Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mil and DH

32 replies

Mamathebest · 06/07/2019 11:09

So my partner and I have DS (14 months). Since he’s been born my family have been a massive support. They would bring food, help out with cleaning or offering to give me a break when I needed it. They’ve also been a huge help financially and if my mum is coming around she will always have some form of present for DS.

I have little support outside of them and genuinely think I would have suffered from PND without them around for the first year. My partner worked night shifts for nearly 7 months. In that time me and DS barely saw him as he was always working. Once a week I would stay with family (mum and sister, we are very close). Normally take DS out and go out for lunch/shopping etc.

Since DS has been born in-laws have seen him sometimes once a month or longer periods depending on how busy they are. They actually live closer to us then my own parents do. For whatever reason since DS has been little if MIL holds him, he begins crying/screaming. MIL has only babysat 2x. The second time DS screamed for about 2 hours and then passed out. Since he’s seen her after this, he tends to start crying.

I did explain to my partner that it might be because he doesn’t know her well. And that it might be better for MIL to spend more time with him with all of us before babysitting. DH stated that I was being controlling and feels his mum can only have a “real” relationship with DS if I am not present. I find this strange as although I see my family often, I’ve never had to leave DS in order for them to bond.

She doesn’t ever offer to look after DS and rarely comes around to see DGS. Normally it’s my DH that makes the effort by taking DS to her home once a month and inviting her around when she’s free.
MIL stated she would like to spend more time with DGS. I’ve also said she is more then welcome to and knows she can pop around anytime to see him. This doesn’t really happen. I’m not interested in forcing MIL into doing anything she doesn’t want to and have basically left the ball in her court in regards to DS.
My DH seems to think that this is my fault. Apparently DS has spent a lot of time with my family and therefore has a strong preference for them. DH states that I’ve “pushed his family out”. I try to speak to MIL often but she is quite busy as she works full time and her youngest is 10.

It feels as though the responsibility is completely on me to make contact with in laws and arrange contact. Why can’t DH or in laws?

For DS first birthday party I was quite poorly. Family had offered to help out with small arrangements that needed doing. My partner had also asked his mum and sister to help out. DH wanted them to feel included. I thought this was a fab idea. Sister in law offered to come around to do decorations. She never showed up. So me and my sister did this. MIL also stated she would bring food on the day. She showed up 4 hours late after everyone got there.

None of his family bought any presents for DS. I didn’t say anything at all to DH. I could see he was quite upset about it.

This is currently building lots of resentment between DH and I. DH feels DS “ isn’t part of his family with in laws but is very much involved in mine”. I’m getting the blame for most of it. I don’t know how to rectify the situation. If I stop seeing my family as much, this would not increase contact with his family. My DS adores my mum very much and looks forward to visiting. I guess I’m wondering is there anything I can do to improve this situation. Is it my fault?

OP posts:
EKGEMS · 06/07/2019 11:18

Your husband is projecting his anger and disappointment with HIS family onto you! You sound reasonable and level headed. You should just tell your husband that they are welcome to spend time with your son and you'd never do anything to hinder a relationship but you DONT need to be away for that to happen especially if you want to stay. Hopefully your husband can be reasoned with if not just tell him to shove it

Stressedout10 · 06/07/2019 11:20

No its not your fault.
If dh wants his family to have more involvement with ds the it's up to him to facilitate it not you. Be firm and clear with dh that you have made reasonable requests/offers and have been rebuffed by them so now it's all on him/them.
Don't put up barriers though just leave all il contact to him and let him deal with the brush off . Sooner or later he will understand that they are the problem not you.Flowers

TremblingFanjo · 06/07/2019 11:23

Your husband is projecting his anger and disappointment with HIS family onto you This.

PersonaNonGarter · 06/07/2019 11:25

Do you think he has a point at all?

Minai · 06/07/2019 11:27

If you don’t already have a good relationship with dh’s family I really don’t think it is down to you to facilitate contact between them and your ds. It’s your husband’s job to do this. I wouldn’t be leaving my baby with someone he barely knows, especially if he cries and can’t be comforted by them.

Hanab · 06/07/2019 11:31

He needs to make the effort of encouraging his mum to come around and engage with your son. If he can’t clearly see that your son is distressed in his mums presence than he is a twat!

Obviously your son is closer to your family .. they make an effort with him ..

Your H needs a dose of reality! Small steps works wonders with kids 🤷🏻‍♀️

Mamathebest · 06/07/2019 11:33

Thank you for the replies guys. I know I can over worry sometimes when it comes to DS. My partner stated he wants to ask MIL to babysit next Saturday. I have my concerns as like I said earlier DS becomes quite distressed with her. If I say anything to DH about it, he will say I am hindering their relationship. I just wish MIL would get to know DS better before he’s left with her. I don’t have any safety concerns. It’s just that will become hours of DS screaming and quite stressful for everyone involved.

OP posts:
Missingstreetlife · 06/07/2019 11:39

Why doesn't he take dc to visit mil for a couple of hours once a fortnight

Mamathebest · 06/07/2019 11:39

Hi persona- I think that I have probably been more inclined to go to my family before his for support. When I need advice/ help with DS (first child so I have a lot to learn) I tend to go to my mum first. I guess I could have made more effort with MIL. Even before DS I always saw my family more often then he saw his. We come from different cultural backgrounds. In my culture quite normal to spend time with family etc. It’s also pretty normal when someone has a child in the family for everyone to do their bit. I just feel like I’m being punished by DH for this.

