Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To cut off my lazy teen's allowance unless he goes to the gym?

60 replies

HitAndHiss · 29/06/2019 10:13

He is 16 next week. He does no exercise. Doesn't do PE at school and all his friends live nearby so doesn't do much walking and school is literally across the road. He is quite overweight (a fair few stone) and whinges about it constantly. He'd like a girlfriend and sulks because he can't get one. Yet he doesn't do anything about it. He has a takeaway every other night if not every night with his mates, they all put money to it and there's loads of them so it's practically free.

Me and DD17 go to the local gym a couple of times a week (not together). I suggested DS joining as well as he'd also get a discount. He scoffed at the idea of going to the same gym as us but said he'd join the one in the next town over which is a short tram ride away, so I said okay. He went a grand total of once in April and I've been paying the monthly fee since, not out of his allowance. He keeps saying "I'll go next week!". Never does, but when I threaten to cancel the membership I get a sob story about how all his mates take the piss and he'll never get a girlfriend and how I can't cancel it. He is a pain in the arse.

I don't really want to cancel the membership as I can see he wants to get fit etc and he doesn't want me to cancel it either, it's just about getting him to go. I've suggested him taking a mate and got an eye roll. DH thinks we should cut off his allowance (30 a month) unless he goes once a week, 4 times a month. The gym he is signed up to is good as you can log in the website and it shows when he's there and how often he's been, so he won't be able to lie to us about going. I'm inclined to agree with DH as it also stops him getting as many takeaway if he doesn't go. I'm sure his mates won't be keen to pay for him/give him bits of theirs after they've all contributed.

OP posts:
newmomof1 · 29/06/2019 10:48

Tell him to get a paper round - he can earn money and get a bit of exercise at the same time.

OP how much of an allowance does he get if he can afford takeaways all the time?

hidinginthenightgarden · 29/06/2019 10:49

It is so hard to lose weight. You have to change your whole mindset and it is so easy to fall back into eat.
Also super hard being the fat one in the gym and walking in feeling like people are looking at you.
Any chance his birthday is coming up? If so I would pay for a block of PT sessions for him so he can learn how to train properly. Some will also advise him on his diet too.

HollowTalk · 29/06/2019 10:49

I know he should be going to the gym but if he's a few stone overweight then he's confronted by that when he goes - it will make him really uncomfortable. It would be better if he had a personal training session at a time when the gym wasn't busy - do you think he'd go to that?

formerbabe · 29/06/2019 10:51

Yanbu.

I think actually putting the weight aside for a moment, I'd treat this more as an issue about motivation and zest for life. His lifestyle sounds like one which could make him quite depressed.

Ponoka7 · 29/06/2019 10:51

No, ypu should cancel his allowance, just the gym membership.

Give him over the Summer holidays to go, then if it isn't used by the end of August. It gets cancelled.

I don't think alienating him from eating with his friends is going to improve things.

How quickly dod he become so overweight? Where you active, not in a gym sense, as a Family? Did he not do any extra curriculum sports?

A young Man's mental health is as important as his physical health. That should be at the centre of any intervention.

Make sure you are listening to him, not just giving solutions.

He might just need to grow up a bit.

Hoggytat · 29/06/2019 10:54

Take him to the gym he wants to go to the first few times.

I've been wanting to sign up to my local gym for over a year. I haven't gone because I'm scared to because I'm fat and unfit. Hearing comments from gym bunnies in my office doesn't help. I'm an adult and know I'm procrastinating and why I'm procrastinating. Yet I still desperately want to go.

Ponoka7 · 29/06/2019 10:54

"Tell him to get a paper round - he can earn money and get a bit of exercise at the same time."

There's no paper rounds where i live, anymore. But at 14, yes, but a fat 16 year old? That's going to further destroy his self esteem.

ifonly4 · 29/06/2019 10:54

Yes, I'd cut his allowance, but give him money as and when he genuinely needs. He can have tea and then meet his friends, or alternatively you could invite them around a couple of times, something like lasagne, bread and salad might work. Also, reduce unhealthly food at home.

Is there anything else he'd be willing to do, swimming, walking, club?

TriptychDebbie · 29/06/2019 10:56

I never had an allowance but I did have a weekend job at 16. Make him take some responsibility for himself. Stop giving him money.

AgnesNutterWitch · 29/06/2019 10:59

The gym membership is obviously useless, as he's not using it and at the moment his social life revolves around eating crap with his mates on a daily basis.

