Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be hopping mad at husband?

59 replies

Skiphopnicknok · 08/08/2019 08:33

Been married almost 2 months but together 5 years with 1 year old DC. We’ve always split everything 50/50 but retained our own properties we had pre being together (we also own a house jointly). We’re looking to buy a bigger property and have another DC. When we bought our current home, I put in more than my (then DP) DH as I had more available cash.

He recently sold his property and paid me back (even though I now consider it “our” money). He’s been dabbling in stock market for last 5 years (he works in finance anyway) and is up for the most part but had a bit of a disaster earlier this year having taken a big position on one stock. He made it back but yesterday had another big loss.

He told me originally he’d lost 12k of “his” money. He’s also invested some of my money I had given him (to invest for me) in it and our DC’s. DC and I have lost our paper gains we had but capital is safe (well, I’m 700 down on capital) but last night it transpires he’d actually lost 18k of “his” money and so when added to mine and DC’s losses, we’ve lost about 22k as a family.

We are looking to buy a bigger house and I am SO mad at him. He is mortified and has immediately sold all his shares (other than those in funds which are managed by other people as to be fair, we do need to try to grow a bit of it). He’s not slept all night (neither have I).

He recognises that he’s done wrong and is going to seek help. I told him in no uncertain terms if it happens again I will divorce him. He is genuinely remorseful.

He’s a great husband and dad but I’m a little worried and of course hopping mad.

We are sitting down this weekend and pulling together all finances. I’ve also said we will now have “spending” money each month and rest goes into a joint savings account so that way he’s not even tempted to do anything on markets (other than with his spending money).

Now also feel I need to take control ofDC’s investment account.

I don’t want to lose him but I am very very cross.

More advice rather than AIBU I guess.

OP posts:
SunniDay · 08/08/2019 13:20

It seems unfair to me that you were happy for your husband to invest money into stocks until he lost money. Then he has to be "sorry". Stocks go down as well as up. If you don't want to take risk with your money put it in a savings account or government bond/premium bonds etc. A safer way to invest is FTSE 100 tracker but they can still fall.

Skiphopnicknok · 08/08/2019 13:20

And the divorce comment was straight after I found out he’d lied so was a reaction to that really I think but a knee jerk reaction.

Overall we are even compared to where we were when he started investing so I guess that’s not so bad but I thibk it was the shock of losing that amount overnight when we are looking to move house

OP posts:
CottonSock · 08/08/2019 13:25

I bet you wouldn't be hopping mad at a 22k gain. Stock markets are for long term and patient people. Selling shares as soon as they are down is not how to make money.

Skiphopnicknok · 08/08/2019 13:32

If you read my last comment you’ll see I’ve recognised that @Cottonsock - it was a knee jerk reaction

OP posts:
QualCheckBot · 08/08/2019 13:37

YANBU: He’s also invested some of my money I had given him (to invest for me) in it and our DC’s.*

You gave him the money to invest. He invested it. The stock market is uncertain (Brexit is hardly a surprise occurrence all of a sudden). It was as much your loss as his, as you instructed him to invest. In fact, pressurising him to sell at the bottom of the market makes it possibly your fault.

Why didn't you make your own investments, or put the money somewhere safe instead?

CottonSock · 08/08/2019 14:22

Yes sorry missed your update.

larrygrylls · 08/08/2019 14:31

There is a lot of ignorance about trading/investing on this thread.

Buying one stock and hoping to make money on it is trading (at best) and gambling at worst. Equally, buying and hoping to make money over the short term to buy something else is again gambling.

If you carefully select a balanced portfolio of stocks, balanced with fixed income securities and cash, and intend to hold them long term as investments, then the Warren Buffet dictum 'be fearful when others are greedy and to be greedy only when others are fearful' is sensible advice.

However, if you are effectively having a punt, and your time horizon is short term (less than 5 years, say) then momentum is probably better than value. Stocks can sit in the doldrums for years before they trade at fair value.

Personally I prefer to invest in dividend paying large stocks which, in some ways are safer (after all I can pick up my dividend every year while I wait for them to go up).

If you trade/invest you need to firstly think about your risk tolerance and time horizon, then be very disciplined. And remember, especially when trading (i.e buying for short term gain), you are competing with professionals, who have practised for years and have far more sources of timely information than you have.

Myimaginarycathasfleas · 08/08/2019 15:18

Sounds like you've had chance to take a breath and the fog has cleared. Hope you get some clarity from a joint approach - and some profit!

XXcstatic · 08/08/2019 17:58

Thanks for the update, OP - nice to know you will be sorting it out between you. Good luck Smile

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread