Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to let DH drive her home?

61 replies

teenytinypontypine · 18/10/2018 22:01

I think my friend is lashing out a bit due to grief because I genuinely don't think we have done anything terrible, but my friend had a proper shout at me earlier because I let my husband drive her daughter back to our house. The whole story:

This couple have been our friends for many years, more specifically the husbands have been friends for nearly 30 years. They have an 18 month old daughter, we have a 4 year old and a 6 month old. We are named to be guardians of their daughter should anything bad happen to the parents. We are close, but not so close that their daughter would be totally comfortable with us - mum is a SAHM and spends (obviously) an awful lot of time with daughter and daughter is a little clingy. Not unusual for her age.

My friend got a call yesterday morning to say her mum had been taken into hospital with a serious condition and may not survive. She was in a hospital about 3 hours from where we live. Friend called me in a panic, asked me to have her daughter so they could drive straight up there. Obviously I said yes, I came to their house, they left distraught and in a big hurry.

The afternoon looking after the daughter was OK, she was quite upset at being left with me and my kids but distractible and had her own toys etc. Got a call from friend's DH about 6pm saying they weren't coming back that night as the mum was very poorly and they were going to stop treatment, mum likely to die overnight. Obviously, utterly utterly awful. I said no problem, will take daughter to ours for sleepover, whatever they needed us to do really. There was no objection to us taking her to ours at all.

When my DH finished work I got him to come to their house to help. Our two kids have isofix car seats that we have never taken out of the car since they were fitted. Friends had left their daughter's car seat, which could be fitted with a seat belt. So I put our kids in my car in their seats, DH put their daughter in his car with her car seat. We drive virtually in convoy back to our house about 20 mins drive away.

Bit of a rough night as expected, their daughter clearly upset at not having mummy and daddy and being in a strange place, but we did eventually get some sleep.

Friends called this morning to say that yes sadly mum had passed in the night but they were heading home and friend's brother was taking care of things. A few hours later they arrive to collect their little one and I just describe what we did in the afternoon and evening, including mentioning in passing that we had been slightly flummoxed about how to put her car seat into DH's car but we got there in the end.

My friend then looked all incredulous and wide eyed and shouted that she should have been with me as I was the one who had said yes to taking responsibility for her. I explained that I could virtually see DH's car the whole way back, and also apologised saying I hadn't realised she would feel strongly about it - it just seemed the most sensible and obvious way to get all three kids home, given my car has the fixed seats in it and couldn't have fitted the third seat (OK technically could have gone on front passenger seat but I don't know how to turn off the airbag). She calmed down a bit but they left shortly afterwards, without her thanking me (though they had been very effusive in their thanks when they first arrived) and was really frosty. Her DH just looked a bit blank, so I'm not sure whether he thought it was an issue or not.

Do you think she was just stressed out by grief and blowing things out of proportion a bit? Or WIBU to put her kid in my DH's car for a 20 minute car journey?

OP posts:
chocatoo · 19/10/2018 00:44

If she is happy to entrust her child to your care she has to accept what you decide is best. In those type of circumstances my DH and I come as a package. So if your DH had cooked for you all, would she say that only you should cook for child. She is being ridiculous. I expect she is tired and taking out her grief on someone she knows she can lean on.

HelloSnow · 19/10/2018 00:46

Only thing that has crossed my mind OP, has your DH has any issues with speeding or been in an accident? Anything like that which might have contributed to her wobble about DD going in his car?

BTW I don't think you've done anything wrong at all and your solution was the most logical one. If her DD had been upset then it may have occurred to you at that point to swap cars, IYSWIM, but it wasn't necessary as her DD was fine.

OhDearGodLookAtThisMess · 19/10/2018 08:47

Why on earth would you have suggested to your dh that you should have driven this child, rather than him? What message would that have given him? That you didn't trust him either?
Ridiculous. Not sure I accept the "grief talking" argument, either. I lost a parent recently, in horrid circumstances (not that there are often "nice" circumstances) but I sure as hell wouldn't have let rip at a friend like this.
Sure, I'd let it pass for now, but I'd be a bit wary in future.

longtompot · 19/10/2018 11:03

I guess the only other way to do it was you have your friends dd in your car with one of your kids and the other child who uses the same size car seat as friends dd go in your dh car.
I also think it was grief talking, and I am sure she didn't mean anything by it. Like you said, if you are both named guardians in case of their deaths, then they must have a bit of trust in you. Both of you.

MaxTeyon · 19/10/2018 11:14

you switch the airbag off for children sitting in the front either forward or backward facing until the child is at least 12. the force of the airbag would shatter the small fragile bones in a child's face.

You NEVER turn the airbag off for a forward facing passenger. Only for a rear facing car seat.

user1981287 · 19/10/2018 13:39

www.childcarseats.org.uk/choosing-using/airbags-and-child-seats/

This is the guidance re children in the front seat. It entirely depends on the individual vehicle whether its safe to have the airbag on when children are forward facing on the front seat.

user1981287 · 19/10/2018 13:40

You NEVER turn the airbag off for a forward facing passenger. Only for a rear facing car seat.

So this is completely wrong I'm afraid.

GreatDuckCookery6211 · 19/10/2018 14:23

Have you spoken to your friend today OP?

Lethaldrizzle · 19/10/2018 15:46

Grief is not an excuse

teenytinypontypine · 19/10/2018 22:41

greatduck not directly, but I think we are OK. Her DH sent round a group WhatsApp to update all our group on what was happening (they already knew from a phone call yesterday, this was just to say they were going down to where mum lived for a few days to sort stuff out). I replied that I was thinking of them and offered again to help if there is anything I can do. He replied to thank me for the emergency childcare and to say she thought the flowers were lovely.

So I am just going to leave it, really. I always was, of course.

They will no doubt have a horrible and busy few days coming up sorting things out, so I will maybe send the occasional "thinking of you" message and see if she needs anything when they get back home.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page