Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to want to be a glutton at Christmas?

39 replies

Swimtobreathe · 07/11/2019 09:42

Bit of backstory: been with DH since early twenties, am low/no contact with my own family and his parents have kindly included me in their family Christmas' since we got together. He has two siblings, everyone lives in different parts of the country - drivable, but not local enough to visit anyone without an overnight stay. As the years progressed all the siblings have taken in turns to host, as well as parents hosting, we've done the last two.

The two siblings now have young families and realistically will be doing their own thing for Xmas for the foreseeable future. PILs are at an age where traveling and being away from home feels quite stressful, and they have said they want to go back to having Xmas at theirs. I've said to DH that I'm happy for us to do the travelling as it's only going to get harder for them as they get older (they're both in reasonable health but fil is mid seventies). Just to be clear this isn't about hosting, it's about spending time with them - we stay in a local hotel, in the past we've done the food order and cooking at theirs etc.

Now my AIBU - PILs are at an age where they don't eat much, their portion sizes have shrunk. Understandable. They also have started to worry about the environment, and waste. This year MIL has said not to order food for Xmas dinner as it's a waste, especially as there won't be children there in Xmas day, instead she'll just do a chicken dinner.
I've been to PILs for dinner before and chicken dinner would be chicken, maybe three potatoes, and a yoghurt for desert. These days they don't eat between meals and it wouldn't occur to them to get anything else in.

I really want to either take food to cook, or at least take extras if we're going - either for the meal, or snacks (mince pies, chocolates, nibbles etc). DH says not to as it'll cause offense.

I know people might read this and think they really don't want us to go for Xmas but I know that's not the case - pil has already planned where he wants to go for a Xmas walk, mil is excited about showing us photos of the grandkids on her new tablet. They're just not very interested in food any more.

I do feel that as we're the couple without children/the ability to travel, and esp given how lovely they were to me about past festivities, that its our responsibility to spend Xmas with them, and they are good company. But to me, food is a huge part of Xmas, and that includes a bit of excess! I feel like just taking extras anyway, but DH thinks we should suck it up and avoid a fuss - after all, it is their home. I feel like I'm being greedy to be bothered by this but it does make me feel a bit sad to think of future xmas' being so sparse! AIBU?

For what it's worth, we have tried alternatives - suggested going out for Xmas dinner but they think it's unnecessarily expensive (we'd offer to pay the lot though they don't let us usually) And going away for Xmas is out because of the travel. We'd be there Xmas Eve til boxing Day and I only get the bank holidays off work so I can't do something on alternative days.

OP posts:
Jimjamjong · 07/11/2019 11:13

I think it could offend to bring your own stuff to cook but surely you could bring in nibbles and extra snacks to enjoy and share. If they talk about waste, just say not to worry you'll take the leftovers home unless they fancy some.
I wouldn't say sorry though or we are piggies, it's a normal part of Christmas or parties.

Ponoka7 · 07/11/2019 11:17

My Mum would say stuff like they have, but once we'd explained or challenged her, she'd realise that she hadn't thought it through.

You need to speak to them and explain that for you, food is a part of Christmas. A proper dinner with extra roast potatoes doesn't create waste. Nor do some of the extras.

As a, pp poster sugested, put mince pies in tupperwear and say they came from a lical baker.

They need a gentle reminder that tgis is your very limited time off work.

It's really selfish of FIL and DH to be happy as long as they get to drink what they want.

I hate 'Christmas is for the kids'. My Adult DDs now want Christmas in their own homes. Christmas for me and my Adult DD who lives with me is about a decent steak dinner, Baileys in every flavour, crips and Christmas themed horror films.

Put your foot down. Or this will be the norm every year.

SummerInSun · 07/11/2019 11:18

Another vote for doing it, but a friendly conversation about it first. I only think I you risk causing offence of you show up with a lot of stuff without having discussed it first. I think you just say to PIL - in advance - "for me, a big part of Christmas is enjoying the festive foods I are as a child, so I'll contribute that to our Christmas all together".

BigFatLiar · 07/11/2019 11:25

I'm with the go along and have a nice visit have a snack at the hotel if you want. Do the big meal at home with your DH where you can both eat and drink and not worry about traveling. Watch whatever you want, have a nap, go for a walk. Make your visit about his parents and have your day later.

BuildBuildings · 07/11/2019 11:26

I understand completely. One yer about 6 years ago we went to my mil and her mum was there too. Neither massively like Christmas. I was working in a retail job after finishing my MA. So working very hard at that time of year plus looking for work and feeling down about it! Christmas is really important fto me. They just do it differently including food. We basically stuff our faces and really enjoy ourselves. Life is hard and I think time to do Christmas how you want is important. This Christmas really was difficult and given other things that were going on made me feel very low. So yanbu. It's obvs important to you.

BuildBuildings · 07/11/2019 11:29

Sorry for the few typos!

SillyUnMurphy · 07/11/2019 11:32

No way AYBU! This would ruin Christmas for me. I'd just be honest and say that you will be ordering and bringing food as it's all part of the festive season for you.

ChileConCarne · 07/11/2019 12:23

Omg that sounds miserable! The ONLY thing that I care about with Xmas is the foodie treats I can enjoy, which I don’t really get to eat for the rest of the year.
We had a final miserable Xmas at the in-laws (no tree, no decorations, wasn’t offered a glass of fizz etc) and we’ve hosted ever since.

Apolloanddaphne · 07/11/2019 12:30

If your MIL cooks a decent roast chicken then let her do that and you can take the trimmings and extras with you? We used to do this type of thing with my PIL and they never objected.

jay55 · 07/11/2019 13:43

Take a few things and tell your in-laws that you brought them with you as they'd only go out of date at home....I mean this requires being crazy you with use by dates but I'm sure you can take some nice cheese and a few trimmings...
And keep a shit ton of choc at the hotel.

jay55 · 07/11/2019 13:44

Crafty with dates not crazy

NoCleanClothes · 07/11/2019 13:45

YANBU. I hate food waste but there's no reason the extra has to be wasted and lots of christmas food can be brought in locally and doesn't have to be wasteful.

Sleepyquest · 07/11/2019 13:50

That sounds miserable OP. Everyone knows Christmas is for eating, drinking and being merry! Do you have to go? I don't think I would go but I'm a brat. Maybe suck it up this year but next year tell your DH that you are having the Xmas you want and then plan it all how you want.

Swimtobreathe · 07/11/2019 14:10

Thanks for all the responses, as per my previous post I'll have a word with DH. Just to be clear, noone is insisting on anything, I think they're just not thinking it through. Mil mentioned it to DH and he said it was fine. He's pretty easy going. When DH mentioned it to me I said mil doesn't have to go cook, I will, and then he mentioned that mil might feel uncomfortable (when we've cooked before she's got quite involved, I think she feels responsible for her kitchen so it creates work for her even if I try and insist she sits down!) I just wanted to check as noone else has thought it's a bit deal so far, that I'm not going mad to make a big deal of it!
(I suspect dh hasn't thought about how it would mean no pigs in blankets...)

I'm going to ask DH to make it clear that I'll bring food and cook, but I'm thinking of suggesting making it one of those order in dinners (like m&s) so that there's minimal fuss in the kitchen and she won't feel she's got to get involved, and it'll be straightforward to clean up.

If it was a one off I wouldn't mind, but given our commitment to spending Xmas with them I don't want our xmas' to whittle down to a microwave meal in a few years time!

Genuinely, thanks for all your responses and reassuring me that its ok to be an adult and want to spend Christmas stuffing my face and eating a selection box for breakfast

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread