Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

stupid fight about prosecco

162 replies

TotHappy · 23/03/2018 10:17

But not really about prosecco i guess.
I'm going away this weekend with old friends, I'm driving while they're training so I've got all the food and drink and they're saying me back. The money for this weekend has come out of payment for some overtime i did in the last couple of months - so over and above my regular wage. Dh and i pool our wages and after all bills are deducted, split the remainder 3 ways - the usual result is £150 each as spending money plus £100 joint 'fun money' to do things together or as a family.
When i got this extra lump of cash we discussed what to do, i said i wanted to do this weekend and he agreed (enthusiastically). He got a similar amount recently (unexpected inheritance) and spent some of it on paint and other stuff to decorate the kitchen - his,idea, his choice, i actually didn't know about it until he'd started. I assume the rest went into his general spending money.

Last night i picked him up from a,meeting and after dinner he asked if we had any wine, i said no, he said can i have one from your stash (for the weekend), i said no, it's for the weekend. He said, you could replace it tomorrow? And i said 'if i wanted to go shopping tomorrow (on the way there), i wouldn't have gone today! Bit rude, admittedly, i was stressed out about packing etc I'm afraid.

Later on he said he was really angry at,being told 'no' like that. He said a lot of things, over and over, but the general gist is that its how you would speak to a junior at work, and he didn't like coming home from a day at work, followed by another stressful meeting to be just told 'no, you can't have that' about something we do have . This escalated to a huge row all about finances in general and me being controlling. The back story here is - he is shit with money and,has,been since we married, so a few years,ago we moved all the direct debits etc to my bank account, every month he pays his wages over to me minus his spending share. I recognise that i am quite controlling of our money, because i worry so much about him pissing it all up the wall, but i dispute his argument here that the weekend prosecco was bought with 'his' money. It didn't come out of the family budget, i bought it on cc, will be partly reimbursed by friends and pay the rest off when my overtime comes in at end of the month. He says if I'd asked him, he would have agreed in a heartbeat and gone out to replace today. He agreed i have a 'right' to say no but says,he never would to me.
I feel he's implying I should say,yes to whatever he asks, even if inconvenient and i think, why? To me it was just a casual request and a casual denial. Nothing stopping him going out to buy some for himself. As it was he went ahead and opened it anyway so i had to drive out at 10pm and replace it as i really didn't want to stop today.
He agreed in the argument that.i am right 'within the letter of the law' but clearly felt i was,being a tight, selfish bitch. I feel that if you ask for a favour/gift and are then outraged that its refused, then you weren't really asking but demanding, and he's basically implying that whatever he asks for, i have to give him if i love him properly.

All this over fucking prosecco!!!! What,do you think? Am i just being tight and selfish? Our views are so totally opposed that i felt genuinely bewildered during the row and need some perspective.

OP posts:
Thingsthatgo · 23/03/2018 10:58

YANBU. He was cheeky to ask imo, and incredibly rude to open a bottle anyway. I would’ve been furious if my DH did that to me. I would’ve gone without a glass of wine in order to not inconvenience my DH and I would expect him to do the same for me.

FullMetalRabbit · 23/03/2018 10:59

"Not too much of a hardship to stop today is it?"

Why the fuck should she??

agree with this

He sounds vile, sorry OP, YANBU

However, this is clearly more than about the Prosecco

BitOutOfPractice · 23/03/2018 10:59

Why the fuck should she??

Crikey! Because her DH wanted a drink and it would take 5 minutes? Partners do stuff like that? Just maybe?

TroubledTribble28 · 23/03/2018 10:59

Does your husband usually get angry about alcohol? It's worrying really. Human beings don't need alcohol so he's having a tantrum/drink problem fuelled episode.

ChameleonsInCarsGettingCoffee · 23/03/2018 10:59

It depends how big the stash was tbh.

It doesn't matter how big the stash was. It wasn't her stash, it was a group stash that would have needed replacing.

And why should she have to be the one to do it?

If it's easy for her to pop out for 10 minutes to replace it, surely he can pop out for 10 minutes to buy himself a bottle?

Even better, he get buy it chilled rather than her warm stash!

BastardGoDarkly · 23/03/2018 11:00

Hmmmm. I see your point op.

But I guess if you spent your disposable cash on a piss up weekend away,,and he's spent his on kitchen paint, and will be home alone decorating, I can kind of see why he's thought... ffs, don't be so tight!!?

But technically, you're in the right,;and he's said he accepts that.

ChameleonsInCarsGettingCoffee · 23/03/2018 11:02

But technically, you're in the right,;and he's said he accepts that.

He may have said it but he's lying. He opened and drank a bottle anyway!

jay55 · 23/03/2018 11:02

If he had offered to replace it it would be one thing but he didn’t. He insisted you should be inconvenienced when you already had a lot on.

Trinity66 · 23/03/2018 11:02

It was kind of mean of you not to give it to him tbf, I'd be annoyed if DH said that to me and I would never dream of depriving him a bottle of wine if I had one and he wanted one :/

SaucyJack · 23/03/2018 11:03

" I always have to say yes to him because that's what partners do."

I don't believe that you should have to say yes because that's what partners do.

More that there didn't seem any reason to say no to something that could've been a nice evening for the both of you.

I dunno. We both like drinking here. I would have enjoyed starting the weekend off by sharing a bottle with DP- even if it meant taking a small detour the next morning to replace it.

Maybe he's just a bit miffed that you've spent your spare money on a weekend away with your while he's apparently "pissed his money up the wall" by spending it on improvements to the kitchen, and he isn't even allowed one bottle on a Friday night?

I probably would be too TBH.

kimanda · 23/03/2018 11:04

YABU to drink prosecco. It's horrid.

BusterTheBulldog · 23/03/2018 11:06

It’s 10 mins that she didn’t need to do though. My life is built on ridiculously tight schedules, having to plan that in what be a pain in the ass for me so it’d be a no.

Why couldn’t he offer to replace it in the morning? It’s not like op has her own wine that she’s hiding, it’s wine packed for a weekend away for other people.

A healthy relationship would be that the other person doesn’t act like a spoilt brat. Rather than op facilitates and rearranges her time to enable someone who fancies some wine. She’s already said she’d have got him some at the time she was out if he’d wanted it, or possibly shared it with him if he’d suggested a nice evening together. But he didn’t. Tough luck,

Allthewaves · 23/03/2018 11:06

I'm with u op. He asked and u said no then he belittled u and opened it anyway.

It will really irritate me going to have to buy another bottle the next day

Trinity66 · 23/03/2018 11:06

If he had offered to replace it it would be one thing but he didn’t. He insisted you should be inconvenienced when you already had a lot on.

I may be wrong but I assumed that he wouldn't be able to replace it in time before she went off on her weekend so that's why she'd have to do it on her way?

@SaucyJack totally agree, i couldn't imagine falling out over a miserable bottle of wine

BusterTheBulldog · 23/03/2018 11:08

It was kind of mean of you not to give it to him tbf, I'd be annoyed if DH said that to me and I would never dream of depriving him a bottle of wine if I had one and he wanted one :/

But she didn’t have one of her own!! It was shopping for a weekend away! She’s hardly depriving him, it’s a treat for goodness sake!

cuddlymunchkin · 23/03/2018 11:08

He wanted prosecco. There wasn't any in. Therefore he goes to buy some.
The prosecco 'stash' belonged to other people.
It sounds to me like he just wants his own way.

BitOutOfPractice · 23/03/2018 11:09

My DP is doing me a favour today that will take much longer than 10 minutes. Just because

Anyway, it would seem that this is much more about the balance of power in the relationship. I'd say your DH feels a bit powerless, he asserted himself (wrongly) by opening the wine, because it was about more than the prosecco to him too.

I want prosecco now. I'm suggestable. I'm an advertiser's dream Blush

anxious2017 · 23/03/2018 11:09

If your DH wanted wine so badly he'd be willing to cause an argument over it, he has a problem.

Also, he should have just gone and got his own. Dick.

Confusedbeetle · 23/03/2018 11:10

I dont think this row was about the wine. I think he feels emasculated because you are in charge of the finances. His own fault if he is useless but there will be consequences

Trinity66 · 23/03/2018 11:10

But she didn’t have one of her own!! It was shopping for a weekend away! She’s hardly depriving him, it’s a treat for goodness sake!

Technicality, it was easily replaced. Whatever, it's so petty

Travis1 · 23/03/2018 11:10

YANBU, he could've asked you to stop off so he could pick something up on the way home, but this way it was you inconvenienced. Basically saying your time isn't important as long as you're doing things my way!

JessicaJonesJacket · 23/03/2018 11:11

I think it's about the backstory rather than the prosecco tbh.
Letting your DH have a bottle of prosecco after a bad day at work would have been kind.
But it was more important to you to be in control and stick to your plan than to be kind to your partner. That's a sign of a relationship in a bad place.

LimonViola · 23/03/2018 11:11

You sound very fixed/rigid, which would irritate me over time. Like you can't bear any deviation from the agreed upon plan. Would having to stop off somewhere to get an extra bottle be that much hassle, really? Or he could have done it?

You also snapped at him because you were 'stressed about packing', really? Packing stressed you out so much you were a dick to your husband? Why?

He was wrong to drink it anyway but tbh I can see why he did!

LimonViola · 23/03/2018 11:12

But it was more important to you to be in control and stick to your plan than to be kind to your partner. That's a sign of a relationship in a bad place.

Yes, you phrased it much more succinctly than I did.

mummmy2017 · 23/03/2018 11:12

I get you point 100% your right. It was for the trip. You planned and everything...
BUT...
I also get his point. He had a shit day. Got home the was no wine and he wanted to borrow one and give you the cash to replace it.
Sometimes we get stuck in what is black and white.. had you sat and realised how the effect of sticking to your guns would have effected your evening I am sure you would have rather spent 10 mins in a shop than what followed. Sometimes giving in is a win not a loss.. when you feel an argument coming on say you need the loo. Sit and think about the outcome and if it is worth being right or being happy.