Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask what is the difference between smacking a child and abuse?

51 replies

lowbluehorizon · 29/08/2019 13:43

I was talking about my childhood with my Mum yesterday. I harbour quite a lot of resentment about it. My Dad had a very nasty temper and would regularly hit us if he didn't like the look on our faces, or we said something he didn't like. I was the only girl and received the brunt of it. I can remember many occasions where he lost his temper and I would be on the floor screaming while hits were raining down on me. He never used a belt and never hit me on the face. The worst of it started at the age of 11 and I think the last time he hit me was around the age of 19. I suffered with quite a bit of depression due to this and made my first suicide attempt at age 17 and again around the age of 23. I have battled with low mood and depression all my life. I never hit my own children.

My parents were working-class and I lived in a nice, clean home and they both worked hard. On the surface, everything should have been ok. None of my friend's parents hit then and I envied their happy go lucky attitudes as a result. My Mum never defended me when I used to get hit and she revealed to me that he hit her once when they were 'courting' and a few times in their early marriage but not in recent years. I was quite shocked but this. They have been married for nearly 50 years and his temper has mellowed with age.

What are your views on hitting children? Where does smacking end and it become child abuse? I am extremely anti-smacking, I remember being hit lots but never the reason why nor the 'lesson' that was trying to be taught.

OP posts:
chocolatemademefat · 30/08/2019 16:11

Like ithinkmycatisevil I was often backhanded on the face by my mother. Another favourite form of punishment was throwing things at me - mugs and books being her favourites. Her language was awful and totally destroyed my self esteem. Listening to her now you’d think she was the perfect mother. I swore never to be like her and never smacked my 2DS.

I think you get back what you put in. I’m close with my sons but have a cold relationship with my mother to the point that now she’s older and needs me more I can’t stand being with her. I still see her and help her when I can but I hate every minute of it.

I’m sure there’s more to it than the smacking but what kind of parent wants to inflict harm on a child. I’m not talking about a pat on the bottom when they’re in danger.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page