Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..to feel hurt I’m not a bridesmaid?

56 replies

sellotape12 · 11/02/2018 18:27

I don’t know if I’m being unreasonable but I do know that today’s left me shocked, sad and unable to stop crying. My sister in law, whom I’ve been very close with for 12 years, has not asked me to be bridesmaid.

I met this girl when she was 15 and I was 21. I’ve coached her through college and breakups and uni and diets and illness and career stuff and hairstyles and grandparent grief and all the in betweens. She always looked up to me (she has four brothers!). I felt special and that I had my own little sister. Two years ago she was my bridesmaid. We shared so much and chatted about how I’d repay the favours one day for her.

But in the last two years she’s drifted from her family. She favours her fiancé’s family and has changed enormously. They’ve been together for 3 years. His family is very ‘new money’, very close knit, quite judgmental, very flash with cash they don’t have. He has a sister that’s at the centre of it all (same age as me). She stamps her feet and my SIL comes running. She’s manipulative (made her leave her uni course) and showers them with gifts. How can I compete with spray tans and lunches and shellac and trips to Dubai? Our whole family thinks the fiancé’s sister - let’s call her Crystal - has pulled SIL away. It’s like she’s under her spell.

There has been a myriad of excuses where SIL has cancelled her own family events, Christmas, Skype calls and the rest. Her brothers only now see her once a year. She spends almost all her energy and time with the fiancé’s family. Her mum is also sad that she’s lost her little girl to a flashier family.

Today, after yet another advice session, SIL told me and my DH that since she’s having lots of flower girls and Paige boys the whole ‘bridesmaid and usher thing was making her feel awkward’.

At his point I felt a pans of dismay but understood her decision to not have bridesmaids at all. Except I was wrong.

She finished her point by saying “I’m having one bridesmaid and that’s Crystal. She’s a machine and gets things done. But can you guys help decorate the venue?” At that moment I felt like the blood left my body.

May I point out that I literally organise and negotiate for a living, so the ‘machine’ excuse is b.s.

So is this pathetic jealousy? I feel a profound sense of loss. Her picking fiancé’s sister but not me sends a signal - why not just include me too or have no maids at all!? DH and his brothers aren’t in the wedding part either. Her fiancé can’t see that his umbilical attachment to his own family alone is causing a distancing, not does he realise marriage is about fairness.

I feel like some of you might read this and not see what hurts or that I’m being ridic. Please understand that I feel I’ve been a big sister to this girl for a good chunk of her and my life. X

OP posts:
BackforGood · 11/02/2018 19:41

What HolyAngelus said.

You are being very judgemental about her fiance's family in your post.
The fact you gave her lots of advice doesn't mean that you should be a bridesmaid though, or expect to be a bridesmaid - you were available to give her advice when she was younger...... even though the age difference is small, the "stage" difference is big, from when you met her. It would seem unlikely that she would, at that point have seen you as a bridesmaid.

Always disappointing when we aren't asked to do something we would like to, but this isn't really (from your description) and occasion when you would really have 'expected' to be a bridesmaid.

NeilPetark · 11/02/2018 19:48

TidyDancer

Do not decorate the venue. Trust me on this one.

Listen to TD, she knows. And look up her threads.

FizzyGreenWater · 11/02/2018 19:49

Grin at TidyDancer.

DO NOT DECORATE THE VENUE. This woman knows of what she speaks.

If you do decorate it, get Crystal to pay for the Sylvanians.

Notonthestairs · 11/02/2018 19:55

YEs listen to tidydancer - she knows of what she speaks.

But just to chuck this in - I don't think being a bridesmaid is that much fun. I've done it for a couple of friends but only because I love them and want to help. I generally had much more fun at those weddings where I was simply a guest. And I must have a big ego because I've never felt less important for not being in the wedding party Grin

Don't decorate the venue, make sure you have an outfit you love and feel comfortable in and go and enjoy the day.

Notonthestairs · 11/02/2018 19:56

X post with fizzy! Slow fingers!

Fishface77 · 11/02/2018 19:57

Decorate the venue.
Take tidy dancer with you Grin

SecretDisneyAddict · 11/02/2018 20:04

3 of my friends asked me to be a bridesmaid and each one eventually did a u-turn favouring the future in laws saying they couldn't afford to have another (me).... Despite me already poised to buy my own dress!

I would tell her that you are upset and why.
I'd agree to help decorate the venue but if the current bridesmaid arrangement doesn't change, I'd accept that you are drifting -her choice- and let the relationship fizzle.
Sad but it was her choice.
She can't have her cake and eat it.

sellotape12 · 11/02/2018 20:05

Omg! Tidy, will you be my date to the wedding?

OP posts:
HolyAngelus · 11/02/2018 20:05

The exposition is to build the story of my feelings, which is the reason we all come to MN. And yes, the other lady did force her to leave uni. And nope, you have totally misconstrued what I said.

All I'm saying is that the 'story of your feelings' involves a lot of explicitly class-based prejudice towards the other family, which may be very obvious to your SIL. And how have I misconstrued:

His family is very ‘new money’, very close knit, quite judgmental, very flash with cash they don’t have. He has a sister that’s at the centre of it all (same age as me). She stamps her feet and my SIL comes running. She’s manipulative (made her leave her uni course) and showers them with gifts. How can I compete with spray tans and lunches and shellac and trips to Dubai?

Her mum is also sad that she’s lost her little girl to a flashier family.

That's pretty much a checklist of middle-class complaints about the shiny toys and arriviste shellac nails and Dubai sun breaks of the nouveau riche. Would the SIL be any less magical and spell-casting if she were clad in well-worn Boden accessorised with black labs jumping out of the back of her battered estate on a wintry Norfolk beach? Grin

And how exactly can anyone 'make' someone quit university, unless the person in question is extremely vulnerable or somehow under their financial control? Isn't your SIL ultimately responsible for her own decisions, whether it's who to have as bridesmaid or university?

I'm not unsympathetic, and I don't think you're unreasonable to be be hurt, in fact, but it does sound as if your SIL may have grown out of the Baby Sis Big Sis dynamic, and/or your snobbery towards her fiancé's family is making her pull away.

eggsandwich · 11/02/2018 20:18

I can totally understand why your upset, it sound like she’s trying to please her partner which is a recipe for disaster once she’s married.

Marriage is about give and take and if she continues to do what she thinks is expected of her from her partners side then she’s going to have either a very short marriage or be very unhappily married for a long time.

All I can say is yes her wedding her choice, but I suspect it’s not her choice, do stay silent and play the waiting game for if ever issues will occur it sounds like it will for her.

TidyDancer · 11/02/2018 20:19

Ooh yes, happy to be a plus one! Grin

mrsmcbitsy · 11/02/2018 20:20

I know it hurts, but I’d look at this as a bullet dodged. No matter what happens Crystal will be a bridesmaid, if you were too, you’d have to spend a lot of time with her and given your feelings that would probably be quite hard.

petbear · 11/02/2018 20:32

@Sellotape12

Personally I would not even go. And do NOT decorate the fucking venue, or do ANYthing for her. Tell her you're gonna be busy hoovering the cat!

I had a friend called Heidi in my childhood/teens for 13-14 years, who I spent time at school with, and went out with all the time, (clubbing and partying and on hols.) We shared a flat, we double dated with 2 men who were mates several times, (and also 2 brothers once!) we travelled around Europe backpacking, we cried on each others shoulders, we were soulmates.

She met 'Shaun' when we were in our early 20's, and set the date for her wedding just 3 months after they met. (It was for 4 months from then, so only 7 months after they met!) Not only did she not ask me to be bridesmaid, she didn't even invite me to the wedding. I was utterly devastated, and couldn't get my head around the reason why.

It was a very quickly planned wedding, and the reception was at a pub, and it wasn't a hugely expensive wedding, but around 75-80 were invited, including around a dozen of her workmates who she had only known a year.

I left messages on her answerphone saying I think my invitation got lost in the post, but she never responded. She avoided me like the plague and didn't return my calls. Then after the wedding, I enquired with her family members when I saw them as to why I hadn't been invited. They said it was just people very close to her. Hmm

I moved away from our town a few months after, and never contacted her again. I was so hurt.

Long story short, I discovered about a year later (from Lisa - a mutual friend who went to the wedding, who had now fallen out with Heidi,) that I wasn't invited, because Shaun didn't like me, and had told Heidi I had asked him if he wanted to fuck me before he married her. Shock

I said to Lisa 'NO WAY did I say that!' She said she believed me, and he had tried it on with her a few months ago, and Shaun ran to Heidi and said SHE had tried it on with him too! And also, she knew someone he had slept with a few months ago! So he was a lying twat, and a cheat too - asking women for affairs! And he ruined a wonderful friendship for me and Heidi.

Over 2 decades later, she is still with him. Ewwwww.

disclaimer; names are not real......

SandyY2K · 11/02/2018 20:56

I think I'd be more worried that her new SIL to be got her to leave Uni, than not being a bridesmaid tbh.

The wedding is one day.... but the fact she's become distant from her family is a bigger issue.

..and with all the money they have why arent they paying for professional decorators? There's no way I'd be decorating the venue. She can get stuffed on that note.

SandyY2K · 11/02/2018 20:58

@petbear

What a shame she didn't even ask you about it.

I bet he's cheated on her throughout the marriage.

BookHelpPlease · 11/02/2018 21:00

You're not a maid though?! You are married and a bit older than the bride. Of course you weren't going to be a bridesmaid.

I would't help decorate the venue in your shoes.

Sparklesocks · 11/02/2018 21:01

I was an ‘usherette’ at a friend’s wedding and was flattered at first but Quickly realised it meant i was doing all the rubbishy jobs at the wedding! Handing things out, collecting things, checking things, I was up and down constantly throughout the sitdown meal doing her bidding..she asked me to help clear up the venue at the end of the night (they’d bought lots of ‘extras’ with them and the venue people who normally clean up as part of the package refused as it was so much extra work..) but I was so knackered i ended up sneaking back to my hotel room during the final song. Cheeky I know but I was dead on my feet...

TryAgainAndAgain · 11/02/2018 21:05

.

Heartofglass12345 · 11/02/2018 21:25

I get how you feel. I didnt ask my best friend to be my bridesmaid but i only had family (2 sisters and niece). I said to her jokingly once, i've never been a bridesmaid, hurry up and get married. She responded with 'well i wasnt yours' so i'm guessing she was pissed off with me!
One of my other close friends was getting married abroad and asked my best friend to be a bridesmaid and not me, i was secretly gutted, i dont know why she picked her over me as we were all close. Even when my friend couldnt afford to go she didnt ask me, and i went to the wedding!

petbear · 11/02/2018 21:25

@SandyY2K

Yep, he almost certainly has cheated on her throughout their marriage.

Horrible parasite.

SandyY2K · 12/02/2018 00:34

@Heartofglass12345

I think it was a bit cheeky considering you didn't choose her as your bridesmaid tbh.

Saying you only had family isn't really an excuse either. ..if you really want someone to be your bridesmaid, you'll ask them regardless.

Many people choose friends to bridesmaids over family too.

Added to that some people don't choose married bridesmaids. Traditionally. ..they are meant to be single ladies.

I has single bridesmaids... I didn't ask my married Dsis. ..because she was married (single Dsis was my chief bridesmaid)... married Dsis asked if she could be my maid/matron of honour. ..I was happy with that

SeaWitchly · 12/02/2018 06:55

I love that movie Niki Grin

It reminds me of an ex friend [let's call her Jill] who phased me out of her life when a new 'helpful' friend [let's call her Joan] muscled her way in. It was very similar in style to the Bridesmaids situation although Joan was not as wealthy and so no trips to Paris but rather she just took over everything... and was wealthier than I and had a bigger house and so was able to host pre wedding events, etc.

I sensed that Joan was trying to leave me out of things, anything she organised I was always the last to know... but Jill certainly went along with it, I think she was flattered by the intense attention.

However the kicker was when Jill told me that the wedding ceremony would be family only but that I could come to the reception. Fine, I was happy with that... only to turn up at the reception and discover that Joan was invited to the wedding [as were a number of other friends]. So I had been lied to for weeks in the run up to the wedding .
Jill explained it as there having been a number of family who hadn't been able to make the ceremony and so she had invited friends to fill the spaces... but I later discovered that this had been arranged weeks prior and I therefore just wasn't told or considered as a space filler.

Very hurtful and our friendship has never recovered tbh.

speakout · 12/02/2018 07:00

You sound a drama queen OP.

You really want to be a bridesmaid? You sound 10 years old.

ZoeWashburne · 12/02/2018 07:49

Honestly, it sounds a bit like you are jealous of Crystal. You liked feeling needed by SIL and now that she has moved on, you miss the attention and power of being big sis. And I agree with the other posters. There is NO way Crystal forced your SIL out of her course. Your SIL is an adult who is making choices. Maybe the relationship that you saw as guiding and mentoring, she saw as judgmental and domineering. You are treating her like a puppy that is swayed by treats rather than an adult with agency. It’s horrible to feel babied by someone.

I just can’t believe a 33 year old woman would be so devastated. Don’t go decorate (because it’s rude to make friends do ‘chores’ at weddings). But also just take a step back. You sound very judgy/sneery of her fi’s Family.

Piffle11 · 12/02/2018 08:17

It seems as though you have drifted apart, which tends to happen over time (she was a child when you met) and her priorities have changed. Whether her in laws are influencing her or not, it's ultimately her decision who to choose as bridesmaid. My DSis didn't ask me to be bridesmaid when she got married - I didn't mind - but I did ask her when I got married a few years later (I'm older, FWIW). Don't decorate the venue - I've never heard of guests being asked to do this!! Let them pay someone to do it like the rest of us have to! You're probably jealous that the Sil has effectively stolen your place in Crystal's affections: this is completely understandable. Unfortunately there is nothing you can do about it. Smile, hold your head up, and let them get on with it. Go to the wedding and be gracious.