These are all from PIL to either myself or DH
A soap on a rope ( only very very slightly used)
A bag of pasta ( regular, quills from Safeway in their savers range)
A box of out of date M&S shortbread. The date had been scratched off the tin. We knew they were out of date as a) they were soft and b) we had dear nephew staying with us when we opened the two weeks after receiving them. He recognised them as having given them to PIL three years prior.......
A cookerybook. Used. Containing a phone bill from my BIL . MIL had bought it from a charity shop for BIL birthday 5 years previous. She had simplygone to their house, whipped it off the shelf without asking or to his knowledge and wrapped it for me.
A lovely nail care kit in a china bowl. We had given it to her for mother’s day three years before.
A Christmas ornament with the year 2002 painted on it. She gave it to me for Christmas 2011.
Baby clothes from a charity shop that were all bobbly and a teeny bit stinky. They were binned. ( BIL son got £3000 so it’s all in the same ball park. Sort of)
A book of hypnosis on how to loose weight. It was newthough!
I’m sure there’s more.
I think the soap on the rope (first present ever fromthem ) should have given me a clue!