OP posts:
Mamathebest · 06/07/2019 11:43

DH also thinks I interfere too much with his relationship with DS and I am too controlling. DS tends to come to me if he is distressed, angry, hungry etc. When DH tries to soothe him. DS begins crying for me. I try my best to hold back but it’s hard to listen to the screams. I do tend to want to comfort/soothe DS in these moments. There have been a few moments where DH has refused to hand him over. As he states DS has to learn that he cannot always have his own way..

OP posts:
Harveywallplanner · 06/07/2019 11:45

it Seems quite a lot from your family, cooking,cleaning, giving you money so maybe they feel whatever they do it pales into insignificance.
Mil works full time and has a ten year old. I actually think you’ve got a bit of a cheek expecting any help from her.

Mamathebest · 06/07/2019 11:49

Actually Harvey I don’t expect anything from MIL. I don’t actually have any expectations from anyone. In fact I always say to my DH that it is understandable that your MIL doesn’t have as much time spare. It’s DH who wants more. My family offer to help. I am not going to say no to them because my in laws might get upset? especially if I actually do need the help.

OP posts:
Apileofballyhoo · 06/07/2019 11:53

Your DH and MIL sound like hard work.

YouJustDoYou · 06/07/2019 11:55

Mil works full time and has a ten year old. I actually think you’ve got a bit of a cheek expecting any help from her

OP never said this. At all. Read the post.

Myheartbelongsto · 06/07/2019 11:55

I think your mother in law is just busy with her own life, she has a 10 year old, me too and they have busy little lives.

I think you're going have to take some initiative here.

DishingOutDone · 06/07/2019 12:05

Oh that's interesting, my ILs only ever wanted to see DD without me being present; I used to say shall we all go to the park or have a coffee and it was a flat no. I never really twigged that this refusal was also part of their "thing". Anyway, we went NC and that worked out really well all round.

Ponoka7 · 06/07/2019 12:06

I can see why your MIL would want to babysit with you not there, if he won't settle with your DH because you take over.

He'll settle better when you're not there.

Let her babysit on Saturday and then work out with DH how things can move forward.

I'd say at around 18 months, the babying should start to be pulled back, so it's a little early, yet.

You should be leaving your DH to try to manage. It would be best to start with you not there.

OKBobble · 06/07/2019 12:08

It sounds as though whilst you are happy for your family to help out you really don't want MIl to help out. I suspect when she is there trying to bond/help/play with your DS you are hovering and thus making your child anxious and now your child associates this with the MIL.

It sounds as though you do this to your DH too with regard to HIS own child.

You need to step back. Perhaps take on board what your DH says and let him perhaps take your child to visit his mum without you, just for an afternoon.

I suspect they feel really pushed out.

Mamathebest · 06/07/2019 12:23

Thank you guys, all opinions help!
In terms of taking a step back with DH and DS. I agree and have been trying to do that more lately. DH didn’t really help out with DS previously and has been trying to do a bit more recently. DS generally enjoys being with DH and they have a lot of fun together. It’s only when he’s ill/hungry/tired that he looks for me. I’m more than happy for DH to take DS to in laws without me. DH just prefers me coming along and does ask.

In terms of letting MIL babysit. Have attempted this before and it didn’t go so well. DS screamed for hours and was pretty hard to console. I’m just wary of attempting it again when MIL hasn’t spent any real time with him since. When MIL has come
Around. I always try to leave DS and her to it. DS cries if I leave the room and refuses for MIL to hold him. I try to stay in the room but not get involved as much as possible. I don’t have anxieties of her being around him (at least I don’t think so!). MIL doesn’t really attempt to play with DS or try to interest him. I think she might feel awkward to do so? Possibly because I’m there or because of how DS behaves.

DS isn’t like this with my family at all. But my family are a bit silly and will try and engage DS in games. In fact he has little interest in
me if he sees DGM! But they’ve spent loads of time together, my mum has come around loads and played with him.

OP posts:
Jux · 06/07/2019 12:27

Just do what you feel is right for ds. I made the mistake of trying to ensure things were 'fair' between mum and MIL re time spent with dd, and that meant that my mum saw far less of her than she had been (and I had much less help and relief), as it seemed that if MIL didn't bother then I wasn't allowed to let mum.....

It was ridiculous. The one who really lost out was dd. Once I twigged that I told dh that it was 'his family his problem'.

foreverhanging · 06/07/2019 12:34

I don't get why he thinks his mum can't have a relationship or bond with your child when you're there. That's completely batshit.

foreverhanging · 06/07/2019 12:37

Also, your ds will want you more at this age. It's completely normal.

billy1966 · 06/07/2019 12:50

Your husband sounds like real twat who's punishing you because his Mum is busy and doesn't have much time.

He needs to bring DS to see his mother if it's that important to him. End of.

Do not in any way allow your husband to limit the time you spend with your family.

They have your back and have been a great support to you.

The way he behaves towards you, you could we'll need them even more in the future!!

Good luck.

Feelingwalkedover · 06/07/2019 13:31

Totally agree with billy1966

Aquamarine1029 · 06/07/2019 14:03

Why isn't your husband trying to foster more of a relationship between his mother and your son? Why are YOU responsible for managing a grown woman's visits? I would inform your husband that you are not his mother's social secretary nor her handler. If she wants to see her grandchild more, that's on her to make the effort.

Swipe left for the next trending thread