My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

To be terrified that this is the future for the UK? (Sorry, yes it's a Brexit one)

292 replies

Rainbunny · 07/11/2017 22:40

The US Commerce Secretary just made a speech in which he demands that the UK scrap EU food standards on GM crops and animal farming standards after Brexit. Even more sinister were his words indicating that the USA expects to have influence in whatever Brexit deal the UK makes... "He said that it was critical that US interests must be taken into account when finalising an exit deal with the EU..!"

This is exactly what I've been afraid of and it looks to be coming true and the UK as a lone country will not be able to refuse whatever trade deal the USA demands. I get that people who voted leave are still happy they did but is this what they want to have happen?

www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/us-brexit-eu-uk-trade-deal-wilbur-ross-commerce-secretary-imports-exports-european-union-a8040571.html

OP posts:
Report
Holldstock1 · 08/11/2017 10:33

OP YANBU.

I've just spent far too much time this morning (not working till 11.30 a.m.), mooching around the house, having a bath and reading items on We are the 48% - yes I'm a Remainer folks. It was encouraging to hear how many people are absolutely outraged on that forum by what is happening in Government atm and as a result who have changed their minds about Brexit. The sheer incompetence and dishonesty of those in power. Bumbling Boris compounding his growing number of Foreign Office faux pas and international insults by now getting that poor British woman another 5 years in an Iranian prison by mouthing incompetent falsehoods. Pritti Patel breaking the ministerial code of conduct right and centre with secret meetings with Israel about giving them British aid in the Golan Heights (against British policy) and lying umpteen times about having them without the government knowing. David Davis claiming there were 58 reports analysing how Brexit would affect the different UK industry sectors then it all turns out to be a big fat lie - there aren't any reports - either there are and he's covering up bad news, or there aren't any at all so why did he say there were - either way he has LIED to Parliament and to the country (if there's one thing I really hate and despise its liars), Fallon resigning over a number of sexual harrassment charges (I know Labour also - but they aren't in government or negotiating Brexit), Damien Greene - equal problems and allegations of misconduct...... these are the people ruling the country and negotiating Brexit. Don't get me started on Universal Credit, Food Banks, the NHS, Public Sector payrises, Grenfell Tower, running down our Armed Forces, the threats of Russia and Trump or the Paradise Papers. These people can't even govern the UK correctly - how the hll are they able to negotiate Brexit?

If we took Brexit out of the equation briefly - surely there should be a Vote of No Confidence in this government???? They are not able to competently do their job.

I know that is a scary thing to say, and most will want to say well this close to Brexit deadline better to stick with the devil you know and
'You are a Remainer Remoaner so you shouldn't speak, your view doesn't matter, blah blah blah', but look realistically at the people doing Brexit.

I admit I personally HATE Brexit with every fibre of my being and won't ever accept it because being European is as big a part of my identity as being British - note British not English, Welsh, Scots - I've lived in all three and we have Irish roots in the family back in the gene pool somewhere - I'm British.

But if I'm being logical and stepping back from my emotions and opinions, stepping back from personal political lines of the fact its a Tory government who to me appear to be pursuing policies that persecute the poor, the disabled, the mentally ill, underfund our schools, sixth forms, give our young people huge university debts as they start out on life, etc etc etc.....

Stepping back from that part of myself, logically and coolly looking at the government in power - they are in no fit condition to either govern the country, or to negotiate something as important to the lives of every single person in this country as Brexit.

Even if you want Brexit desperately, I cannot understand for an instant why anyone Remainer, ReLeaver or Leaver actually respects and trusts that this government is capable of bringing a properly organised Brexit about, or competently negotiating trade deals with other nations once we have left the EU that don't mean we sign our NHS, our industries, Animal Welfare, Food Standards, Environment etc etc away.

It was Canada that sorted out Bombardier not the UK government. Its Europe and China being driving partners to battle Climate Change. Its the US which stand alone outside the Paris Climate Accord, are antagonizing the situation with North Korea and Iran, and which are telling the Japanese PM to his face in front of the media that Japan has to come second behind US in any trade deals. These are the countries with the power at the moment - not the UK. We are in an incredibly weakened position at the moment to negotiate, in no small part because of the incompetent politicians that are running the country and responsible for driving Brexit through. How can any of us, whether we are Labour, Lib Dem, Tory or nothing, or whether we are for or against Brexit, actually trust them to get it sorted??

I'd personally prefer that Brexit did not happen in any shape or form. That's my ideal scenario obviously. But, if its to go ahead, I don't think our country or our Parliament is in any condition at the moment to navigate it.

