Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think my MIL is interfering and judging my friends and me wrongfully

78 replies

ShuffleShuffleSpin · 16/03/2019 11:56

My MIL was at a party at my house while several of my mum friends were also there. She stood nearby while several of us had a conversation. Two of my friends are suffering from PND and not doing so well, we all have new babies as well as a toddler or two, and I had recently come out of nursing my family through the flu while having the flu myself. We were all talking about fatigue and exhaustion at one point. I talked about walking around with a 40 degree temp and not being able to sit down while looking after the children while ill and how I had never comprehended how much Mother’s go through until becoming one and becoming so much more grateful for all my own mother must have gone through. We all joked about how tired we were. MIL interjected into the conversation although no one was speaking to her, and said, “If you are going to be a mother, you have to like it!!!” I told her I was sure we all liked being Mother’s and loved our children, but what we struggled with was the build up of fatigue from not being able to rest or sleep and the hyper-vigilance required to keep kids safe. Most of us don’t have extra help so that’s just the way it is. MIL then said, “You must learn to be selfless!” I did not want to push back to explain that I do think most mothers learn to be selfless and taking about being tired doesn’t mean they aren’t. But thought the better of it and just smiled at her and changed the topic. I really think it was the last thing my PND friend needed to hear though, because she struggles with perfectionism as it is. And it irritated me no end. MIL sleeps in when she wants to, has gone on endless holidays this year, and her oldest child is 35. She herself says she has no recollection of what it was like to have small children. And yet she is interjecting into our conversation and saying we must learn to be selfless.

OP posts:
Alsohuman · 16/03/2019 14:59

@Thymeout, as always I completely agree with you.

I’m not sure when postnatal care changed. My son was born 44 years ago and it was definitely a week’s stay in hospital with babies removed at night. Personally I think new mums get a really shit deal immediately after birth now.

mrsmuddlepies · 16/03/2019 15:07

Good post Kurrikurri. I think some posters confuse and conflate time. Lots of comments usually about the 1950s, but how many Mothers or Mils on here actually had babies in the 1950s?
One poster asked how MILS could compare the experience of having a baby back then with having a baby today? it really wasn't that different except for far less awareness of PND. A lot of mothers in the 80's were just expected to get on with it (although they may have felt rubbish inside).

GreatDuckCookery6211 · 16/03/2019 15:16

I get the selfless comment, I think it’s true, we women we can put ourselves last a lot of the time but the other comment was rather tactless given that you were all talking about how hard things were.

I take it you don’t have a great relationship?

FaFoutis · 16/03/2019 15:27

I was born in the 70s. My mother got the week in hospital with me looked after by nurses overnight.

Then she came home and her mother took over. Where was she when I needed her? Playing golf, that's where.

Singlenotsingle · 16/03/2019 16:23

I had ten days in hospital in 1978 with ds1 and they took the babies away to the nursery overnight. They taught us how to bf and how to bath the babies, and they fed us loads to build up the milk supply. Then in 1983 with ds2 it was seven days in hospital.

Marriedwithchildren5 · 16/03/2019 16:33

Id go with the fact she was probably rolling her eyes at the conversation. Every generation of mothers had issues, we have a lot more convenience items for feeding, and changing. There is far more support with pnd and there is also parental leave.

Thymeout · 16/03/2019 16:38

Thanks Almosthuman - and the same to you.

I had my babies v late 60s to mid 70s. 2nd baby was a home-birth - that was the default at the time, 3rd might just as well have been, but I knew what I was doing by then. My dd and dil are fed up with hearing about how well new mums were looked after in hospital, jugs of foaming hot coffee/chocolate brought round for elevenses and nightcaps. When I went to visit my dd, all she'd had to eat was a small dried up baked potato and a spoonful of baked beans. She had to make her own drinks.

I don't think there was much paternity leave. My dh certainly never took any. Grannies expected to be asked to help out, but we were rested when we got home. There seemed to be more home visits from midwives and health visitors really knew their stuff. And then there was the weekly clinic at the church hall, with a doctor in attendance if you were worried, the HV for routine advice and the chance to socialise. I think the change came with Thatcher and cuts in public services.

It wasn't all good. All the faff with washing nappies and fewer appliances. You couldn't wheel your pushchair on to a bus. And fathers weren't nearly as hands-on with either dcs or housework. But the biggest change was the decline in SAHMs. We were hard-up but you didn't need 2 salaries to buy a house. There wasn't the pressure to make the most of maternity leave and to beat yourself up if you weren't enjoying every minute.

Sickofthemoaning · 16/03/2019 16:40

@ShuffleShuffleSpin so you invite your MIL to a party, no one speaks to her and when she attempts to join in a conversation you look down your nose at her? It’s not the MIL who has the problem!