The ideal situation would be if he could kill two birds with one stone and find a social activity that went hand in hand with a healthy, active lifestyle. I'm thinking something like joining a sports team, a running club, martial arts club or a crossfit box. Something where there's social encouragement and where people will notice if you don't show up so there's a sense of accountability.

INeedAFlerken · 29/06/2019 11:02

Cancel the membership.

Cut off his allowance.

No more take away funding. Healthy food at home.

Tell him to start washing cars, mowing lawns, delivering flyers ... earning money and physical movement. If he has a bike, make him use it.

If he whines about the gym membership, tell him the only option is the gym you go to for now, and he must go 2x per week minimum or it will be cancelled immediately.

NotSoThinLizzy · 29/06/2019 11:02

Is there space anywhere for a treadmill or something? Maybe hes embarrased about going?

Weenurse · 29/06/2019 11:07

My youngest is very motivated to exercise. I joke about walking my dog and eldest after work, but she has no motivation to exercise, so we walk the dog together.
Maybe an activity together such as PP have suggested like riding a bike or walking together.
Good luck

Fcukthisshit · 29/06/2019 11:09

I’d cancel the membership and his allowance and pay for a diet club (slimming world or weight watchers) and a mobile personal trainer to come to the house as often as you can afford.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 29/06/2019 11:11

DS1 (15) was heading a bit in the direction of your son and then managed to find a sport he loved - in his case rugby. He now voluntarily goes to the gym following a rugby training plan and has made it into his school team. He is also reviewing his diet and talking about macros.

You may need to find something your DS enjoys to motivate to exercise. He may not really know what to do when he gets there either so either get a personal trainer to do him a plan or get something like this for him
Matt Roberts

James Haskell

Vulpine · 29/06/2019 11:12

Exercise is not just about physical activity, it also has mental benefits. An active life style can lead to eating less over all because you're getting your kicks in other ways. Its a great age to start getting active, a habit that will stay with him for the rest of his life although it doesn't have to be the gym.

Whosorrynow · 29/06/2019 11:16

Lots of blokes would like to build muscle and get lean but feeling confident in the gym and knowing what you're doing in the gym can take some time, perhaps he just feels really self-conscious perhaps he needs a friend to train with?

Namenic · 29/06/2019 11:16

I think I would be doing something similar to what OP suggests but maybe offer a wider range of activities/personal trainer etc. Some people prefer a more skill based thing (eg golf - if there is a public golf course nearby, or cycling, swimming, archery) - that way you can focus on technique rather than just thinking of physical effort. But to get good at these you will also get fit.

Whosorrynow · 29/06/2019 11:17

Another way would be for him to get involved with some kind of group activity or team sport that he enjoys and then he might be motivated to go to the gym to get stronger so that he can be better at the activity

Whosorrynow · 29/06/2019 11:19

A positive role model that he can personally identify with might also help, there are lots of youtube channels devoted to exercise and strength training

cakeandchampagne · 29/06/2019 11:23

Cancel the gym membership.
Are any of his friends active?

cavalier · 29/06/2019 11:24

What about a walk with him for an hour ... if you have time ... or twenty mins there and back .. personally I think the gym is such an overwhelming prospect for some people .. walking is great coz
You can talk at the same time if you want to ...
and yes cleaning the car ... start with walking is amazing how a walk for half hour even can make you feel so much better and energised ... Gym =stress for a lot of people

ShawshanksRedemption · 29/06/2019 11:24

How has it got to the point of him feeling he can have takeaway food so often? As a family we make it a point that we all sit down together each night for dinner and talk about our day. A takeaway is a rarity, precisely because we know it's not great for you if you eat it often.

I would look at how you can support him, not just by paying gym membership. His self-esteem sounds low, and he needs emotional support.

If DS is insistent on gym, could DH take him to your more local one perhaps? How do his friends "work out" - could he join them?

It'll be hard, he's gotten into bad habits, but as parents you need to support him to get him into better habits. At 16, he needs that (non judgemental) guidance from you.

midcenturylegs · 29/06/2019 11:25

Tell with to follow James Smith Academy on facebook and then he can sign up for a free trial. This guy is awesome and very inspiring!

midcenturylegs · 29/06/2019 11:26

Tell *him. Plus if he signs up properly it is MUCH cheaper than a gym membership, and he can do stuff at home.