These are not normal times. Its not just a bulk standard Conservative government that you either love or love to hate and will vote in or out at the next GE. These are genuinely incompetent people, many of whom are personally completely power hungry, happy to bypass Parliament, our Constitution and the the Courts wherever possible, many are privileged and personally rich enough that they won't feel the effects if the country goes t
ts up, seem to have no empathy with those not in positions of power or wealth, happy to lie to Parliament and the country - I could go on - but its the incompetency, lack of real meaningful organisation, lack of ability, weakness and dishonesty that is really frightening.

I know it conveniently plays into me being a Remainer against Brexit, but if I put that aside, I genuinely really do think Brexit needs to be stopped. There should be a Vote of No Confidence in the government and we need to stop Brexit because I don't think this government can negotiate Brexit and I don't think they are capable of dealing with either the mess I think it will be once we've left, or negotiate trade deals if it all smells of roses like Leavers keep saying.

Once the dust settles and we've stabilized the country, then any new government should investigate Brexit with real concrete facts and information about what Brexit will do to and for the country. Then with real information, facts and figures come back and hold a second referendum and take it from there. If it were to come back the same - Leave - then I hope whoever is in government actually does it properly without all the stupidity of throwing negotiating advantages away by instantly triggering Article 50 without any proper plan or strategy.

That's what I truely think once you take all the arguing, recriminations and passion out of the Brexit debate. At the moment I feel like one of the passengers on the Titanic that is Brexit. You know the people in cattle class who were shut and locked away by the crew to go down with the ship so the rich and privileged had a chance at the life boats.

Report
TimFromRuislip · 08/11/2017 10:35

I'd highly recommend the Remainiacs podcast if you want to be kept up to date with all things Brexit. And feel like you're not alone in still supporting Remain.

Report
makeourfuture · 08/11/2017 10:45

Holldstock1. Required reading!!

Report
TokyoKyoto · 08/11/2017 10:47

We are in for a hard few decades whether or not it goes ahead. The UK is spoiled goods - thanks Brexiteers, you've made us all look like small-minded thick racist cunts.

I'm ashamed of my country and can scarcely believe that anybody looking at the clusterfuck that is UK politics right now can even try to put a positive spin on it. But there it is. We're a nation of idiots now.

Any of us with friends and relatives in EU countries knows that they are SAD for us - nobody is quaking in their boots because the UK's EU contributions are about to disappear, they are saddened that we're digging our heels in despite every single unequivocal sign that this is a terrible, ruinous mess. They pity us in the most genuine way, without a hint of high-handedness or schadenfreude.

Yet all I hear from the Brexiteers is the opposite, that the EU exists only to bleed us dry and manipulate us into toeing their line. You bunch of terrible, deluded people. It's no coincidence that the ones I know in real life are people I'd cross the road to avoid. I will never forgive you awful cunts for what you have done to my country.

Report
StigmaStyle · 08/11/2017 11:43

Come on Tokyo, say what you really think :o

I feel embarrassed when talking to my Dutch and other EU 27 friends. And they know I'm an ardent remainer –but I still want to apologise for the shower of daft numpties who voted for Brexit and the shower of lying numpties who encouraged them.

Report
Scabbersley · 08/11/2017 11:49

There should be a Vote of No Confidence in the government and we need to stop Brexit

Wouldn't that mean Labour would get in? Corbyn and momentum definitely want us out of the EU so I don't think that would help, would it?

Report
ChardonnaysPrettySister · 08/11/2017 11:53

Its embarrassing, disastrous and plain stupid to go ahead with Brexit.

Report
TokyoKyoto · 08/11/2017 12:04

I just hate the lot of them. What's the point in arguing it out properly, we're in the post-factual era and nobody who voted for it gives two shits that they've been manipulated to support Brexit (and partly by that cunt Farage! The SHAME!). They just cling on to this fantasy that we're being mistreated by the EU and we'll be fine on our own. Wankbadgers.

Report
Mishappening · 08/11/2017 12:10

I feel pretty laid back about it all - what will be, will be. I have seen so many political crises during my lifetime, and in the main we finish up just ticking along. There's nothing we can do now - we have an incompetent government with incompetent "negotiators" and we are totally impotent. No good fretting about something you can do nothing about.

Report
Itsanicehotel · 08/11/2017 12:11

it is what it is. Yep you can say that again. It is a fucking nightmare that is going to cost us a lot and not just monetarily.

Report
Motheroffourdragons · 08/11/2017 12:25

There's nothing we can do now

I don't believe this to be true.

There are marches, petitions, writing to MPs and Lords.

There is speaking to others to see if they can still be persuaded.

The govt has shown themselves to be people who are only interested in power, if it can be shown that there is a change in public opinion, then they won't be there much longer, or will change their minds in order to keep power.

This is not over yet.

Report
Scabbersley · 08/11/2017 12:27

I feel so personally upset by this. I'm 50. I was looking forward to a relaxing old age. Now its just going to be a fucking shitstorm. I am so, so saddened and depressed by the whole thing. It actually makes me hate people Blush

Report
Peregrina · 08/11/2017 13:49

I have seen so many political crises during my lifetime, and in the main we finish up just ticking along.