BackInTime · 16/03/2019 16:57

I agree that your MILs comments were tactless but then again tactlessness is a MIL specialty. It would have been better to perhaps to have offered some words of wisdom to the mums, to be kind to themselves and to not try and live up to impossible standards.

BadHairDyeDay · 16/03/2019 17:05

Ok so clearly my Health Authority different. Just assumed it was the norm in those days 🤷‍♀️

GiantKitten · 16/03/2019 17:22

2 of my kids are 34 & 31 - born by CS in hospital, but moved to maternity home at 3 days, & stayed there for 4 more, with lovely meals in a dining room & everything...

Anyway, they were taken away at night! So it did happen, even more recently than 35 years ago. (For some reason I literally can't remember what happened in the hospital - it was a nasty old Victorian place with huge wards so I think I've blanked it out)

No excuse for your MIL though, OP. She definitely needs empathy classes Hmm

FaFoutis · 16/03/2019 17:30

I would have LOVED the taking away overnight thing.

ALongHardWinter · 16/03/2019 17:33

With regards to the PPs saying that they'd never known anyone who had their babies taken away at night in hospital,so that the mothers could get some sleep,my own DM told me that this always used to happen in the 50s and 60s! She had my oldest brother in hospital in1955 and said that all the babies were removed from the ward at night. She also spent 2 weeks in hospital after giving birth,despite not having any complications. When I had my DD nearly 36 years ago,in 1983,this practice had been abolished. My DM was horrified surprised that they didn't take the babies away at night. Also that I only spent 7 days in hospital.

BertrandRussell · 16/03/2019 17:39

“I agree that your MILs comments were tactless but then again tactlessness is a MIL specialty.”
Really? You might as well say that tactlessness is a woman over 55 speciality-because most of them are mothers in law! Including your mother......

Weirdpenguin · 16/03/2019 17:52

Your MIL was tactless. Not all MILs are tactless. In the late 70s early 80s I had 4 days in hospital with first baby ( not taken away from me at night) and was out the same day with 2nd baby, No paternity leave for DH so was on my own. Odd that she has no recollection of what it was like to have young children. I would think most people would remember clearly and therefore feel sympathetic.

Accountant222 · 16/03/2019 17:59

I had a baby in 1981, was in hospital 4 days, unfortunately the babies weren't taken off us at night, they screamed the bloody place down all night long, I was glad to be home, at least I only had one screamer with me.

GreatDuckCookery6211 · 16/03/2019 18:19

Where’s the OP?

GiantKitten · 16/03/2019 18:21

Maybe she has a life & will be back later?

GreatDuckCookery6211 · 16/03/2019 18:27

Why so snippy?

DonaldTwain · 16/03/2019 18:29

I’d be inclined to tell her that being selfless also involves not venting stupid fatuous opinions that might cause hurt or offence, but then, I’m not a very nice person.

TheStarOnTheChristmasTree · 16/03/2019 23:09

I had DD1 in 1996. I had her in a small midwifery unit, stayed in 7 nights and had DD1 taken away each night except the first night when I chose to have her with me. I was woken up to breastfeed and each time a midwife made me tea or hot chocolate and provided biscuits or toast whilst keeping me company. The midwives looked after the babies whilst all the mums ate together in the dining room for each meal. They even brought us hot chocolate and toast to our beds for supper and looked after our babies if we wanted to get a bath or shower. It really made a difference to recovering from the birth. The unit closed down soon after so I didn't have that lovely treatment for the next 2 DC and it took a lot longer to recover from the births.

Sashkin · 17/03/2019 00:29

DM stayed in for two weeks with me (1979), and seven days with DBro (1983). Babies taken up to the nursery at night both times. Different hospitals, one in Yorkshire one in Berkshire. So practice obviously varied.

bumblingbovine49 · 17/03/2019 00:45

It is more like 50 years since mother's were kept in after a birth. I am 54, was born on 13 Dec and my mother came home on Christmas Eve with me from hospital. I was not an easy birth ( forceps) but there were no other complcations but my mother had 10 days in hospital before coming home. She had a shorter stay with my younger sister so.ot must have been beginning to change even in the early 1970d

Choccywoccyhooha · 17/03/2019 00:55

My mother stayed in for a week with both me (1978) and my brother (1981). She still speaks wistfully of the lovely cottage hospital where she had my brother with so much care and attention, she said it felt like a holiday.

mumwon · 17/03/2019 01:13

Only reason I stayed in longer was because of heavy bleed after prolonged breech delivery & dc being in intensive care overnight - 1 night the rest of my stay I looked after her - notwithstanding issues - please don't generalize

Swipe left for the next trending thread