Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disappointed in hearing that many UK woman drink during pregnancy [shock]

1003 replies

Leati · 18/07/2007 08:16

Yesterday, I was on a thread when some of the women started questioning about US policy on drinking alcohol during pregnancies. One of the women had heard that if you have a glass of wine, you could be arrested. I assured her that wasn't true but there was chance that if you were visibly pregnant that the restaurant or bar might exercise their right to refuse service. And if a pediatrician became suspicious of drug or alcohol abuse, they could have the baby?s blood tested at birth. If the baby is found to have these in their blood, the child will be taken away. Another woman pitched that she found it disturbing that restaurants had signs warning pregnant women.

I couldn't believe what I was hearing. These women seemed to believe it was actually okay to drink during their pregnancies. Hadn't they heard of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. So today, I did a little research and was shocked to learn that it is a big problem in the UK and that there is little education about it there.

Women who are angry over mothers choosing the bottle over nursing are damaging their children by drinking alcohol. This is not minor damage, in some case it is equivalent to severe mental retardation and in others it less obvious cognitive problems. Overall nearly 10% of babies born in the UK are suffering from some sort of cognitive problems directly related to alcohol exposure in the womb.

What broke my heart the most is that I have been on this site and I know that the mothers on this site care so much for their children. That while I may not always agree with everything said and our perspectives are not always the same, that we share a common love for our children. So I felt compelled to start this thread and share the information. I hope that you will share it, with your loved ones and it may spread.

I have attached some sites so you can research this yourself. These sites are both from the UK and the US.

www.fasaware.co.uk/

www.bbc.co.uk/insideout/west/series2/fetal_alcohol_syndro mfaspregnancydrinkinglearning_difficulties.shtml

www.healthychildrenproject.org/glossa ry/

OP posts:
Leati · 18/07/2007 08:35

Not all alcohol related problems are as visible as those with mental retardation. Many children have milder systems.

OP posts:
alicet · 18/07/2007 08:36

Here here fishie!!!

Pixiefish · 18/07/2007 08:36

It's what some children are taught in schools though- I had a youth worker come in to covwer alcohol with some of t eh kids i teach and she said in moderation it was ok. I said it wasn't and went on to say about FAS but she argued that it is alcoholics that get that and moderater drinking is ok.

Bearing in mind that I am on my 2nd preganncy and she has had no kids so is only going on what she was told by some literature whereas I am fairly up to date- being pg at the minute

ladylush · 18/07/2007 08:36

This has been dredged up on mnet before and the anti-alcohol brigade keep citing research which does not at any stage show that one or two units once or twice a week are hazardous.

Katy44 · 18/07/2007 08:37

alicet how did you do that?

FioFioJane · 18/07/2007 08:37

when i had my last two children the midwife advised it was ok to drink EVERY day, as long as it was sensible and within healthy limits.

8 years on, uits drink nothing but midwives are still telling women they can drink as long as its sensibly. As they have done for years.

Its a personal choice and many women go off alcohol anyway. I personally have had a glass of wine or two and not felt guilty.

I have a daughter with undiagnosed special needs (severe) and never touched a drop whilst pregnant with her. In a way I do think this 'research' (ie. none) is a bit silly and this is getting like groundhog day

Leati · 18/07/2007 08:37

I'll tell you what, you google in
How much Alcohol is Safe to Drink during your pregnancy?

Animal research shows that on the cellular level, as little as one dose of alcohol can reduce brain cell adhesion and cause neurological deficits. Human research has been limited, for ethical/legal reasons, and studies conducted on children exposed prenatally to low levels of alcohol have been contradictory. The following are statements from credible sources that unequivocally warn that the only safe level of alcohol during pregnancy is ZERO.
----------------
National Organization on Fetal Alcohol Syndrome:
"No safe time. No safe amount. No safe alcohol. Period."

[NOFAS Cover Page]

----------------
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism:
"While it is apparent that children who meet the criteria for FAS are born only to those mothers who consume large amounts of alcohol during pregnancy, studies have reported neurobehavioral deficits and intrauterine growth retardation in infants born to mothers who reported themselves to be moderate alcohol consumers during pregnancy."

