Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want a tight relationship with my young half sister

54 replies

IABUQueen · 25/07/2019 13:01

Hi all,

So this is a sensitive topic for me.

My parents divorced when I was 16. My mum was the one who chose to leave as my dad was going through severe mental health issues and wasn’t treating himself and it was leading to her being abused. I was very close to my dad but as he started being abusive to my mother and manipulative I cut contact as it was too emotional for me.

He soon moved in with a woman who he lied to (admitted it to me), he lied to and told her that he is still married to my mother (they were still in the process of separation) and that he wants to resolve things with her. The woman moved in with my dad into our family home, which my mum paid for half of or even more.

My father kept sending me emails which I sometimes replied and sometimes not because he was using me to get to my mother. He said things like how he has a daughter from the new woman and how he completely forgot about me and so on. It hurt as I was 16.

Anyway fast forward two years, I resumed contact with my dad. I started visiting every summer. I tried to build a relationship with my baby sister and I honest to god tried to be very kind to my dads wife.. who admits that she got with my dad as a mistress and was hoping we will never show up ever again in my dads life. I was a very passive child with extremely low confidence and wasn’t always trying to please her perhaps she would like me.

Anyway the initial visit I was quite shocked at her behaviour. She quite obviously wanted me to feel uncomfortable. Kicked me and my siblings out of our own family home.. was using our mums clothes as rags for the floor.. and our children’s towels to sweep and clean.. my toys were handed over to her child . All a bit overwhelming to see.. but I was actually a pushover and just cried myself to sleep.. she told us to never come again, that our dad doesn’t love us. I believed her. Never told my dad because she had this personality where she convinced me she was saying things out of love.

Worst of all is she started wearing sexy lingerie Infront of me and my siblings. And when I spoke to her privately about how it made us uncomfortable she said “this is my house I dress how I like”. She would intentionally talk to me about her and dads sex life and I was too naive didn’t know how to respond but be uncomfortable and tell her to please stop but she was adamant. Looking back now this was alll very deliberate.

Fast forward few years, I suffered at her hands much more than this but was tooo naive to realise it was deliberate manipulation. My father was never told by me but he knew I was miserable.

All this time I was always always thinking of my little half sister. How I don’t want to tell my dad because I don’t want them to divorce and my little sister be hurt like I was.

I used to invest so much time doing arts and crafts with her. But as she grew her mum was always always making digs at me through her. My little sister was encouraged to kick me out , talk to me disrespectfully.. and I always behaved in a way where I wanted her to see me as a good example.. but it deeply hurt.

Until the day came when I was reading a story to my sister about lying and she came told me that her mum asked her to lie to my dad about me, something that would really piss my dad off, and so I got in trouble with dad. I confronted her mother and she admitted she was jealous of me because I look like my mum. I told her I don’t trust her anymore and I didn’t deserve her treatment and I finally came to accept that this woman doesn’t want to like me no matter how much I suck up to her.

She had caused a huge rift between me and my dad.. constantly lying to him about me. Neighbours and friends in common warned me because they saw what she did. I was too naive and always gave her the benefit of the doubt because my mother is actually naive and she hates putting down other woman and she used to always dismiss my emotions and tell me that I need to behave well in my father’s house so that I don’t lose him. My mum was a doormat.

Anyway, after I became older and few things happened which made it clear my step mum was using me to get back at my mum and to draw my father to hate me and my mother.. and my dad admitting that he doesn’t have a way with her... I went almost no contact and only see her when I have to.

I didn’t invite her to my wedding abroad because she was vile to me during my engagement.. I live abroad now and my dad comes once a year to visit and I never extend an invite to his wife. I realise it’s generally rude but my father doesn’t dare to ask even because he knows how much he allowed her to hurt me. I’m civil when I see her but I avoid her when possible and my father only comes for 4 days in a year, in which she is constantly keeping him busy.

He isn’t better but since he is my dad I decided to put up with him but not her.

On two occasions my father asked to bring my sister with him.. I offourde said yes.

However the entire visit was my sister (now 10) making digs at me. Exactly learnt from her mother.. undermining me.. and behaving super competitive saying lies to my dad to degrade me Infront of him. I’m more confident now to call her up on it but it wears me down. She keeps bringing up how her mum does things better than me, while she is in my house.. telling me my mum cooks this better than you whatnot. Which is understandable if I was her step mum but I’m not I’m her sister, but her mothers competitive streak making her feel loyal in a weird way.

I know she is a child.. but my father enables her behaviour. Her mother teaches her.

Right now I’m going through a period of prenatal anxiety. I was breaking down and my father called said he wanted to visit. I assumed it’s because of my depression. But once I accepted few days later he told me he wants to bring my sister.

I don’t feel I have the energy for her. I need my father for support and when she is there she is constantly causing me stress.. and my father on the other hand is still angry with my mother, and having my sister with him makes him take it out on me when he feels like it.. he starts putting me down with words to her like “I don’t want u to be like your sister”..

Adding to that, I lost my father when I was 9.. before the divorce he had a severe accident which led to him mentally not being aware for a long time.. so he wasn’t able to be that father for me which is a sensitive subject.. but I’m not petty to take it out on a child. However my father knows and mentions it at times when he has a conscience but he uses my sister to show me what I missed out on whenever he is bizarrely going through a mental episode.

He is mentally unstable.. but I put up with it because he was a good father prior to that incident. But having her there makes me nervous.

I just don’t feel like I want to deal with all the disrespect and digs. And I don’t want to hurt my dad who is depressed and tell him I don’t want to see my sister..

But I don’t love her. I tried to but he and her mum came in the way by teaching her to be a snob with me and to continue the abuse. The good person in me tells me to be her good example but right now I’m pregnant and she isn’t my priority, my mental health is.

I suffered severe and serious panick attacks this pregnancy just thinking about what my dad put me through with his family.

Is there a way for me to not let my dad know that I don’t want my sister coming? Without causing drama ? He is way too dramatic

Frankly I don’t feel ready to see him either but he is a dying old man and I am used to his ugly ways but just don’t want to add more people if I don’t need to

OP posts:
Castledweller · 25/07/2019 13:22

OP, how awful for you. Sorry to be blunt but I would probably just go NC with the lot of them!
At least in a step parent situation you would have the motivation to make your marriage work but what exactly are you getting out of this situation other than being treated like shit and constantly put down?
I'd tell neither of them to come. Have you had counselling for all this? You should. You have been treated terribly.
I am a step mum and I would never ever treat my step kids like she treated you.

TheInebriati · 25/07/2019 13:23

You don't owe abusive people anything, you don't owe people who failed to protect you from abusive people anything.

You owe yourself everything. Life is too precious to waste it.

IsobelRae23 · 25/07/2019 13:29

Wow. Just tell him, he is more than welcome to come for a few days, however you do not want your sister there as you are unwell. If he feels he can not come without her, then he does not come at all. No negotiation.

I’m sorry you are going through this, it sounds pretty shit. Concentrate on yourself and your family 💐

MountPheasant · 25/07/2019 13:35

Tbh OP I don’t know why you’re bothering with any of them.

You say you stay in touch because ‘he’s my dad’ but he hasn’t acted like it, he doesn’t deserve your time.

You are pregnant, it’s a perfect time to make hard choices and stop your father treating your child the way he treated you.

If you don’t want to cut off your father, at the very least you WNBU to cut off his daughter. Make it clear to your father that she is not invited now or ever, and if he pushes back point out how rude she is to you. You could also point out his behaviour towards you when she is around and let him know you expect better in future.

Hithere12 · 25/07/2019 13:45

OP Just cut them all out. They are way too toxic and as an adult you do not have to put up with their shit. Your Dad only sees you four days a year and still manages to make nasty digs at you?

I know going NC brings a lot of guilt. I’ve gone NC with members of my family because they were toxic and abusive and I still feel guilty over it. But they don’t deserve you. You sound way too nice and you need to protect your own mental health.

ILearnedItFromABook · 25/07/2019 13:47

You don't owe them anything. I'd severely limit contact with all of them, if not cut them out completely.

Professional counselling seems like a good idea. Definitely don't expose yourself to them if you don't genuinely want to see them. Don't see them because you think you "should" see them.

They should have treated you better; they didn't, and those actions have consequences. And yes, that goes for your step-sister, too. Maybe she'll mature and you'll eventually be able to have a better relationship with her, but at the present, she's not good for your mental health.

gardenbats · 25/07/2019 13:53

I'm sorry but that's so abusive, she sounds seriously unhinged and I would think the healthiest thing for you would be to go NC with them all (I've never said that on here before).

Tighnabruaich · 25/07/2019 13:57

I don't even know why you want your father to visit each year. What's the point? Just cut the three of them out. You will have so much less hassle and grief and anxiety in your life. They don't consider your feelings, so why should you worry about his?

EileenAlanna · 25/07/2019 13:58

If you're happy enough for your father to come & it's only for a few days then by all means go ahead. Tell him that "sadly" you won't be able to have your half sister there because of illness associated with your pregnancy & the doctor's advised that it would be too much for you.
Every time he suggests bringing the girl you'll have a ready made, built in reason to say no without looking like the bad guy.
Your father being there on his own with you sounds like a good thing. Without the other 2 there sniping & being rude it comes down to just you & him being able to get on together as father & daughter. He'll probably notice the contrast in the atmosphere.
You're under no obligation to like your half sister or have any kind of relationship with her. She & her mother will only detract from your quality of life & happiness so keep them away - just don't give them ammunition to use your actions in the wars they seem to be perpetually fighting. Always be "sad" that you "unfortunately" can't have her to stay every time it's brought up.

Hithere12 · 25/07/2019 14:02

EileenAlanna

🙄 This is such bullshit. OP is a grown woman and you’re telling her she has to lie/placate her abusive father? Why should she have to walk on eggshells and make an elaborate story up? She’s the victim of their abuse, she should not be placating these people.

SandyY2K · 25/07/2019 14:21

All this is because of your dad. I can't think why you let him back in your life tbh.

If I was your mum, I'd feel so hurt that you even give him the time of day after how he's treated you. It's really painful to read what you suffered at his hands directly and indirectly.

He doesn't deserve you. Your sister is a red herring tbh.

AcrossthePond55 · 25/07/2019 14:23

I agree with those saying go NC with the lot of them and get yourself a good counselor.

You don't need the stress and guilt they put in your life, not now, not ever. And you do need to work through the issues your traumatic upbringing has left you with.

None of this is your fault and you need have no guilt in saying "NO MORE". What happened to your dad (the accident) is not your fault and you have no responsibility to try and make things 'better' for him or to 'make up' for his 'lost years'. You deserve a happy and healthy life, free from the added stress they bring.

QuickThinkOfAName · 25/07/2019 14:27

To be honest I would go no contact with all of them.

You sound lovely. They have treated you abysmally. Worse than an animal.

Don't let them near you to continue to affect your life. Look after yourself.

sneakypinky · 25/07/2019 14:29

I wouldn't bother with either of them. They've treated you like shit.

Cherrysoup · 25/07/2019 14:34

If you really still want your father to visit, fine, but tell him you don't want your half sister coming and tell him why. You don't have to have anyone you dont want in your home.

NKFell · 25/07/2019 14:46

This is your life OP, don't let anyone ruin it. You've been through enough and this isn't your fault. Your sister is young, it may be that in time she sees the error of her ways and acknowledges her misplaced loyalty, but she isn't there yet, don't give her the time of day.

