Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To un-forgive my parents after 15 years?

58 replies

thewintergirl · 25/08/2017 14:23

When I was 22 I fell pregnant with my eldest dc. I was in a very bad relationship with an abusive man who used to hit me and verbally abuse me every day, I know, I should have left him, but I was both afraid of him and on some level hoped he'd change.

My mum's response to this was to throw me out, even though she knew I had nowhere else to go and that he was abusive, although I know now I could have gone to a women's refuge. I just couldn't think straight. My sister also refused to help me saying I could stay a night here and there if it 'got really bad' after I told her what was going on with him and that he was hitting me.

My mum and I had always had a bad relationship before that as I grew up, she was very cold and set a lot of store by what people think. She is very religious. There are too many things to list here but my childhood was a catalogue of just having my confidence eroded away with comments that stay with me even as an adult in her 30s, from being 'disgusting' for sleeping with my boyfriend to her telling me she hated me. She was not like this with my sister.

During the pregnancy my sister told my mum that partner was continuing to hit me, I hoped that they might offer to let me come home but they didn't. Reading this makes me sound absolutely pathetic I know, I know I should have just left, and eventually I did end up in a women's refuge.

After dc was born my mum made a big thing of 'forgiving' me and accepting her dgc. She implied that she did not believe that I had been abused as badly as I had and also suggested that I had 'let it happen to me' if it were true. Our relationship got a bit better and she was an OK grandmother, though only ok, and didn't have massive amounts of time for dgc. She continued to run me down though and often made comments about me being a bad mother eg dc was a late talker and she said it was because I didn't bother to talk to her. Which wasn't true. And often said dc would probably be the only child I would ever have as noone would be keen to take on another man's child.

When I met my really lovely DH she got a lot nicer as I was now respectable and no longer an embarrassment to her.

Anyway we got on ok, and I tried not to think about her throwing me out any more, until a few months ago when we had an argument that escalated. The way she spoke to me just triggered something in me, she speaks in such a sneering, spiteful tone to me, and I just realised that I never wanted to hear her speak to me like that again. I went NC and realised at the heart of it is the fact that I had not forgiven her for what she did all those years ago. My dad went along with her actions when I was pregnant though wasn't as cruel as she was afterwards.

My sister and mum have both implied that I am raking up the past unreasonably and should have got over it.

I feel such a weight off me going NC with her. I can't explain it, I just feel so unbelievably happy and liberated that I will never have to listen to her being nasty to me again. AIBU? And thanks for reading.

PS I have told her she can see her grandchildren but she hasn't taken me up on it.

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 25/08/2017 14:43

YANBU - she left you vulnerable when you most needed protection. She should be asking for your forgiveness.
She clearly is more concerned about the outward show of religion than practising its actual message.

She adds nothing positive to your life and you owe her nothing.
Flowers

DorotheaHomeAlone · 25/08/2017 14:48

I'm so sorry she was so dreadful and let you down. You owe her nothing. Walk away and enjoy your freedom. And no one who knows about dv would blame you at all for what happened with your ex. If anything your mother's treatment had left you a prime target for abuse.

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/08/2017 14:52

If you did 'let it happen to me' it was because of the emotional abuse you suffered in childhood, which made you attractive to an abusive man. Absolutely not your fault. Totally hers. The fact that you are happy and healthy now is probably why you aren't willing to let HER abuse go any longer.

MrsTrebus · 25/08/2017 15:01

I'm going through similar with my dad and posted about it recently. It's horrible to feel the way you do and for me I realise a lot of my resurfacing anger has to do with my feelings about my adored dc and that I would never treat them this way. Do what's best for you and be the mum you didn't have. Happiness and success are ten ultimate revenge. Be kind to yourself.

Willow2017 · 25/08/2017 15:02

I wouldnt let such a toxic, selfish person within a mile of my child either never mind me.

Go totally NC for your and your dds safety and peace of mind. She will treat your dd the same way she treats you, do you really want her sneering at your dd?

quercuscircus · 25/08/2017 15:02

YADNBU. I can totally relate to the feeling of liberation and ligthness that comes from going NC with a family member who is bad for you. It is like cutting off an anchor, but so much more.

I'm sorry you went through all that you have, you deserve so much better Flowers

Sounds like your mum offered nothing but harm to you over many years and so why would you want her in your life?! Forgiveness requires real remorse and I don't think she feels that way.. so it is hard for you to forgive or forget. NC is all that is left but it can be amazing!

So enjoy your freedom! And don't look back :)

And really if she doesn't want to see her DGC then don't push it - does she really have anything good to offer to them?

zzzzz · 25/08/2017 15:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SuperMoonIsKeepingMeUpToo · 25/08/2017 15:05

Not unreasonable at all - I can absolutely understand why you'd be relieved to not have any more to do with her. And even if she comes begging, please don't let her have access to your children - you don't want her screwing them up like she did you.

Benedikte2 · 25/08/2017 15:06

OP there often comes a time when enough is enough and one has to let a toxic relationship go. The fact that your heart feels lighter shows you have done the right thing for yourself and also for your DC who should have to gear someone talking to their DM in that disrespectful way.
Good luck

thewintergirl · 25/08/2017 15:07

thanks everyone. I think it's true that my anger towards her has grown as I realise that I could not in a million years treat my dcs the way she treated me and I try to channel that into being the mum she never was.

OP posts:
SuperMoonIsKeepingMeUpToo · 25/08/2017 15:07

Sorry, abusing. 'Screwing up' trivialises the affair and makes you sounds mentally incapacitated, which you clearly aren't

SpaghettiAndMeatballs · 25/08/2017 15:09

You are not being unreasonable. Something happened to me as a child (physical abuse over a cause of a few months), and 25 years later, I finally had the courage to tell my mum. It turned out she had known all along, but had never said anything. Which is bad enough, but then she laughed, as if it was a silly little thing (it wasn't I was about 6, and so many memories are still clear as crystal regarding it).

Now, we hadn't had what I would call a close relationship anyway (I've always lived far from my family), but like you, it was almost a moment of cold fury and complete clarity with her. I distanced myself further - to the stage that I can't even hear what was previously a beloved song that she used to sing to me to comfort me - let alone sing it to my own children.

We see each other perhaps once a year. My life is better for it.

Papafran · 25/08/2017 15:11

YANBU

Neutrogena · 25/08/2017 15:13

Time to forgive and let go of the anger.
In no way whatsoever does that make your mum's actions right, but pain and anger hurt you and your kids, so time to let it go.
Forgiveness doesn't make her 'right', but makes you feel right.

Silverthorn · 25/08/2017 15:13

So hard to go against the grain of wanting a loving mother and family but from what you have written you are well rid of the lot of them. They add nothing positive to your life or your dc for that matter. An example of how a loving family acts; when my elder sister fell pregnant at 19 with her first boyfriend. There was a bit of consternation and angst (of course), but no question of helping and supporting her.
FlowersCakeBrew stay strong. Ignore not so dear sister and father.

WhatEaglesWear · 25/08/2017 15:18

Unless there is a sincere and heartfelt apology from her, I'd have nothing more to do with her in your shoes.

Moreisnnogedag · 25/08/2017 15:19

OP continue nc if it releases you. There's no benefit to maintaining a hurtful degrading relationship just because she is your mother.

Neutrogena really? I completely agree with letting go of the anger but I don't think that it necessarily only comes with 'forgiveness'. I think in most abusive relationships (which this is) moving on and letting go comes from realising you cannot change the other person, but you can change yourself by not allowing that person to damage you anymore. In lots of cases that means having no contact.

FuckYouLinda · 25/08/2017 15:21

I feel such a weight off me going NC with her.

That tells you all you need to know. Flowers

I found I looked at my DP's parenting with new eyes after I became a mother. Sounds like that's what happened to you.

IdaDown · 25/08/2017 15:22

Sometimes having DCs of our own brings back these feelings.

It's hard to bury feelings when you're raising children / living through similar experiences with your own DCs but not behaving in the same way towards them.

Neutrogena · 25/08/2017 15:22

@Moreisnnogedag

Yes - I didn;t say you go back to a relationship with the people who hurt OP. But forgiveness is giving up the idea of a different past.
By moving on and freeing yourself of anger, you are forgiving.

RachelP247 · 25/08/2017 15:28

YANBU.
I've had similar; entire childhood and early adulthood was plagued with her bitter, twisted actions and spite filled tongue - One time she point blank told me I had deserved to be raped; after physically attacking me in front of my then 3 year old DS I decided enough was enough and have been NC for nearly 7 years now and its bliss!

It's made me strong enough to ditch other relationships I deem toxic too because once you have divorced your own mother you can get rid of anything that has a negative impact on you. I only surround myself with positive and empowering people these days and it's actually really liberating.

No YANBU to rid yourself of abuse. xxx

Neutrogena · 25/08/2017 15:31

@RachelP247 I only surround myself with positive and empowering people

Say if someone gets sick, and they get negative and needy?
Do they get dropped?

quercuscircus · 25/08/2017 15:32

neutrogena sometimes that pain and anger serves a purpose - if it reminds the OP or anyone in her situation that she cannot trust her mum not to abuse her then I think the anger is fine. As the OP says she channels it into motivation to be a fantastic mum. I don't get the impression she is storing up a big vat of hatred.

Sometimes forgiveness can be confused with going back/ reinstating contact and that sounds like it would be a very bad idea.

Natural forgiveness might come in time if the mother is genuinely remorseful but as Moreisnnogedag says, you can gain acceptance and a wonderful sense of peace from distance and letting go, no matter what the other person does or does not do.

Booboobooboo84 · 25/08/2017 15:34

You deserved so much better, give your dc every piece of protection your d-family failed to give. An absent abusive grandmother is better than a present abusive grandmother.

BellaNoche · 25/08/2017 15:36

I think that if you feel better NC then that is fine. Please don't feel guilty about it. I'm so sorry you have been through such difficult times.

None of this has been your fault at all, shame on them for not caring for you. You will be a great mum to your own I'm sure.

We went NC with some very toxic family members years ago and have never regretted it.
All best wishes for good times ahead x

Swipe left for the next trending thread