Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument with BIL aibu

55 replies

Familyfeud22 · 30/05/2018 21:53

Name changed as very outing.

Was round STBBIL and SIL's a few weeks ago (DFiance's brother and his wife) with MIL and other BIL where lots of wine was consumed. Me and SIL were chatting outside when BIL comes out and demands SIL comes inside to get their child a drink. BIL is someone who doesn't do a lot for his children, which SIL frequently moans to me about. In my drunken state, my mouth opened before my brain registered and said Maybe BIL should parent his own children.BlushBlush now I do agree I should have just kept quiet here.
However, BIL retorts saying me and DFiance wouldn't know because we don't have children and it was my fault that I had a miscarriage last year. Cue lots of upset and me storming out with DFiance and his mum.

BIL messages me the following morning saying he is sorry we argued but he didn't say it was my fault I lost my baby and he would never say that. I replied two weeks later because I was upset that he was denying it and didn't want to say something else I regret. I replied saying I'm sorry as well and that we're all good.

Fast forward to now (3 weeks after the event), it's mine and DFiance's engagement meal. BIL and wife aren't coming because he says replying 2 weeks later isn't good enough and it's too little too late.other BIL agrees with him, although I don't know what version of events he has been told and he left before this happened.

Now I just really need some advice mumnetters :( I don't want there to be an on going rift between me and STBBIL. How do I rectify this? Do I message him and ask him to come? Apologise again? Yet I'm still hurt and angry that he said those things to me, but understand I shouldn't have said anything in the first place.

Aibu to still be pissed off? And AIBU to message him and try and move past this?

OP posts:
CornishMaid1 · 31/05/2018 09:12

The best I could do (other than ignore him) is to be honest back at him.

"I understand you don't want to come to our engagement party if I don't apologise to you for taking two weeks to reply to your text. I am sorry that you feel that way and the reason that I did not reply to you for two weeks was that I needed the time to calm down after you blamed me for the loss of our baby. I appreciate that you had had a lot to drink that night so now don't remember what you said, but it was incredibly hurtful to both me and your brother.

For the sake of your brother I am willing to move past the hurtful comments you made and you are still welcome to join us at our engagement party if you wish to move on from the hurt caused.'

SeriousSass · 31/05/2018 09:20

Oops sorry didn't mean to post the last message.

I Meant to say your comment was awful and his comment was even worse.

I'm not surprised he lashed out at you after you comment though. For you to be in his house and then to comment on him parenting his own kids is very aggressive.
I think he should have properly apologized too but you not answering for two weeks will have come over as very deliberate and unpleasant.

Have you had other run ins with him?

The wedding is going to be fun🤔

MissVanjie · 31/05/2018 09:32

He sounds like a nobhead

Let him sulk, blessing in disguise if you ask me

TopofthePops · 31/05/2018 11:06

Do not apologise to him again. He's using the length of time it took you to text him as an excuse to 'punish' you because you dared to pull him up on his awful attitude to his wife. My bet would be he doesn't want his wife to be in your company in case 'your attitude' might rub of on his wife.

emmyrose2000 · 31/05/2018 11:56

I might either say, 'yes BIL seems to have been avoiding us since he told me my miscarriage was my fault'

I'd go with this.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page