"Clinicians, however, must offer advice to their patients based upon the best available scientific evidence. Although some clinicians believe that recommending total abstention for pregnant women may subject them to unwarranted guilt about drinking small amounts of alcohol, most accept the need for clinical caution. Because we do not know at what point alcohol damage begins, it is prudent to recommend that pregnant women abstain from alcohol."

[NIAAA US Dept of Health & Human Services, Alcohol Alert No.13, July 1991]

----------------
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention:
"Public health concern over the use of alcohol during pregnancy was first signaled in 1981 by the release of a public health advisory from the Office of the Surgeon General warning women who were pregnant or planning to become pregnant to abstain from alcohol use because of the potential risks to the fetus. Since that time the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services issued additional advisories in 1990 and 1995 reiterating that women who are pregnant or planning to become pregnant should not drink alcohol."

[National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities: FAS Prevention Activities ]

----------------
March of Dimes:
"Research shows that even small amounts of alcohol can increase the risks of birth defects. So the safest choice is not to drink at all during your pregnancy."

"In fact, it's best to stop drinking before you try to become pregnant. Three weeks after you conceive, your baby's important organs are already forming. But you may not even know you're pregnant yet. During that time, alcohol could affect your baby's developing brain and body. So if you are thinking about getting pregnant, you should stop drinking before trying to conceive."

[March of Dimes, Alcohol and Pregnancy: Make the Right Choice]

----------------
More from the March of Dimes:
"No level of alcohol use during pregnancy has been proven safe. The March of Dimes recommends that a pregnant woman does not drink any alcohol - including beer, wine, wine coolers and hard liquor - throughout her pregnancy and while nursing.

"Drinking while pregnant can cause fetal alcohol syndrome, a lifelong condition that can include mental retardation, facial abnormalities, stunted growth, and learning disorders. It can also increase the risk of miscarriage, low birthweight, stillbirth and death in early infancy. When a pregnant woman drinks, alcohol passes swiftly through the placenta to her fetus. In the unborn baby?s immature body, alcohol is broken down much more slowly than in an adult?s body. As a result, the alcohol level of the fetus?s blood can be even higher and can remain elevated longer than that of the mother?s blood."

March of Dimes: Drinking During Pregnancy

----------------
United States Institute of Medicine (1996):
"Universal prevention intervention strives to ensure that all members of society understand that drinking alcohol can have hazardous consequences, particularly during pregnancy. The universal prevention message for FAS is a conservative one that encourages abstinence prior to conception and throughout pregnancy as the safest alternative."

[Fetal Alcohol Syndrome: Diagnosis, Epidemiology, Prevention, and Treatment]

----------------
Mayo Clinic:
"When you drink alcohol, it enters your bloodstream and can reach your developing fetus by crossing the placenta. Because a fetus metabolizes alcohol more slowly than an adult does, your developing baby's blood alcohol concentrations are higher than those in your body. The presence of alcohol can impair optimal nutrition for your baby's developing tissues and organs and can damage brain cells."

"Consider giving up alcohol during your childbearing years if you're sexually active and you're having unprotected sex. Nearly half of all pregnancies are unplanned."

[MayoClinic.com: Fetal Alcohol Syndrome]

----------------
Queens University in Belfast (1999):
"The behavioural effects observed indicate maternal alcohol consumption has influenced, possibly permanently, the functioning of the brain and CNS of the fetus and infant. These effects are observed at low levels of maternal alcohol consumption (5-6 units per week) and this raises questions regarding the 'safe' level of alcohol during pregnancy."

[Hepper, P.G. Report on Prenatal Exposure to Alcohol, 1999]

----------------
Wayne State University Research:
"Sixteen percent of the children born in the United States are exposed prenatally to alcohol, making alcohol the most common neurobehavioral teratogen. Whereas the earliest reports of neurobehavioral toxicity related to drinking during pregnancy were described among children of alcoholic mothers, more recent research suggested deleterious outcomes for children who are exposed prenatally to moderate amounts of alcohol. Jacobson and Jacobson, in their review of prenatal alcohol exposure and neurobehavioral development, suggested that even the smallest dose may adversely affect the fetus."

