Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want tawdry tat?

78 replies

Southfields · 25/06/2018 19:29

I'm very fussy and picky about what I have on display in my home. I'm a minimalist and what few ornaments and pictures or other things on the wall are very carefully chosen, tasteful, pleasing to my eyes and they match the style I have created. All my crockery is a matching set and my kitchen cupboards have no space left for assorted, non matching bits.

The problem is, kind-hearted, well-meaning people keep buying me nasty, cheap-looking tawdry tat, like badly-painted resin representations of robins or hippos, cheap looking tat wall hangings, hanging signs with unamusing writings on them, and ugly pottery mugs or jugs, cow-shaped milk jugs.

My own family and friends were bad enough, but now I have a Latvian flatmate who has zero aesthetic sense of what is tasteful and what is tawdry. I have told her -gently, kindly, and with an appealing smile - that I have enough art and crafts in the house and there really isn't room for more, but she will not desist. Her mum and sister come to stay twice a year and to say "thank you" they are bringing me nasty, tawdry looking plastic or resin "souvenirs from Riga" - ornaments, stuffed toys, badly painted pictures, and fridge magnets.

I hate fridge magnets and would not have one. However, once about ten people had bought me one and stuck it on my fridge, everyone now thinks I collect them and buy them specially, and there are now about 100. It's a job to find the blooming handle!

Every now and again, when I am cleaning, and feeling guilty AF, I slip the most tawdry ornament into the bin, pushing it well down underneath the kitchen waste so she won't see it. In this way, I am getting gradually rid of them. But sometimes my flatmate asks where an item is and I have to tie myself in knots apologising for accidentally knocking it over and smashing it :-( Sometimes she has replied, not to worry, I will get my mum to bring you a new one! Aagghhh!

My DB and DSIL bought me the most disgusting piece of tasteless tat: it was a huge, heavy, badly-painted resin bundle of birds ornament, complete with a tacky water feature, which played a jingle and spouted water whenever you clap your hands. I had to remember to get that out, every time they visited, for 3 years until one day I pretended that my butterfingers cleaner had smashed it.

I cannot be the only one who has faced this. How do you handle it without hurting people's feelings? How do you stop them from buying stuff, and if they take you by surprise, or still bring stuff, how do you get out of having to put it on your mantelpiece or wall?

OP posts:
LighthouseSouth · 25/06/2018 23:34

*that not tat
Best autocorrect I've ever done Grin

ThistleAmore · 25/06/2018 23:42

My PiLs (who are genuinely lovely people) have gifted us not one, but TWO A7/A8-sized canvasses of pics of me and the OH together from pics one or t'other of us have randomly stuck up on FB.

I mean...apart from anything else, how insanely narcissistic would it be to hang wall-sized photos of yourself around your home?

I am a pathological declutterer, with very firm one-in-one-out rules, whereas the PiLs are chronic hoarders. They're not terribly well-off, either, and these bloody albatrosses that they've presented us with wouldn't have come cheap.

I would rather chew my own leg off than display them, but I'm also the product of an upbringing that means you smile, grit your teeth and say 'how lovely!' when somebody gives you a gift

I really, REALLY have to get my big girl pants on and deal with this before we end up with a musical fountain with our own faces displayed in gilt on them...

CoughLaughFart · 26/06/2018 00:08

It’s amazing how clueless people are too. An old friend of mine received a very 80s country pub painting from her dad and was told ‘You could move the mirror over the fireplace’. She’d had the mirror specially designed to fit that space.

You’d think, on the basis of that, she’d understand. But no. She bought me a nice, but tiny, mirror as a housewarming gift. She complained I’d ‘downgraded’ it to the hallway. It fit the colour scheme there perfectly and was the right size for a small wall. She expected me to make it the centrepiece of my lounge, despite it being tiny compared to the wall she expected to see it on Confused

condepetie · 26/06/2018 01:02

Your poor "flatmate". Is she a flatmate or a lodger? Why is she not allowed to decorate the space that she pays the same money as you for?

condepetie · 26/06/2018 01:03

You should think about getting a place to yourself if you don't want the dreaded OTHER PEOPLE cluttering up your space with the things that they like.

Whether you were there first or not.

You sound vile and I'd hate to live with you.

Whereismumhiding2 · 26/06/2018 06:18

Lol OP!!

And what a fab idea for any ongoing MB's thread..
Maybe posters could set up a MN swap shop

I do love an AIBU thread where it has such a simple answer. YANBU. Don't display them, simply regift or drop them off at charity shop or send in for school fayre. One person's tat is another's treasure.

If it is your flat, then if flatmate rents from you, say she can display what she likes in her rented bedroom but rest of flat is minimalist. She knew what she was renting when she moved in. Or you could find a small shelf for her. I don't know any minimalist person who wouldn't feel irritated by what you describe!

I'd bin all the fridge magnets or put in a bag for charity shop straight away, voila clear fridge!! People get the hint when they see your blank fridge & they are never put up. And also get the hint when their gifts aren't on display. These things multiply otherwise.

I'd say thank you at the time but then just say 'yeah sorry it's not really my style but my friend/colleague liked it' if they ask later where it is. It's your home and you choose.

You don't have to apologise for wanting the home you pay for to look how you want it to. Mostly people wouldn't ask though but silently make a mental note.

