Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my MIL is interfering and judging my friends and me wrongfully

78 replies

ShuffleShuffleSpin · 16/03/2019 11:56

My MIL was at a party at my house while several of my mum friends were also there. She stood nearby while several of us had a conversation. Two of my friends are suffering from PND and not doing so well, we all have new babies as well as a toddler or two, and I had recently come out of nursing my family through the flu while having the flu myself. We were all talking about fatigue and exhaustion at one point. I talked about walking around with a 40 degree temp and not being able to sit down while looking after the children while ill and how I had never comprehended how much Mother’s go through until becoming one and becoming so much more grateful for all my own mother must have gone through. We all joked about how tired we were. MIL interjected into the conversation although no one was speaking to her, and said, “If you are going to be a mother, you have to like it!!!” I told her I was sure we all liked being Mother’s and loved our children, but what we struggled with was the build up of fatigue from not being able to rest or sleep and the hyper-vigilance required to keep kids safe. Most of us don’t have extra help so that’s just the way it is. MIL then said, “You must learn to be selfless!” I did not want to push back to explain that I do think most mothers learn to be selfless and taking about being tired doesn’t mean they aren’t. But thought the better of it and just smiled at her and changed the topic. I really think it was the last thing my PND friend needed to hear though, because she struggles with perfectionism as it is. And it irritated me no end. MIL sleeps in when she wants to, has gone on endless holidays this year, and her oldest child is 35. She herself says she has no recollection of what it was like to have small children. And yet she is interjecting into our conversation and saying we must learn to be selfless.

OP posts:
YesimstillwatchingNetflix · 17/03/2019 01:13

Wow what a bitchy thing to say.

Did you step in and defend your friends?

ShuffleShuffleSpin · 17/03/2019 06:35

Wow to all of these comments about hospital care. When my DC were born, I was in a noisy hospital ward with lots of crying babies. Even after recovering from c sections I was expected to stay up all night with the baby. I think the change must have come with emphasising the “breast is best” movement. If you are BF, then they can’t/don’t take the baby away because the mum has to establish milk supply.

About MIL, I also find it strange that she says she remembers nothing about having small children. We actually do have an ok relationship but I have come to expect lack of empathy from her.

In reply to a post above, I did attempt to stand up for my friend who has PND by explaining to MIL that my friend loves her child so much and it’s not that she doesn’t like being a parent but is just really tired from chasing a toddler. It would be like having a job you loved but you are always required to stand most of the day and can’t take a lunch break and must get out of bed at unpredictable times every night. Those types of working requirements would be illegal for an employer to allow, but those are the requirements for a mum to fulfill her roll. MIL saying “a mother must become selfless” was her comeback to my sticking up for my friend, and I didn’t want to engage her in tit for tat further than that.

She was never excluded from conversations. There were plenty of people to talk to. In this conversation she came up and started listening and then interjected. She later told me she was amazed how I put up with so much moaning from my friends.

I was just wondering whether other people thought it sounded like she lacked empathy. Since she is my MIL I am exposed to her quite a bit and it does feel to me that she lacks empathy — in her world she is the only one who is entitled to complain about her issues (and she does). When I’ve mentioned various normal challenges of raising three little ones, she says things like “oh well, it’s just a season”. “It’s just a season” seems to be her favourite “brush it all away” comment. Obviously she is not the one I talk to if I need support but if she asks about my life and I tell her I just find it frustrating.

About grannies helping when babies come along, MIL and FIL planned a month long holiday leading up to my sons birth with arrival scheduled for a few days prior to 40 weeks gestation, and baby came at 38 weeks so they missed the birth completely. My own mum lives in a foreign country so she came to help but it was a number or weeks after the birth.

OP posts:
ShuffleShuffleSpin · 17/03/2019 06:40

PS — to give you an idea of the types of things MIL says, one time when visiting her house she drew a bath for the children. DH felt the bath water and put in our baby bath thermometer and said, “That’s amazing mum, you got the temperature just right for the children” and MIL then turned to me and said, “That is due to experience. Some day, Shuffle, you may be this experienced”

OP posts:
Lost5stone · 17/03/2019 07:15

I was born in 92 and my mum said I was taken away at night. Might have been normal in some trusts.

I couldn't wait to leave hospital with DD after 1 night because I didn't get a minute of sleep with all the other screaming babies so I'm glad they didn't make me wait a week!

Your MIL was insensitive though. You do become selfless as a mother but you don't have to be silent about it

Whereareyouspot · 17/03/2019 07:21

She shouldn’t have butted in but I do find it so irritating listening to mums constantly moan about life.
It’s like the go to topic when mums get together how hard it is being tired and caring for kids etc etc etc and half the time they actually have hugely blessed lives and all sorts of help

I can just imagine the drama of the woe is me with a fever and poorly kids and I was just DYING whilst I had to get little Sebastian some more calpol....

Yes it’s tiring but no one ever promised wouldn’t be and you know it’s a damm sight easier than the vast majority of women around the world have it or previous generations who had to hand wash and shop daily etc.

It’s such a middle class moan it is dull and a bit pathetic and I can see why MIL probably felt irritated although she should have held it in.

Whereareyouspot · 17/03/2019 07:25

why shouldn’t they go on holiday around the time of your birth!!

Half these threads go on about how they won’t let the in-laws visit for weeks whilst they all ‘bond’ and then next breath is moaning that PIL aren’t dashing over offering to clean and shop and hover in the back room while being allowed five minutes looking only access to the previous new baby

Don’t blame her for her holidays.

You sound a bit of a PITA and so do your friends

Nicolastuffedone · 17/03/2019 07:44

And this was a PARTY you say??

FaFoutis · 17/03/2019 07:52

It does sound like she lacks empathy, but then so do most people. The best way to deal with people like that is not to tell them anything, then they don't get the chance to be a dick back at you.

I think the change in hospital care came about because of cost and nothing else. It is ridiculous that we have to care for new babies, alone, straight after having a C-section. I had three and never had any help in hospital.

deste · 17/03/2019 07:52

My eldest is 41 and he was taken away at night,
as was my youngest at 32.

53rdWay · 17/03/2019 07:52

It is a bit unusual that she remembers nothing about raising her own small children. Maybe she’s blocked it out? Still no reason to tell you off for feeling tired though!

My mum and MIL remembered all too well what it was like and were brilliantly supportive to talk to as a result.

53rdWay · 17/03/2019 07:55

Both my mum and MIL had babies in the 70s/80s and they were in hospital for a week at least, babies taken away to nursery overnight. MIL’s hospital with one of them even did an evening babysitting service so you could go out for dinner with your husband Shock MIL said it wasn’t much fun though as she was sore and tired and just wanted to rest.

junebirthdaygirl · 17/03/2019 07:57

I think mothers of that generation weren't as open with one another and kept the best side out. So hearing your conversation she would have been shocked that ye sounded like ye weren't enjoying motherhood. Not realising it was just a big moan and the next day ye got on with it.
I do think you sound like you are prepared to understand all your friends but not poor mil who is coming from a different point of view. She deserves empathy and understanding too.
As for the comment about the bath it can be a bit annoying for us senior moms seeing someone pop out a thermometer to check us out rather than have respect for our experience and knowledge. Respect goes both ways.

Spudlet · 17/03/2019 07:58

I'm 36 and was born in an army hospital. Mum says they took me to a nursery at night and whhen I wouldn't settle for them, they wheeled me into the 'naughty baby bathroom' and left me shut in! She found me there in the morning in a right state and never let them take me away from her again. I really hope that wouldn't happen today!

Your MiL sounds a bit of a tact vacuum... mine was a bit like that. To be honest I dealt with it by being relentlessly positive, no matter how I felt. I saved honesty for other people. My mum was brilliant.

grubus · 17/03/2019 08:08

New mums need to talk with other new mums about their shared experience. After a while, yes it gets boring but when they're doing it for the first time why should they shut up in case other people get bored?

DwayneDibbly · 17/03/2019 08:26

I had my DC last year by c-section in a rural area with a large teaching hospital. Re: the taking away at night, I wonder whether it depends on which nurses you get?

The first night or two DC was taken away so I could grab some sleep and brought back for feeding. By the third night (I caught flu on the ward and also needed a blood transfusion so my stay was longer that it would've been), there was a shift change and all the nurses who'd helped on the first few nights disappeared. No more help at night.

mrsmuddlepies · 17/03/2019 10:40

As I said upthread, I had domino births, in and out the same day (that is what they were called). it was the early 1980's in South West London. There was a much publicised theft of a baby around that time (baby recovered, I think). It meant that hospitals were increasingly reluctant to separate mothers and babies.
I was NCT and was advised not to let my baby out of my sight to the nursery in case they gave my baby a bottle. My teaching hospital was very pro breast feeding though as was my midwife.
i hated being asked for my breast feeding diary. It was just another chore to fill in neatly.

Mememeplease · 17/03/2019 10:51

My newborn slept all through our night in hospital but I didn't get a wink of sleep because of the constant screaming of the baby in the next bed Angry

Being able to moan to our friends gets us through the tough times. As does celebrating the good times. I don't think your mil has experience or understanding of a good friendship so I'd feel sorry for her.

Alsohuman · 17/03/2019 11:09

The thermometer thing is a complete own goal, OP, your husband was incredibly patronising and totally deserved the response he got, in fact I think it was quite restrained.

Marriedwithchildren5 · 17/03/2019 11:22

“That is due to experience. Some day, Shuffle, you may be this experienced”
You totally missed your chance to point out you are married to her son so not to get too cocky as your still working on him for her! Followed by a little laugh. Because obviously its just a joke Grin

Alsohuman · 17/03/2019 12:25

It’s not a joke though, is it? Why do so many of you seem to go out of your way to patronise your mothers and MiLs and credit them with knowing nothing?

FaFoutis · 17/03/2019 12:35

Experience Also.
And the fact that my MIL thinks I can't eat potatoes because I'm vegetarian. That all gay people should be in prison, and that everyone not completely white should 'go home'.

Alsohuman · 17/03/2019 12:44

What’s any of that got to do with childcare?

53rdWay · 17/03/2019 12:46

your husband was incredibly patronising and totally deserved the response he got

Agree with you he was patronising but he didn’t get the response - OP did!

Alsohuman · 17/03/2019 13:04

True.

hammeringinmyhead · 17/03/2019 13:36

My mum in 1984 also had the experience of having me taken away to feed and sleep so she could rest. Comparatively, in 2018, I was woken every 2 hours to feed even though he wasn't latching and on the hour between each of those they woke me to do blood sugar tests. By the time I got home 2 days later having been sent