Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having Lost Weight, what do I say to this?

60 replies

DamnItAllToHell · 08/07/2019 10:03

I was a size 10 to 12 for years when young. After 4 kids, born over a 20 year span, I ended up slightly into the obese range of BMI and weighed almost 13 stone. My clothes size was variable, which I believe is due to shit sizing by manufacturers these days, and which meant I could no longer say what dress size I was to compare with my youth.

Anyway, afetr a health scare just over 2 and half years ago, my GP offered me 12 weeks free at slimming world, which I took and which worked well. I now hover slightly over into the overweight range, but mostly am at the top end of normal. I am 5ft 4inches tall and weigh 10st 7lb. I have been this weight for almost 2 years and have never exceeded the 3lbs up/down leeway given by slimming world to target members.

I feel healthy (mostly), and I can walk further than I have done in years. Trouble is other people! From my mother (who was never a great mother, so we don't have a fantastic relationship) to people at my weekly hobby group, I have lost count of how many of them have said "don't lose anymore weight, you've lost enough" . My Mother takes this further and says I look haggard and am too obsessed with food and what I can/can't eat.

It's true I do try and be careful. because I don't want to end up back where I was before losing weight, but since I am at the top, the VERY top of normal range, surely IANBU to want to stay around that weight? FFS I could go a lot lower and still be classed as in a normal range!

Can someone please give me some responses that won't make me sound horrible or too defensive?

OP posts:
Roussette · 08/07/2019 12:35

I get what you're saying but coming at this from the other side...

I lost 5 stone, dropped from 18/20 to 8/10. I loved being thin BUT it was not my natural size and I got a bit obsessed. I look back at pics and TBH I look pretty horrendous being 60 ish.

My best friend kept saying do not lose anymore etc and looking back she was right.

However, I have put a lot back on so maybe my view is now a bit skewed!

trackingmedown · 08/07/2019 12:52

We had this a few years ago with my DD. She lost the weight she wanted to lose (not much, just the ‘freshers 7’ that many young people put on when they first leave home) but she couldn’t stop. She became addicted to hunger and calorie counting and exercise and ended up with anorexia. We could see that she was gaunt and unhealthy and haggard but she was blind to it and ignored everything we said for a long, long time.

I’m not saying that you have an EO OP, but just trying to point out that sometimes it’s hard to see ourselves objectively. Someone saying you have lost too much weight isn’t necessarily jealous or manipulative. They might genuinely have your best interests at heart.

Trooperslaneagain · 08/07/2019 13:01

I lost a shit load of weight without trying - ill.

Loads of people kept congratulating me - I looked like shit - I looked old, haggard and gaunt.

So, a bit the opposite of you but similar in that it did my head in. I wanted to scream "I HAVEN'T EATEN PROPERLY IN MONTHS". Managed not to on the whole.

I don't think anyone's weight is anyone else's business. And I bet you a tenner it IS a sabotage thing. Well done x

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 08/07/2019 13:06

I'd go with "My health concerns me more than my looks, so thanks for your input but I'll do what's right for my health"

HisBetterHalf · 08/07/2019 13:10

I find this so rude. If the tables were turned imagine how outraged people would be if you say 'lose some weight, you look fat'

Swolleneye · 08/07/2019 13:15

I had this when I lost a bit of weight a few years ago. I was a comfy size 16 so still overweight but a few people said ‘you look great, don’t lose any more’. I think I carry my weight well and don’t look like I weigh as much as I do, so maybe that’s why. I don’t think it came from a place of malice but it is weird.

mumofthemonsters808 · 08/07/2019 13:42

I wouldn't say anything OP, you don't need to, you look good, she knows this and it makes her feel uncomfortable, she has the problem, not you.

I'm slim, I always have been, but now I'm middle aged I have to work at it and it seems to annoy people, I never speak about my weight or comment on anyones size, but when I bump into people they will for some strange reason start talking about their weight issues, I just nod. I've also been the brunt of harsh comments "Still a skinny bitch then", I read Facebook posts from my friends, all about men preferring curves not bones etc. I don't even rise to it, because I'd rather be in my position than theirs.

You've done amazing.

BatShite · 08/07/2019 13:46

Congratulations on your loss. It sounds like it has done you the world of good and yes, of course its not unreasonable for you to wish to stay within the normal range.

It seems really common for women to get comments about their weight. Be it that they have put on too much, or lost too much. Its just constant. I also get the 'you look ill' type comments when I lose, apparently I lose in my face first and it somehow makes me look 'gaunt', despite being quite overweight at the min. Its odd really.

I have no suggestions about how to answer while being nice. As I tend to give sarcastic replies these days, or ignore it totally. Or sometimes, if they go on and on, snap a bit and tell them to back off.

I would love to know why it seems womens bodies are public property, there to be commented on, and even touched by anyone who fancies it and the woman is stil expected to be nice about it.

Sherry19 · 08/07/2019 13:57

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns and so we've agreed to take this down.

cavalier · 08/07/2019 20:48

If all else fails Just say don’t I look lovely Mum ... .... I have worked so hard to get healthy ... can’t wait to try on new clothes and treat myself .... hope I can be an inspiration and I’ve hopefully extended my life span .....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page