Louloulovesyou · 25/07/2019 14:46

It sounds like you are their emotional punch bag! And they all get some kind of terrible pleasure from hurting you. You don't owe any of them anything. You are ruining your life by continuing contact. You can have a happier, lighter life without them. Seek counselling to help you move on, I can imagine their behaviour towards you is now so deeply ingrained in who you are, you will need help unpicking the damage and setting yourself free Xx

SavingSpaces2019 · 25/07/2019 14:49

You do realise that your dad ALLOWS this abuse of you?
He even ALLOWS it to happen to you in front of him.
Your dad was abusive to your mum and you - and he continues to be abusive towards you because you allow it.

You have every right to say 'no' to him bringing your sister - and ideally you should be telling him exactly why.
You don't owe any of them anything - your time, money, affections or energy.
Your contact with your dad should happen on your terms only.
You need to stop giving him/them power over you.

Derbee · 25/07/2019 15:17

I would say NC with SM and SS. If your dad won’t accept that, NC with him too. Your mental health is more important. You don’t owe anyone anything

IABUQueen · 25/07/2019 16:01

Wow.. I’m quite shocked actually at the replies. I genuinely for a long time believed I would get replies saying “FFS she is only 10 and you are being immature”. Or “it’s rude to not invite your step mum you asked for it”.

Thank you everyone. I have actually never got this acknowledgement before. This is a great start for my confidence on this subject.

OP posts:
Lucifer666 · 25/07/2019 17:13

Wow OP reading what you wrote is shocking! My heart breaks for you. Why bother keeping these venomous cunts in your life? You dad has sat back and allowed your step mum to abuse you and enable your sister to be the same way he's no better than them they're a match made in hell from the sounds of it. Go no contact for your own happiness and peace of mind its hard but once you do that it's like a weight being lifted from you. I cut contact with my biogical dad for similar reasons he was an abusive drunk and when I finally opened my eyes and saw him for what he was I soon cut contact and I've never regretted it no more walking on egg shells and no more doubting myself and minimising his behaviour. Just tell your dad straight up after all the crap step mum, him and your sister pull you've had enough and they're no longer welcome in your life. Don't bother trying to be a good example to your sister her mother has clearly moulded her into a rotten person which is sad but its no excuse for her to disrespect you in your own home just walk away.

fargo123 · 26/07/2019 06:16

Your step mother is evil. Who hell treats an innocent child like that??
Your dad is absolutely vile and toxic. He stood by and allowed/encouraged you to be abused.
Your half sister is awful and likely to turn out as revolting as her parents.

Cut them all off. You'll feel a million times better for it. I wouldn't even tell them when your baby is born.

It sounds like you're pregnant with your first child? Hopefully you've got a supportive and loving husband. These are your family now. Use this new baby as a chance to start afresh with the family and loved ones who mean the most to you. If you parent the complete opposite way that your so-called parents did/do, then you'll be a brilliant mum. Smile

Kko1986 · 26/07/2019 07:48

I read your post and my heart broke for the little girl you were and the lovely woman you are now

I could cry for you, I can see the torment your mind is in.

You have such loyalty to your dad and after everything he put you through you still love him.
Regarding your sister tell your dad no if he wants to come he can come alone and spend time with you or not at all.
You need to put yourself and your baby first x

IABUQueen · 26/07/2019 19:39

Thank you everyone.

I often wonder how comes my parents didn’t see my grief as a serious reason to take action. And being pregnant now with my own daughter, I just can’t comprehend thinking it’s ok for her to go through that. Must have taken a lot of selfishness to shut down and accept that on your own child.

I’m struggling to find my self worth in all this mess but hopefully will get there soon.

OP posts:
AndNoneForGretchenWieners · 26/07/2019 19:51

I feel sorry for your sister, because she knows no different. She has never been pulled up on her behaviour towards you by her father, and has been encouraged by her mother. She will likely grow up isolated from her sibling arms when her parents have gone she won't have a family to grieve with.

That said, I wouldn't want her around me. PP that have said you should refuse your father's visit, I agree with this. He has lay you down badly here. He has also let your sister down, but that isn't your problem.