It might be true in the UK now, but I can think of other examples in history where the crisis has been difficult to recover from - E.g. the Irish potato famine - the population now is only just returning to what it was before the famine - with starvation and emigration seeing off large numbers.
The nazi slaughter of the Jews and others.
Stalin's purges
Khmer Rouge

Or going back much further the Black Death which devastated Europe and killed off feudalism.

I think you can get the picture. I do think that people can be resilient, but there comes a point where the crisis overwhelms.

Report
makeourfuture · 08/11/2017 14:13

We truly do not know where this is heading.

Report
StigmaStyle · 08/11/2017 14:23

Exactly Peregrina. Crises, disasters and appalling decisions of all kinds do all eventually become past history, but in the process a lot of ordinary people suffer.

Report
Ttbb · 08/11/2017 14:28

I sure hope so. The EU standards remove consumer choice and encourage inefficiency. It makes me irrationally angry that I can't buy 'imperfect' aubergines with noses when I am in Britain. Rules for labelling organic are also fairly lax. Then of course the cost of fresh produce is driven up without any meaningful improvement.

Report
StigmaStyle · 08/11/2017 14:30

You can buy imperfect produce in the UK. Sainsbury's labels it specifically as such in their bargain ranges, so it must be legal.

Report
Ttbb · 08/11/2017 14:34

Also on the note of the Black Death surely that was a good thing despite the massive loss of life? Without it we would likely be living slavish lives either under supreme royal rule or communism or the like. Just look at the European countries that did not suffer as much from the Black Death. They suffered far greater catastrophies as a result. Russia being a foremost example. Tyrant under the tsars, ebskacement and genocide under the communists and, corruption and political persecution under it's current government. Because the balance of power remained in the hands of rulers (in a way that it did not when the Black Death culled the labour force in Britain) Russians have never experienced true freedom. The Black Death was of course terrible but a great deal of good came out of it, not only for the survivors but for all of humanity. You cannot put it in the same category as the Khmer Rouge for many reasons.

Report
Ttbb · 08/11/2017 14:36

@StigmaStyle I've never seen properly imperfect produce here in the same way as I have found it Australia. You do get a few bits and pieces outside of the normalitive size and weight but it still doesn't look like real food half the time.

Report
thecatfromjapan · 08/11/2017 14:37

Misshappening :

I have seen so many political crises during my lifetime, and in the main we finish up just ticking along.

Sadly, I think that this type of thinking is what is allowing this crisis - and, make no mistake, this is a crisis - continue. The UK has been amazingly fortunate and stable for a very long time. Hence the absolute astonishment amongst foreign commentators at the state of affairs we are currently seeing unfold.
Meanwhile, in the UK, we are simply refusing to actually believe what we are seeing unfold before our eyes.

You need to read some of the accounts of life in, say, Austria before the hideous events of the C20 overtook them. Surprisingly, a lot of people there thought exactly the same thing. With good reason.

There's nothing we can do now.

This is just not true. It is the counsel of doing nothing . simply being lazy is not going to stop you being caught up in the wheels of history. Not only can you do 'something' - but you really need to, or this disaster is going to pull the UK you know and enjoy apart.

Report
StigmaStyle · 08/11/2017 14:38

Hmmmm well that's a bit like saying a lot of good came out of the second world war. Yes, sort of but that doesn't mean holocaust and atomic bombings causing vast numbers deaths and untold suffering are desirable. You generally want to avoid disaster.

Report
Humpsfor20yards · 08/11/2017 14:43

I have seen so many political crises during my lifetime, and in the main we finish up just ticking along.

Oh to be privileged, eh.

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

Peregrina · 08/11/2017 14:44

I can't buy 'imperfect' aubergines with noses when I am in Britain

You have listened to Boris Johnson's lies - you can. I can never understand why people trot this one out, and yet will happily come back from France, Spain or Italy and rave about the gnarly fruit and veg that they bought at a market over there. You can't buy them here because supermarkets have persuaded us that we don't want imperfect products - so your complaint should be addressed to the supermarket.

Report
Motheroffourdragons · 08/11/2017 14:45

Ttbb - the Black Death caused death all across Europe, not just in the UK.

The Black Death was one of the most devastating pandemics in human history, resulting in the deaths of an estimated 75 to 200 million people in Eurasia and peaking in Europe in the years 1346–1353

Report
allegretto · 08/11/2017 14:45

Also on the note of the Black Death surely that was a good thing despite the massive loss of life?

Confused Confused Confused Confused Confused Confused This is one of the weirdest arguments that I have ever read on MN! I don't even know where to start - deadly disease good apart from being a disease which is deadly? The Black Death and Communism are separated by centuries by the way - and Russia was affected by it too.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.