"Maternal alcohol consumption even at low levels was adversely related to child behavior; a dose-response relationship was also identified. The effect was observed at average levels of exposure of as low as 1 drink per week. Although effects on mean scores for Externalizing and Aggressive behaviors were observed at low levels of prenatal alcohol exposure, effects on Delinquent behavior and Total Problem Scores were observed at moderate/heavy levels of exposure. Children with any prenatal alcohol exposure were 3.2 times as likely to have Delinquent behavior scores in the clinical range compared with nonexposed children. The relationship between prenatal alcohol exposure and adverse childhood behavior outcome persisted after controlling for other factors associated with adverse behavioral outcomes. Clinicians are often asked by pregnant women if small amounts of alcohol intake are acceptable during pregnancy. These data suggest that no alcohol during pregnancy remains the best medical advice."

[Pediatrics Vol. 108 No. 2 August 2001, p. e34]

----------------
Center for Science in the Public Interest:
"A recent survey illustrated the need for physician education on "how much" alcohol consumption is "too much" during pregnancy. 41% of physicians placed the threshold for FAS at one to three drinks per day while 38% placed the threshold at one or fewer drinks per day.17 Both opinions directly contradict the Surgeon General's advice that women not consume any alcoholic beverages during pregnancy because of the risk of birth defects."

[CPSI Booze News Fact Sheet: Fetal Alcohol Syndrome]

----------------
Vanderbilt University School of Medicine:
"Laboratory studies suggest that a single drinking binge by a pregnant woman can damage for life the brain of her unborn child."

"Drinking in late pregnancy is really unsafe for the brain... One glass of wine at dinner is unlikely to cause the damage, but we cannot say that any added intake would be safe... The most prudent policy would be to have no alcohol during pregnancy."

[Science News, Vol. 158, No. 2, July 8, 2000, p. 28]

----------------
American Academy of Pediatrics (1993):
"Fetal alcohol syndrome is one of the most common identifiable causes of mental retardation, with a worldwide incidence estimated to be 1.9 per 1000 livebirths. However, when children with less severe manifestations of the syndrome (FAE) are included, the estimated incidence may be as great as 1 in 300 livebirths. Evidence indicates, however, that physicians may not consistently inquire about alcohol use during pregnancy or recognize the full spectrum of the effects of prenatal exposure."

"There is no established 'safe dose' of alcohol for pregnant women."

"The consumption of at least one to two drinks a day was associated with a substantially increased risk of giving birth to a growth-retarded baby."

"While there is remaining controversy about the association between maternal consumption of smaller amounts of alcohol and possible damage to the fetus, current data do not support the concept that any amount of alcohol is safe for all pregnant women."

"Since there is no known safe amount of alcohol consumption during pregnancy, the Academy recommends abstinence from alcohol for women who are pregnant or who are planning a pregnancy."

[Schydlower M et al, Committee on Substance Abuse and Committee on Children With Disabilities, Fetal Alcohol Syndrome and Fetal Alcohol Effects. Pediatrics, Vol 91, No.5 May 1993, pp.1004-1006]

----------------
American Academy of Pediatrics (1998):
"FAS is the leading cause of mental retardation in newborns."

"There is no safe level of alcohol consumption during pregnancy."

"Even one drink risks the health of an unborn baby."

"Pregnant? Don't Drink. Period."

[American Academy of Pediatrics, Fetal Alcohol Syndrome: 10 Things You Need to Know

----------------
American Academy of Pediatrics (2000):
"Because there is no known safe amount of alcohol consumption during pregnancy, the Academy recommends abstinence from alcohol for women who are pregnant or who are planning a pregnancy."

"The Academy supports federal legislation that would require the inclusion of health and safety messages in all print and broadcast alcohol advertisements based on the US Surgeon General's warning: 'Drinking during pregnancy may cause mental retardation and other birth defects. Avoid alcohol during pregnancy.'"

OP posts:
FioFioJane · 18/07/2007 08:39

I will ask you ONE question Leati.

Have you ever met a child with fetal alcohol syndrome (or on the spectrum) that has been born to a non alcoholic mother?

Leati · 18/07/2007 08:39

Read the articles.

OP posts:
FioFioJane · 18/07/2007 08:40

I dont need to

answer my question

mrsmalaprop · 18/07/2007 08:40

I'm so sceptical of statistics like that. How do they know these problems are 'directly related to alcohol'? There are so many variable factors in any pregnancy that it is impossible to pinpoint the direct cause of anything without any doubts.

My son is deaf. I had the occasional drink while pregnant (small glass of wine - maybe once a month), but I also had surgery at 6 months under a general anaesthetic and a whole load of other medication (administered by doctors). How am I to say what individual thing caused his deafness - or is it genetic?

I agree that women in the past have drank all through pregnancy and most people are not suffering as a result. My friend was one of those poor people who had a sudden and unexpected birth having never known she was pregnant. She was a student and had been off her face many, many times while pg and the baby was a perfectly healthy 8lb-er. She was extremely lucky, but it can't be so horrendously dangerous if that's possible - can it?

eleusis · 18/07/2007 08:40

I'm sure you meant well by posting this information. But, it does come across as one step over the nanny state line.

America also has prolems with FAS. And, if I can remember all the way back to my child deveopment psych class at Uni correctly, FAS is caused by a pregnant woman who consumes something like 8 or nine drinks a day. And most of the damage is done in the first trimester (as with most things).

I, personally, don't drink a drop in the first trimest and after that follow the occassional but never more than 2 units at once rule.

Can they really test a baby's blood and take them away after birth?

ejt1764 · 18/07/2007 08:41

So am I, pixie (pg that is) ... but as fishie says:

"The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists says there is no evidence that a couple of units once or twice a week will do any harm to the baby"

I think we will just have to agree to differ on this one ... personally I have a much greater problem with pg women smoking - but I would never lecture them about it, as I treat women as intelligent beings who can make decisions for themselves.

Leati · 18/07/2007 08:42

Have you ever met a child with fetal alcohol syndrome (or on the spectrum) that has been born to a non alcoholic mother?

Yes. Mothers think it is okay to drink. A glass of wine a night to settle their nerves. 7 glasses of wine in any seven day period of your pregnancy is enough to cause severe mental retardation. Lesser amounts are known to cause other cognitive problems.

There several articles that discuss the lack of education amongst midwifes in the UK. Seriously, I am begging you to research it.

OP posts:
Mindles · 18/07/2007 08:42

Fio that's what I wanted to say.

It's anecdotal evidence I know so barely counts, but myself and one of my best friends got absolutely hammered in the beginning stages of our pregnancies because we hadn't realised we were pregnant - shock horror I even smoked cannabis before finding out - and surprise surprise both our babies are absolutely fine.

Ladymuck · 18/07/2007 08:43

Sorry what I find truely shocking is the percentage of women who smoke during pregnancy. Something over a third if IRCC.

alicet · 18/07/2007 08:44

OK Leati.

None of that so called evidence provides and evidence that a couple of drinks is harmful. What you are quoting are the conclusions of the authors without any detail on how they met their conclusions. This is relevant.

I'm sure there is just as much information on Google about what is safe. You can find anything you want on the internet after all.

I will accept the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists anyday.

eleusis · 18/07/2007 08:44

She had an 8 pound baby and didn't know she was pregnant?!?!?!?!

fishie · 18/07/2007 08:44

leati you haven't answered fio's question.

or do you assume that if a woman has consumed one unit of alchol during her pregnancy then her child automatically has fas?

alicet · 18/07/2007 08:45

here here ejt

alicet · 18/07/2007 08:45

Katy44 what do you mean how did I do that? Sorry not sure what you are referring to...

ejt1764 · 18/07/2007 08:45

Leati there is a big difference between 1 or 2 units once a twice a week (RCOG) - and your one glass once a day ...

And where is the statistical evidence? Note, statistical, not anecdotal!

VeniVidiVickiQV · 18/07/2007 08:46

To be fair, there is no real evidence to say that one or two units a week doesnt affect either.

I also wonder whether some folk really do have a good notion of what constitutes one unit of alcohol, or, just how much they really do consume in a week.

More information is definitely required.

mrsmalaprop · 18/07/2007 08:46

Yep - unbelievable isn't it! But I was there and she looked like she had put on a few pounds, but no more than that. Apparently the baby was so far back into her pelvis that you couldn't really see it.

Her periods didn't stop until she was 7 months and she had been to the doctor saying she felt awful and had been told she had IBS. After that, she put all other symptoms down to that. Amazing isn't it!

ladylush · 18/07/2007 08:46

Agree with alicet.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread