Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A wedding AIBU- DP and I can't agree!

75 replies

WanderingNotLost · 29/07/2016 22:10

So DP and I are beginning to make tentative wedding plans- we'll be paying for the whole thing ourselves so won't have a huge budget. We're hoping to keep it at around £10k- half of which is coming from the inheritance I received when my Grandma died, which is all being put towards the wedding.
I took my DP to the church I've been a semi-regular at for a while now and he liked it well enough (he's not religious so it makes very little difference to him) however I kept looking because a- there's no guarantee that church will be available around the time we want to get married and b- as a church it doesn't have a great deal of character or atmosphere. We're getting married in London so no shortage of churches to choose from! I However DP is pissed off with this because he says I just can't make my mind up and will never be happy.
Similar situation with the reception venue- we've found a pub which as yet has no bookings next summer and would work within our budget. One downside is that whilst there is space outside there's only a couple of benches to sit on- we're getting married in summer so if it's a nice day people will want to spend time outside, and won't necessarily want to stand up all day. Also it is a courtyard surround by buildings so not very bright. So I kept looking around because I didn't want to just stop at the first place we like the look of. I've found a venue which is lovely, still in a convenient location, and has a gorgeous outside terrace with plenty of seating and a lovely view of the city. It is more expensive (not ridiculously so), but I think it's worth the extra for a much nicer venue, and nicer food. Again DP is saying that I'll just never make my mind up and I'll just keep looking and looking and won't be satisfied. To me, he just seems to be saying 'yep, that'll do' to the first church and venue we look at!
Basically we can't agree on certain budget aspects. My DP is insisting on putting a fairly hefty chunk of money behind the bar- (in his words, "otherwise what are they coming for?" I responded that if people are only coming to our wedding for a free piss-up I'd rather not have them there.) To me that is literally throwing money down the drain. I'd rather pay the extra for a better venue and not have a free bar than downgrade just so we can pay for everyone to get pissed. He says if we go for the more expensive venue we'll have to make sacrifices elsewhere- like having a video. I really want a videographer- the whole day passes in such a blur and I think it would be really nice to have a video to capture the day. I'm feeling a bit resentful that I'm putting my entire inheritance into this and he wants me to settle for the first place we look at that's in our budget just so we can spend a load of money on booze. I'd rather have memories of a gorgeous venue than a literal piss up in a brewery!
I'm trying to be as un-Bridezilla about this as possible- I'm not stamping my feet and insisting we do everything my way- I'm just saying let's not stop at the first thing we look at, let's look around see what else might work.
So, who is BU- me or DP? (dons flameproof hat and clutches at G&T)

OP posts:
Lorelei76 · 30/07/2016 00:46

Oh so he's not really suggesting a crazy bar, just a reasonable amount of free drinks
Also easy to issue drinks tokens to make sure no one gets ten free drinks when others get two.

If he's likely to get that drunk what difference does the cost to others make?
pp suggestions of a hall are very good, or see if pub can hire extra seating.

DontMindMe1 · 30/07/2016 00:50

so he's more interested in a jolly piss up than getting involved in what should be the best day of his life?

He put his foot down over your home town as Essex is 'too far' from london?!

He's already drip feeding the manipulations - by not 'going along' with his way you're made to feel shit/doubtful of yourself.

He's full of pathetic excuses, trying to mask his true 'colours'. Why can't he just be honest? That a 'show' is more important to him?

You're a fool for sinking your inheritance into this - especially when your gut is saying 'slow down'.

When you have dc, will you have to walk on eggshells around him every time you 'speak up' or make a decision or act in any way that doesn't immediately kowtow to him?

WanderingNotLost · 30/07/2016 00:52

I don't think he'd actually get hammered, he's not really the type- but that is an example of why I don't think open bars are always a good thing!
The issue is if we do go for the more expensive venue, he would want to keep the free drinks at the expense of something else- like having a video.
I've put in a previous post why it's sort of necessary to use the inheritance. Can't be arsed to type it again!

OP posts:
JuanTime · 30/07/2016 00:53

No open bar,wine on table when food served.thats it.guests want a drink ,they pay

SpecialAgentFreyPie · 30/07/2016 00:54

FGS he's hardly coming across as abusive for having different opinions!

SpecialAgentFreyPie · 30/07/2016 00:57

he would want to keep the free drinks at the expense of something else- like having a video

Something YOU want. Can you get creative, do you have any arty friends/family who could do a video? Free drink is obviously important to HIM. Is there no compromise to be made at all? He suggested a bar cap and you still disagreed.

I've put in a previous post why it's sort of necessary to use the inheritance. Can't be arsed to type it again!

Apologies, should have made it clear I had read your PPs, I just thought maybe it's something you should give more thought to.

WanderingNotLost · 30/07/2016 00:58

DontMindMe I don't know if it's my poor explanation or your misinterpretation but yikes- he's not that bad!

OP posts:
tidyfairy · 30/07/2016 01:11

Don't overthink it. My daughter chose not to even have a photographer at her wedding. Everybody has smartphones nowadays, and they make brilliant pictures. Weddings come in very expensive. Don't sweat it about the wedding. It's your marriage that's important.

ExtraHotLatteToGo · 30/07/2016 01:13

Ok. I'm going to be very blunt.

Things are clearer from the outside, he's manipulating you & you are making excuses...plenty of us have said it, but you're choosing not to listen.

Obviously, that's up to you, your life and all that.

I just hope you don't end up wishing you'd paid more attention to what we were saying and at least giving it some consideration...you're dismissing it out of hand because you're in a hurry to start a family and you are invested in him/this being the right thing to do.

Newmanwannabe · 30/07/2016 02:27

YsNBU. But Use half your inheritance on the wedding and put half into the mortgage. It's a lot of money, and you will end up feeling like you have paid for the wedding, not got what you wanted and resent him. Large gifted sums of money are rare, let it make a difference to your life, not one day of your life. Or his true colours will show and then you'll regret spending it all.

I think it's a bit Hmm that he didn't give the money for the first wedding back to his parents (unless they insisted he keep it).

Newmanwannabe · 30/07/2016 02:28

s=A

onemorecupofcoffeefortheroad · 30/07/2016 03:19

Warning bells also for me. My first wedding I remember finding a venue thinking it was great but then after sleeping on it having second thoughts. Expressed these to fiancé, he dug his heels in wouldn't reconsider, told me I was being fussy and demanding, I gave in because I wanted to be see as being reasonable and not difficult - I regretted it always - should have asserted myself. All my concerns about the venue were proved legitimate on the day. Also his behaviour over this was a template for our subsequent marriage, as soon as my opinion differed from his over something he would resort to telling I was unreasonable, hysterical, always overreacting, paranoid ...
We didn't last.
Your view is equally valid as his and of course you shouldn't pick the first (or second or third or tenth) venue you come across if it's not right. At the moment you're researching places to find the right one - absolutely the sensible thing to do - tell him to wind his neck in - YANBU.

PersianCatLady · 30/07/2016 09:20

Your marriage is the important bit and you can do that quite well without blowing all your money on getting your mates drunk.
A piece of advice that every person planning a wedding should think about.

PaulDacreCuntyMcCuntFace · 30/07/2016 11:14

Best advice I can give you; there are 3 things that people remember about a wedding:

  1. Were they made to feel welcome?
  2. Was there somewhere comfortable to sit down - plenty of seating and not too hot or cold?
  3. Were they fed and was there plenty of it?

I guarantee you that a year post-wedding nobody except you will remember what colour the seat covers were, or what the table favours looked like, or the colour of the wallpaper in the function room.

I don't see any issue with a pay bar. I think it's entirely appropriate to have gratis fizz, beer and soft drinks available when people walk in. It's also nice to lay on water and wine for the table during the meal and some more fizz for the speeches and toasts. Beyond that I would expect to pay at the bar for other drinks.

By all means book the venue that you want; but don't prioritise your venue over the comfort of your guests. I went to a wedding recently where the B&G had gone out of there way to make everyone feel welcome, were very laid back and concerned that guests should enjoy the celebrations, consequently everyone had a whale of a time - including them. Genuinely one of the loveliest weddings that I have been to - and it wasn't because of the venue, or the food or her colour scheme!

FeliciaJollygoodfellow · 30/07/2016 11:18

It's nice to have some money behind the bar. Maybe a compromise of £X amount, enough for each guest to have a couple of bottled beers or mixed drinks?

A much better venue will only matter to you unless you're planning on selling the pictures to a magazine.

BackforGood · 31/07/2016 16:20

Good grief - it happens all the time on MN, people's OHs being accused of being manipulative and controlling. Hmm
Nothing in your posts suggest that to me. He has an opinion about some things to do with the wedding (his wedding too, remember), and you have some things that are important to you. That does not make him manipulative, or controlling or any of the other horrible things a few posters are saying - I presume they must be projecting from some bitter experience of their own.

You are both marrying each other, therefore, you should both be able to have some things that are important to you, even if not so to the other - like the Church in your case, like the money behind the bar, in his. Neither is 'right' or 'wrong', they are just differences in what is important.
I do agree you have to keep reminding yourselves this is one day, and a party, when looking at what you are signing up to spend, but, as you say your Gran would have made a contribution to the wedding had she still been there, then you should feel free to spend her money that way if you wish Smile

Cosmo111 · 31/07/2016 16:30

Best weddings I've been to have been to at a nice pub relaxed nothing over the top or expensive drinks. We wanted our wedding day to be relaxed and went for a nice pub, good range of lagers not pricy. If you can't a agree on what type of wedding you want what hope have you got? Realistically it's a just a day but marriage lasts a life time but only if you put the time effort and comparise when you have to.

BringMeTea · 31/07/2016 16:45

Venue - YANBU
Money behind bar - He is NBU
Church - Meh as neither of you are particularly religious.

Him criticising you changing your mind is more of a concern imo.

Olivialoves · 31/07/2016 17:02

chips and peas: nothing worse than going to a wedding and having to pay £5 for a drink

Really?! £5 is cheap nowadays, and being in London, £5 is a bargain!
I've been to a wedding in the midlands this weekend, and a single g&t was £8.50!!

Cutecat78 · 31/07/2016 17:06

10k isn't a massive budget?! Shock

confuugled1 · 31/07/2016 17:11

Might be worth pricing up a nice venue near your parent's home in Essex (assuming you'd like to get married from there) to see the difference in prices - might be much cheaper than London and/or nicer for the same price so that you both can have the things you want...

Smurfnoff · 31/07/2016 17:35

You want to get married in church, so that's what you're doing. He's happy with the venue you've seen, but you want to keep looking - so you're carrying on looking. He wants to put a few quid behind the bar to give people a drink. Is it really that big a thing? Throw him a bone.

becciandbump · 31/07/2016 18:09

We got married 5 months ago, I also put £5000 inheritance towards the wedding which in my eyes was the best thing to do as I didn't think I could save so much so quickly (we were engaged for less than a year) the wedding ended up costing more than we thought we will have finished paying for it by 7 months after the wedding but was worth it. We put a small amount behind the bar but didn't have a videographer our photos were lovely and tell the story of the day and the best man recorded our vows for us on his iPhone. I sometimes think Id love to relive it and have a video but if im honest the memories are enough xx

DoNotBlameMeIVotedRemain · 31/07/2016 18:21

YANBU about the general principle that you don't just settle for the first thing you see. It's sensible to shop around. Money behind bar is a nice idea but not essential I think.

2kids2dogsnosense · 31/07/2016 18:22

Just a note - if you are having a video of the church service you will need to ensure that you have the priest's permission and that the appropriate licence has been issued (this isn't the church's responsibility - you or the photographer will have to do it).

I only mention this because I used to be a verger, and many people arrive with all the accoutrements - except the appropriate licence. No licence, no video.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread