Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To make her go?

57 replies

IAmLordVoldemort · 28/08/2018 18:38

DD is 3.5. She’s a wee angel, very well behaved generally. However, she’s very cautious. Always has been. She was never a climber as a baby, she isn’t much of a fan of running about wild. She likes to read, imaginative play with her dolls for hours etc.

I have signed her up for a few classes as this is her last year before school and im keen to build her confidence a bit. She also goes to nursery three days per week. She loves it there but staff say she’s quite shy and a bit timid.

Anyway. One of these classes is a swimming class. I think confidence in the water is important. She had her name on the waiting list for these lessons (which are well sought after) for ages and has now done two of them. She seems to enjoy them when she’s there.

However, at the very end of the last lesson the instructors had the kids (four of them, all same age as DD) jump into the baby pool (pretty much into the instructors’ arms). DD did it at the time, after some persuasion, but told me afterwards that she didn’t like it.

Now she’s saying she isn’t going back tomorrow. Doesn’t like swimming and that’s it.

I know that she’s only 3.5 and has years ahead of her to learn to swim. But tbh I’m not sure what the best thing to do is. They are great lessons and the other kids all love them.

She does this quite often, will enjoy something then something minor puts her off. In times gone by o have just let it go. She didn’t like ballet so we didn’t go back to that, for example. I just want her to enjoy herself.

But this class seems like such a good wee opportunity for her. DH thinks we should persuade her to go but I’m just not sure.

OP posts:
witchy89 · 31/08/2018 18:58

I would talk to the teacher and say that she wasn't keen on jumping in. I never learnt to swim because I was terrified of water. The actual swimming wasn't so bad and I did try hard, but at the end of our lessons the teacher would make us all line up at the side of the pool (adult pool, and I've always been short so the water came up to at least my shoulders) and squat down holding on to our knees, and she would come one by one and push us into the water. It used to freak me out so much that I never gained any confidence in the water. I think it's best to ease a kid into something that scares them, not just throw them into the deep end (literally!). There's a difference between not enjoying something and being genuinely scared of something!

witchy89 · 31/08/2018 19:00

I forgot to say, I really regret never learning to swim and wish that my mum had recognised my fears and found me a more compassionate instructor! So I would say stick at it!!!

newmumwithquestions · 31/08/2018 19:06

Agree with all the other posters saying take her but just don’t make her jump in.
My DD is the same. We tried and stopped 3 different classes and switched nurseries because she didn’t like things.
I persisted with swimming. She was the one crying by the side of the pool too scared to go in. New costume and wetsuit helped. Bribing with chocolate helped more. It was 3 weeks of awfulness and she decided she did like it after all.

newmumwithquestions · 31/08/2018 19:07

Oh just to add we switched swimming instructor too - but it sounds like it was the bit at the end not the whole lesson for your DD so not sure if you need to do that

garethsouthgatesmrs · 31/08/2018 19:14

I see that she was poorly so this week you didn't go but I second everyone who has said you should take her. My DS is nervous about things the instructor used to hold his hands to jump in and he was ok. He was like your DD in that one tiny little thing could put him off something he used to love so for example when his teacher was off one week and the other teacher told him to listen more carefully because he was daydreaming missed an instruction he didn't want to go back and hated swimming.

Can I ask, those of you with nervous children like my DD... does it ever frustrate you?

Yes it's very frustrating. My DS hates the soft play parties and at 3 he would only join in with things if his 2 little friends were there (they were my friends children he had known all his life) otherwise he would sit with me. Now he is better but still doesnt join in with things like school discos and kids club's or holiday club's. He is nearly 8 now and he won't join a sports club after school or anything we suggest he just wants to come straight home after school. We have got him to beavers though which has been amazing for his confidence so I would recommend that or rainbows.

, 3.5 is too young for 'proper' swimming classes, these are (I am assuming) baby/water confidence/play classes

(If they aren't take her out as she is too young, most places won't take them for proper lessons until they are 4-4.5)

This is nonsense my DD could swim a width on her front before she was 4. She attended lessons from age 3 and mother and toddler swimming for a year before that.

garethsouthgatesmrs · 31/08/2018 19:15

I mean clubs not club's

TheDowagerCuntess · 31/08/2018 19:33

This thread has been posted on FB by Mumsnet, and there's one comment from someone saying they never learnt to swim, and it doesn't matter, because all they need to do is avoid water!

What a life! Thanks, but I'd rather be able to take my kids to the beach, on holiday, boating, snorkeling, jet skiing - whatever - and not have to panic if they got into a bit of trouble, because I couldn't swim!

Can't imagine having to completely avoid all water-based scenarios forever, and keep my kids away too.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page