Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To keep parts of my life separate?

32 replies

PinkBalloon123 · 06/11/2019 11:01

I am lucky to have lots of people in my life. A very small but loving family, a couple of sets of really good friends, a nice man in my life... but I see these as different compartments of my life and I not always, but often, choose not to mix them.

My friends have never met the 'special person' in my life and to be honest unless I get engaged or move in with him - neither of which I'd want to happen for at least a couple of years - I don't want to introduce him to anyone. I just find that specific relationship very private to me and it isn't really something I feel that open talking about. If anyone ever asks oh how's it going with him I just shrug and say oh yeah good thanks. Don't get me wrong I'm not hiding anything and he treats me well, I just think as long as I'm happy people don't need to be concerned. On the odd occasion when I've had a disagreement with him (we met online a couple of years ago) I've just fumed in private and we've then sorted it out between the two of us. I'd never phone somebody to rant about it, probably my Mum but even then only if I was desperate! I'm not hugely close to any of their partners either and it's not like any of us would want "couple nights out" etc. I think part of this is because I've seen and heard it all so often in the past. Somebody will flaunt their relationship around and air everything in public both good times and bad times and then well meaning friends will pick apart someone's personal life with their opinions and judgements. I'd much prefer it if people stayed out of mine thanks! I'd find it very intrusive and quite pressurised.

Another example is work. A friend of mine recently (casually) asked me to enquire about any jobs at my place now that her youngest is in school, which I immediately said no to and was very honest about. I feel like my place of work is my own thing and shouldn't be mixed with my personal friends. It's not a hospital or a big corporate place where I'd likely end up seeing a friend who just happened to start working there it's just a very small office with 10 of us. I know if someone I knew applied for a job there then that's up to them and I can't control where people work, but would I specifically try to secure a job for a mate? No. Again I've seen it all before several times with personal friendships deteriorating or going south permanently because they've mixed their work and have then grown sick of the sight of each other or there's been a fall out over a promotion or some other work related drama etc that would never have happened if they'd not worked together. Twice I advised a friend not to do this, twice she ignored me and eventually lost both friendships.

The final example would be a needy, toxic relative and my complete refusal to have him around me at all when I'm with other people. I don't have an issue with family in general, just this relative specifically and the discomfort I feel around him. But there's much more to that and I won't bore you. He makes me feel like a shit person for not including him, but I won't budge on this.

Don't get me wrong I've introduced people to each other before and I've been pleased when they've hit it off just like I've not been bothered if they've not liked one another etc. I did also introduce my past boyfriend to a couple of people but then it didn't work out so it was pointless anyway. I often see someone having a night out with colleagues and they'll think nothing of bringing friends along too, or someone will plan a spa day with some mates and they'll happily invite the mother in law.

I do feel things are simpler and there is less hassle by keeping certain things separate but also wonder in the back of mind am I just a massive, awful control freak?!

Does anyone else pigeon hole parts of their life?!

OP posts:
PinkBalloon123 · 06/11/2019 11:04

I did use paragraphs but I can't see them :-(

OP posts:
ThatMuppetShow · 06/11/2019 11:05

You do sound very immature regarding your relationship.

Work and private life, I keep more separate. I have made friends with people from work, but it's easier that way because you know them professionally first. You just need your priority rights - you know that when you get promoted above others, they will resent you.

TokyoSushi · 06/11/2019 11:06

Yes, I do this. I think it makes things easier. I have DH & DC who go across all 'sectors' (except work). Then I have work - I would never invite anybody I knew to work there as I like to keep it a 'my' thing plus 4 sets of friends, some groups which I have huge involvement and some less so, I never mix them though. Some people may think it's odd but I like it that way!

Maliko · 06/11/2019 11:07

You sound afraid and you're reaction to that fear is to keep everything separate and to control as much as you can. Does that ring true?

churchandstate · 06/11/2019 11:08

I don’t do it consciously, no.

PinkBalloon123 · 06/11/2019 11:23

Hmm not sure why it's very immature to keep a personal relationship private but okay. Yes I agree it's different if you build a friendship with someone you've known professionally first.

I see your point on the "friendship group" thing. I would not mix certain groups not because I'm trying to control because I just know they are different personalities and probably wouldn't be that interested in one another.

Control via fear - you do have a point, I do fear potential awkwardness somewhat.

OP posts:
Grumpos · 06/11/2019 11:24

I do this to a degree, I’ve never been the type to organise a dinner party or get together and then invite people from all sides of my life.
However I do think sharing snippets and events across family, friends, partner and colleagues is what gives your relationships substance. I very rarely see my partners friends and haven’t done work events together (just bc of timing and childcare etc) but I go to weddings and parties as the plus one and he will talk about them to me and I know he shares stuff about our home life

  • kids, holidays, house refurb etc.
I wouldn’t feel overly secure if I knew my partner never spoke about me to friends or ever introduced me to work colleagues etc. I don’t think your wrong as I also like to keep a level of separation but you seem to be very extreme over controlling it
Applesanbananas · 06/11/2019 11:30

I would think you are hiding something about your relationship or possibly making that person up. Especially with your brushing off answers regarding him.

The only person who I know is like this, is a friend who enjoys being the centre of attention and having that control. Not having groups mix, no risk of people clicking and getting on better than with you. Not saying this is you, if it makes you happy then you know best what works.

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 11:34

I do this. I think it's fine, obviously!

I've never introduced a friend into a workplace but I've seen people do it and it go spectacularly wrong.

there can be weird reasons for keeping friends separate. An admittedly ex friend joked about wearing a fur coat to my birthday because she thought it would be funny to upset my white vegan friends - while simultaneously crawling up the arse of my non-white vegan relatives. (of course, in her world, one set of people is okay and one set is not).

anyway, Im no longer friends with her (!) but it was a bit of an eye opener about how much things can maybe go wrong if you mix people. I think the whole "identity politics" thing has the potential to cause a lot of clashes now, so while in the past I would get everyone together for a drink on my birthday, I don't think I'll be doing that again for a while either!

I never liked boyfriends meeting anyone.

Sparklyring · 06/11/2019 11:35

I think this is very odd. Surely you just have a life and everyone and everything is intertwined?!?

Flouncysinatra · 06/11/2019 11:37

Work and personal life separate - fine. However are you saying you don’t introduce anyone to your partner in case it goes wrong? That is odd.

Primr · 06/11/2019 11:38

So, what's the problem?

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 11:40

"Surely you just have a life and everyone and everything is intertwined?!?"

I think we cross posted but there's just so much crazy attached to that. When I was young, there were people taking lots of drugs and people who didn't approve....now people are probably more discreet lol..

then there's politics, general stuff like potentially clashing personalities. I have real issues with my best friend's sister, which is a pain, but I honestly think she has an aggressive personality and a tendency towards bullying.

I do wish we could all hang out together but we really can't.

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 11:41

PS when I say "crazy" I mean potential crazy in the mixings, not the poster of the comment is crazy!

ilovetofu · 06/11/2019 11:43

Very controlling behaviour.

MrsWillGardner · 06/11/2019 11:43

You sound like you like to push people away, to be honest.

PinkBalloon123 · 06/11/2019 11:44

It's not like I point blank refuse to talk about my relationship, I'll mention if we're going away somewhere or something and people have seen pictures of us etc. I'm not some nutcase making him up! I just don't go into massive detail every time there's a high or low and he's not a huge topic of my conversation.

I have one friend in particular who mixes everything. Family, friends, colleagues, partner, everyone's kids all know each other etc. Yes she has a lot of people in her life... but there is ALWAYS a fall out or a drama. A friend dislikes her boyfriend or one of her mates kids has fallen out with one of her kids and everyone gets involved. I just think oh for the love of God if you hadn't have pulled everyone together you wouldn't have so much bloody drama.

Me? I definitely don't like being the centre of attention. I like a quiet, non eventful life.

OP posts:
Ekundayo · 06/11/2019 11:46

You’re completely reasonable about mixing work and friends, not inflicting your nasty relative on others, and keeping friendship groups separate. I think your attitude to your significant other being kept completely ‘private’ needs a bit of unpicking, though. I mean, there’s a big chunk of middle ground between ‘flaunting’ your relationship/ discussing your boyfriend’s sexual kinks or your rows in endless detail with your friends (I don’t talk to anyone about my marriage, and we’ve been together since our teens) and on the other hand keeping him so entirely apart from all your other relationship — are you afraid the relationship isn’t robust enough to survive the light of day? Would it matter if he and your friends didn’t like one another? Or, alternatively, if they got on like a house on fire?

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 11:47

"I just think oh for the love of God if you hadn't have pulled everyone together you wouldn't have so much bloody drama.

Me? I definitely don't like being the centre of attention. I like a quiet, non eventful life."

yes. this is another reason I do it. I don't think it's "controlling" you aren't forcing people apart!

I used to go to a friend's work drinks quite often. I stopped going when someone there invited me to her wedding and got very cross when I said no. She didn't have my contact details but hassled my friend, her colleague, about what my "prior engagement" was. There's just too much crazy around to risk multiplying it.

Cheeseandwin5 · 06/11/2019 11:52

I wonder how your BF and friends feel about your attitude.
I think I would be a bit narked if my DH didnt want me to meet any of his friends or family ( and if I was a friend and you didnt want me to know about your BF).
You are stopping people ( both your BF and friends) to know you, and by doing so you will stop the relationships grow.
Too be honest I would have cut you loose by now.

Ekundayo · 06/11/2019 11:55

You seem to have surrounded yourself with drama-prone people, OP. I genuinely don’t recognise all those soap-opera- type fallings-out from my own life or the lives of people I know.

Proseccoinamug · 06/11/2019 11:55

I don’t think it’s very nice!

I have a friend who does this. I see her one on one, we are close, we confide in each other.

She never invites me to anything, mentions me to anyone else. Nobody would know that we’re good friends.

It feels like she doesn’t want to be associated with me publicly or that I’m not good enough for her other groups of friends, and also that I’m dropped when she has plans and tough shit if I’d like to go along too.

I’m distancing myself.

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 11:56

with regards to partners, I'm 43, if that helps, and with friends aged up to 55, I don't know most of their partners. I meet them at the odd do, but I don't know them socially. We socialise as individual friends.

I never wanted coupley friends.

AutumnRose1 · 06/11/2019 11:57

Prosecco "and also that I’m dropped when she has plans and tough shit if I’d like to go along too."

you mean she cancels if she thinks something better has come along? That's completely different.

Fatted · 06/11/2019 12:03

I guess it depends on the reasons why you're compartmentalising your life. I think most people realise that there's people they know that just wouldn't get along together if they were in a social setting together. I do find the bit about your partner a bit odd. Would you not perhaps bring your partner along on a night out if it was a mixed group and other people were bringing their partners? Or say a wedding or similar?

I tend to keep some parts of my life separate. My family don't mingle with the in laws, but that's mainly because they're just very different personalities with different interests. I don't really socialise with work much, again because we don't have too much in common outside work. I do take DH along to most things. I don't talk about my relationship as such. I tell people I have a DH and kids and that's about it. We've had a lot of hard times lately and I don't really think it's appropriate to bog people down with all that!!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.