Aibu re peanut butter?!

[Ribrabrob]

I made a peanut butter sandwich and put a layer of normal dairy butter on first, as I always do, but then it got me thinking as to whether this is the done thing!

Am I bu and breaking some kind of rule for having both butter and peanut butter?!

Butter is essential. It's too clay without. But I had a friend who felt strongly that butter was uncalled for. Better still, add a banana. Or ditch the bread and butter and spread the pb directly onto the banana.

You are all being unreasonable because the bread should be spread with Nutella, not butter. Then the peanut butter.

That sounds like a good combo Prof

YABU to not add marmite.

It's not unreasonable, it's essential.

Sounds delicious to me, and I always add Marmite when I'm putting it on toast.

Butter and PB? No, oh no no, not for me.
I do however put butter on a bacon sandwich which I'm told is not the done thing, also put mayo on rather than ketchup so I'm a bit maverick.

YABU, you forgot the jam!

I hated peanut butter (too dry) until I saw a friend's father do this-changed my life forever!

YABU.
Butter or spread, unless it's honey.

@MikeUniformMike

But honey and butter are the BEST

I always but butter with peanut butter unless I am having jam & peanut butter

I can't cope with the British obsession to put real or fake butter on every slice of bread in a sandwich. Even when it's frickin' mayo, you still put marg first!! just NO. You can do this. A Sandwich can exist without fake/real butter in it.

You are being VVU. No addition of butter - However, if you feel that you need something extra try this - peanut butter (only crunchy allowed), sliced cucumber, very thinly sliced extra mature cheddar, a tiny squirt of salad cream and a liberal sprinkling of crushed Hoola Hoops (only Ready Salted). Nectar of the Gods. You're welcome

It sounds bizarre but I'm going to have to try it.

Yabu

Pure PB or nothing!

My husband has butter and peanut butter, I think it's weird. Unfortunately he took the same approach when making me chocolate spread on toast and I was nearly sick. Chocolate spread and butter DO NOT GO TOGETHER.

Butter?

Shouldn't it be jam?

Think I'll be trying PB & chocolate spread!

Does it taste like a Reese's at all?

lljkk I am so with you!!!! The first time my MIL made me a sandwich ( naice ham and cheese) I actually gagged...didn't expect a slather of marg!!! Bleurgh! Butter and peanut butter...no. Just no.

Lashings of both, especially on toast. Devine!

with NorksAkimbo.

I hate butter - it's fine "cooked" (garlic bread is pushing things though) but give me a sandwich with butter, cheese, pickle, ham, mustard, and gherkins and all I will taste is the butter. It's a pain in the arse. I was at some training thingy today and there was a sandwich lunch - except to me it was a butter lunch, and I nibbled some stale Ready Salted.

Anyway - my point is you're very wrong, and peanut butter should only ever go with jam. Or bacon.

Marg in sandwiches is foul. Really foul.

Butter is wrong too, but has a handful of exceptions: hot sandwiches, and peanut butter.

A Sandwich can exist without fake/real butter in it.

This is true in the same way that you can survive without food for quite a while, so long as you keep drinking water. You can have bread/toast and PB without butter, but why would you if butter is available?

Yabu