, and a yoghurt for desert. These days they don't eat between meals and it wouldn't occur to them to get anything else in.

I really want to either take food to cook, or at least take extras if we're going - either for the meal, or snacks (mince pies, chocolates, nibbles etc). DH says not to as it'll cause offense.

I know people might read this and think they really don't want us to go for Xmas but I know that's not the case - pil has already planned where he wants to go for a Xmas walk, mil is excited about showing us photos of the grandkids on her new tablet. They're just not very interested in food any more.

I do feel that as we're the couple without children/the ability to travel, and esp given how lovely they were to me about past festivities, that its our responsibility to spend Xmas with them, and they are good company. But to me, food is a huge part of Xmas, and that includes a bit of excess! I feel like just taking extras anyway, but DH thinks we should suck it up and avoid a fuss - after all, it is their home. I feel like I'm being greedy to be bothered by this but it does make me feel a bit sad to think of future xmas' being so sparse! AIBU?

For what it's worth, we have tried alternatives - suggested going out for Xmas dinner but they think it's unnecessarily expensive (we'd offer to pay the lot though they don't let us usually) And going away for Xmas is out because of the travel. We'd be there Xmas Eve til boxing Day and I only get the bank holidays off work so I can't do something on alternative days.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 07/11/2019 09:50

I totally get you. I’d be inclined to email or call and say that you are really looking forward to spending Christmas with them and that one of the parts you enjoy the most is preparing a lovely meal so would they indulge you?

It’s unlikely they will point blank refuse but reassure them that it won’t be over the top and you love to use up the leftovers - turkey curry buffet?!- etc etc.

Bring it with you, cook with minimum fuss and clear up. And keep it relatively simple. A lot of people actually get turned off eating altogether if faced with a mountain of food, especially if they don’t have a huge appetite in the first place.

Magenta82 · 07/11/2019 09:51

YANBU, that sounds very sparse and not at all festive. Have you tried talking to them about what Christmas means to you and how much you enjoy the celebration including the food?

Kitkatfordinner · 07/11/2019 09:52

I would have a stash in the bedroom!

Tractorgirlz · 07/11/2019 09:54

YANBU! Just because their appetite has changed with age doesn’t mean you two need to starve yourselves for the day! Christmas as an adult is all about family & food surely?!

SilverySurfer · 07/11/2019 09:56

Not unreasonable at all, if you can't be a glutton at Christmas when can you be?

If I were you I would take emergency rations to keep in your room and perhaps do your own Christmas lunch at home with all the trimmings on a weekend near Christmas?

Crazyoldmaurice · 07/11/2019 10:00

Just bring extra food for dinner and dessert as you want to contribute to the meal. Once the food is there they cant exactly refuse it being there can they? Also I'd say I won a big hamper at a work raffle and bring in a basket full of chocs, mince pies and whatever you fancy etc it's your christmas too!

Dontlikeoranges · 07/11/2019 10:00

I totally get you! I'd be gutted about not having a good Xmas dinner and all the bits and bobs between meals etc. I'd go along with what a pp said and say how much you love cooking Xmas dinner and how much you really want to do it. I'd also bring all the extra bits you want but don't make a fuss of it - just stick them in the fridge/cupboards and bring them out when you fancy it.

Your DH is being a bit odd about not causing a fuss - everyone knows a big part of Xmas is the food.

NoSauce · 07/11/2019 10:07

Yanbu.

In your shoes I’d be taking pigs in blankets, roast potatoes, cranberry and bread sauce, maybe even a turkey joint. Lots of other things too like mince pies and brandy butter, chocolates and Prosecco.

They don’t have to eat your stuff ( but I bet they will ) but that way it means you can eat things you like and enjoy Christmas.

theoriginalmadambee · 07/11/2019 10:12

YANBU

Essentially you will be having a roast dinner, noting Christmassy.

Can you talk to your pil/mil and tell her some of the things that are important to you to celebrate and get into the Christmas spirit? Try again.

Otherwise tell them you are all going for dinner as a present.

Actionhasmagic · 07/11/2019 10:13

Yanbu food IS a huge fun part of Xmas and I look forward to it more than gifts! If I were you I would do a special Xmas dinner just you 2 on Xmas eve. Get everything in you want - and do a full on Xmas roast. The next day you could take leftovers and then it’s not a waste ! Eg cook more sausages in blankets, extra turkey on Xmas eve then take it to them Xmas day. Fun and 2 Xmas meals for you!

Swimtobreathe · 07/11/2019 10:18

I think my DH isn't fussed as long as he's got a nice Xmas drink tbh! (He and his dad both like a nice scotch at Xmas). I'm genuinely heartened by the responses I thought it was just me being a bit selfish! I like the idea of suggesting I've been gifted something - that'd help with the no waste preference 'ooh I got these at work and can't manage them all myself'. And MIL listens more to DH than me so I might ask him to say about how much I love cooking.... (I don't particularly, but it's worth it for the eating)

OP posts:
Geminijes · 07/11/2019 10:19

YANBU.

Maybe if you take some food such as mince pies, biscuits etc then when it's in front of your in laws they may be more inclined to eat it.
Their appetites have decreased so they don't feel the need to buy more but will probably indulge when it's presented to them.
Sometimes, people don't feel hungry but they eat just because it's there. Especially, at Christmas, I don't think there's many people that don't indulge just for the sake of it.

TheFaerieQueene · 07/11/2019 10:21

Why not buy a Christmas hamper that was a ‘gift’ from work and take that.

Junkmail · 07/11/2019 10:36

I don’t think this a big deal—Christmas is for everyone to enjoy not just your PIL and if the food is really important to you then just bring it with you. You don’t have to do everything their way. I’m sure that’s not what they’re thinking but if you haven’t voiced that this is important to you then how would they know? If they don’t want to eat the food you bring then they don’t have to and you can surely just take any leftovers home with you to avoid waste.

RhiWrites · 07/11/2019 10:44

The real problem is your DH wanting you to shut up about the kind of a Christmas you want to keep the peace when he’s getting the parts that are important to him.

Bringing a hamper wouldn’t cut it for me. I want roast potatoes! Many roast potatoes, not one decent size one cut into three.

Tell the in laws you’re craving a full Xmas dinner and will be happy to cook it and take care of any leftovers to avoid waste.

And tell your husband to stop being so selfish and that you are person whose desires count too.

RaininSummer · 07/11/2019 10:53

I would take a few bits to supplement it and laugh it off by just saying that you two are little christmas piggies and bought the stuff as it looked so nice. I would then have another Christmas dinner at home sometime that week so you can overindulge (and also get lots of reduced food probably).

DeathStare · 07/11/2019 10:54

Could you not just be honest with them and say you have bigger appetites and enjoy food at Christmas so a chicken dinner probably isn't going to fill you both? Offer to bring the food and do the cooking. given how nice you say they are, I'm guessing they just don't realise that you need more.

P1nkHeartLovesCake · 07/11/2019 10:57

I’m with you at Christmas, I want all the treats, the dinner and lots of champagne.

Could you take some bits anyway, and if mil says anything say these are for me to enjoy OR x gave this hamper of delicious stuff to me so we’ve got to enjoy it wouldn’t want to waste

You could offer to cook if you really want the dinner

dayslikethese1 · 07/11/2019 10:58

I don't understand why they'd be offended by you offering to cook? Surely they'd be glad not to have that struggle as it sounds like they're a bit frail these days.

dayslikethese1 · 07/11/2019 10:59

And they can't complain about waste because you can just offer to take the leftovers home!

WomensRightsAreContraversial · 07/11/2019 10:59

I think I'd have our xmas dinner on another day.

My family have chicken for Xmas dinner btw. A nice free range top of the range one is nicer meat than Turkey imo and we have leftovers, just not as many which in my opinion is no bad thing.

Can you bake? Or buy from farmers markets etc a cake and mince pies. That way the packaging is non-existent (Tupperware are your friend), you haven't made or bought too many (the excess is at home in your freezer Halloween Wink) and it isn't rude to take one mince pie for each of you, you can always stress they don't have to have theirs today if they aren't hungry enough for it today.

And equally I don't think it's rude at all to say "MIL would you be so kind as to indulge me, I do love roast potatoes, could we have those with our meal?"

AmIThough · 07/11/2019 10:59

Why don't you suggest you travel to them for Xmas then all go out for Xmas lunch to 'save them the hassle'?

PrincessHoneysuckle · 07/11/2019 11:07

It's possible that they dont enjoy food as much because they cba or have no enjoyment preparing it these days.If presented with goodies (especially after a few drinks) it might gee their appetites up

Shoxfordian · 07/11/2019 11:07

Have a nice order of food in for the following weekend and enjoy yourself when you're back home. Maybe offer to cook for them? You can then bring lots of nice things

LaurieMarlow · 07/11/2019 11:11

YADNBU. Christmas food is a huge deal.

Definitely offer to cook for them. Regardless of whether this offer is accepted or not, bring loads of goodies with you. The hamper is a good idea.

Tell DH it's your Christmas too and you can't just suck everything up for fear of offending.