Now ... I have endless tat made by kids which is dotted around, and I really don't live in a stylishly decorated home, but even I bin or charity 'not-our-tat' tat I'm given! Work colleagues are very used to me taking in twee "toiletries sets" or glass baubles, boxes of liquor candy to give away... Wink

Whereismumhiding2 · 26/06/2018 06:20

Ugh, I meant ..

And what a fab idea for any ongoing MN's thread..
Maybe posters could set up a MN swap shop Grin

NigellasGuest · 26/06/2018 06:37

Whenever I've been given stuff I don't like, I just say thank you (with an appealing smile) and dispose of it after. I don't feel this compulsion to display gifts when people visit. I can't imagine anyone being so rude as to demand when visiting me "Where's that resin gnome I gave you for your birthday 6 years ago?"

EarlessToothlessVagabond · 26/06/2018 06:41

I suspect people are buying you the tawdry tat on purpose and then laughing at you behind your back.

Bluelonerose · 26/06/2018 06:52

Oh god my mil does this. I have a whole shelf dedicated to what she thinks I collect Hmm

MissusGeneHunt · 26/06/2018 07:05

@ANON12345ABC what a marvellous idea... Can we get Noel Edmunds to run it? Should only be allowed though if we all get a tawdry tatty Posh Paws to put up in our drawing rooms...

I'm half with you on this one op, but also I think there's a simple solution... Charity shops or car boot sales.

Undercoverbanana · 26/06/2018 07:05

I’m with you OP. I hate “stuff”. It makes me itch.

RJnomore1 · 26/06/2018 07:15

This thread needs Saltire and her tales of her MIL gifts but I haven't seen her for ages.

I'm with you op I hate tat abd nicnacs.

crispysausagerolls · 26/06/2018 09:13

ThistleAmore

hahahaha oh my god!!!!!

Tara336 · 26/06/2018 10:30

Funnily enough I was chatting to my neighbour about this kind of thing this morning! Luckily no ne buys me stuff like this and I’d hate it too but I wouldn’t be so rude about something someone has been kind enough to buy (even if I hate it) just don’t display it and slowly people will take the hint. Personally I hate ornaments and clutter I just like nice photos in a nice frame on display and that is it.

RoseWhiteTips · 26/06/2018 10:46

OP, you should know that matching crockery is pretty unstylish...

Southfields · 26/06/2018 11:54

whereismumhiding2

"If it is your flat, then if flatmate rents from you, say she can display what she likes in her rented bedroom but rest of flat is minimalist. She knew what she was renting when she moved in."

I think a lot of people on here misunderstood me.

She does not want this stuff in her own rooms or shared rooms. She buys this stuff for me to put in MY rooms, the rooms we do not share.

----------

The replies have given me a LOT of laughs. Thanks! And in between, some kind ladies have assured me that yes, it's OK not to display stuff that I do not find visually pleasing. I was looking for reassurance that it's not rude to endure nasty looking stuff that people with no taste buy you.

OP posts:
Southfields · 26/06/2018 11:58

condepetie

You are clearly one of the nasty, bitchy trolls I was warned about when I joined MN.

All your future responses to any of my posts will be ignored.

OP posts:
TuTru · 26/06/2018 12:01

I’ll have it, I love all that shit!

Southfields · 26/06/2018 12:30

Will everyone who wants some of my tawdry tat please form an orderly queue.

OP posts:
aliceinwonderlandbrum · 26/06/2018 13:02

Very funny thread!

clairethewitch70 · 26/06/2018 13:58

@ThistleAmore - I would keep them in the drawer, they are only about business card to postcard size 2-4 " (A7/A8) Grin

Whereismumhiding2 · 27/06/2018 00:59

@Southfields
Oh my goodness. Though I was saying flatmate renting a room from you in your flat, shouldn't display tat trinkets in rest of rooms as she knew you were minimalist in flat before she moved in and she has her room for that.... it's even worse that she wants you to display her (kindly meant) tat on YOUR private rooms!! Neither is ok!! YANBU!!!

I hope enough MNers have supported you , in a lol way sharing their horror tat stories, that it really is ok to have your home as you like it without ugly tat you don't want. Say thank you to tat gifts and quietly disappear those unwanted gifts.... They'll learn...

Oh yeah, we all spotted the troll entire earlier, immediately before my previous post!!!

As a smart Madagascarn Penguin said, "Smile & wave boys...smile and wave" Grin

Prawnofthepatriarchy · 27/06/2018 02:25

I've never heard of anyone being given this amount of unwanted tat. Sounds like you may have a bit of a reputation in your circle, OP. It's gotta be a wind up.

BoomBoomsCousin · 27/06/2018 02:40

If I were you OP, I would have a massive clear out. Get rid of the lot of it and announce at any reasonable opportunity that you have decided to try and make your environment less busy and will be taking it all to a car boot sale on X day, friends are welcome to claim anything they love. Take all the magnets off the fridge. Put all the pig ornaments in a box. Collect together all the tat you don't like. Let people take anything they want, then on x day either go to a car boot sale and try and sell it or drop it off at a local charity store/the council dump and go for a cocktail. If anyone suggests buying you another fridge magnet /etc. just say something "Oh thank you, that's thoughtful, but I've stopped collecting those, they started to annoy me." And when someone does, inevitably, bring you more tat smile, thank them and then put it in a bag to go to the charity shop the next time you're passing. Let your flatmate know your (to her) changed approach to ornaments is a something you love.

YADNBU to want to get rid of tat! I wish I had a roommate I could lay down the law to instead of a family I have to negotiate with!

Swipe left for the next trending thread