Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

what ever I buy for her birthday she wont like it.

82 replies

lordsteatime · 28/07/2016 13:46

My mum has a big birthday coming up. We wanted to arrange a party, which she suggested as fun, but when we started suggesting were to have it, who to invite, she said no to all of it.
For instance i asked if i could invite her brothers and their partners/wives and she said, no because she didnt like on of the wives. She didnt want her party ruined by having to be polite to 'that woman'.
A suggestion to have the party at her house was 'too much work and not much of a treat for me' and my suggestion to have party in my home/garden was met with 'you live too far away and my friends wont come' BTW my home is about 20/30 mins by car away from hers.
We made a suggestion of hiring local hall, but again, negative comments made about it.

Recently she has been telling me about all the gifts she has had over the years that were crap esp those from my dad.

i suggested in the end that i take her out for a cream tea as she loves cakes, but she said she makes her own perfectly good scones and cream at home and doesnt need to go out for that.

I have a list in my head of things she hates,
clothes, very fussy about clothes, not see through, not too low a neckline, not wool as it makes her itch, and not too long /short a top length, and not yellow as it makes her look sallow.
no ri rings, watches or necklaces as she has a nickal allergy and only wears a necklace that has a very long chain as she hates tight things around her neck, that can hang outside her clothes.
no ornaments,

Before she mentioned the ornament thing, I already ordered something, a real rose dipped in gold. It looked good on amazon but in reality looks a bit shit.
Have also brought a hamper of tea and biscuits as she meets friends and her brothers at her house once a week.
I think ehe will not be impressed about that either.
so am at a loss.
Should I accept I cant make her happy and concentrate on providing her with something to complain about?

OP posts:
HerRoyalNotness · 28/07/2016 14:46

If she is an expert cake maker, would she like to take a course to learn some modern decorating techniques?

DinosaursRoar · 28/07/2016 14:46

Time to ask her honestly "Mum, your birthday is coming up, all you've told me is what you don't want, can you start talking about things you would like? Can you give me a list of ideas? Also, do you want a party? If not, that's fine, if you do, I'm happy to arrange it, but you've got to tell me where you would like a party to take place. I'll do the work, but all I've heard is where you don't want it, if you want a party, where would you like it to be held?"

If she says she's easy to buy for, tell her that's not true, to give you an actual list of things she wants.

Some people are very good at being negative, and are completely thrown if you ask them directly what they would like as they've been so focussed on what they don't want, they've not thought about what would be nice.

If she can't come up with a location for a party or an idea for a gift, ask her directly if she does want her birthday celebrated or not. It could be all the negativity is because she doesn't want to mark her birthday

and most white woman look terrible in yellow

toadgirl · 28/07/2016 14:46

I think you just have to say something like "I want to get you something you love for your birthday. What would you like?"

This sounds perfect and rational.

Something tells me though, her mother would say "I like surprises - I don't want to choose my own present".

I could be wrong, of course.

Chocolatefudgecake100 · 28/07/2016 14:52

Sounds like my mother ive ended up in tears many a birthday/christmas as shes so difficult So no advice but i feel your pain

DinosaursRoar · 28/07/2016 14:53

Toadgirl - the important thing is to call out people like this - "no, you don't like surprises, everytime someone has tried to surprise you, it's been wrong. If you want it to be a surprise, give me a list of 10 things so you'll still not know which thing you are getting."

HandbagCrab · 28/07/2016 14:54

Amazon vouchers. Having put up with years of no present being good enough however thoughtful or expensive I gave up and go for Amazon vouchers. Let the picky person do the work and let them stew in their own time. Don't bother tying yourself in knots to do a party either. You have to accept in these situations that there is nothing you can do to make this person happy because either they don't want to be or they aren't capable of it. Good luck

CatNip2 · 28/07/2016 14:54

I would say to my mother "Ok so you don't want x, y,z what WOULD you like?"

To be honest, I suggested new patio furniture for her 80th from M&S, she loves it, not sure how I managed to luck out with that one, had it delivered to her house and DB put it together. Lunch out and job done!

NotYoda · 28/07/2016 14:55

I am not sure if you have said "Give me a lost of 3 things you want"

If you haven't, do that. If you have, I agree with others - donate some money to charity in her name

NarcyCow · 28/07/2016 14:55

Get her a card and a bunch of flowers and leave it at that. She's determined not to be happy so there's no point in you losing sleep over it.

NotYoda · 28/07/2016 14:56

Or a card and flowers, as Narcy says

FetchezLaVache · 28/07/2016 14:57

My dad's lady friend is like this.

When dad's mobility started to go and he asked me to buy presents for her, I first of all selected thoughtful gifts from expensive local boutiques - all of which were in some way wrong and required taking back. I now go to M&S and buy her a whatever and wrap the gift receipt up with it. At least it means I now only have to go to the shop once!

iseenodust · 28/07/2016 14:59

I have one of these mums. For her 70th we rounded up the grandchildren and had a professional photo taken. It has actually made it on to a wall in the living room !

BobbinThreadbare123 · 28/07/2016 15:07

My mum is like this. She has never hidden her disappointment at Xmas and birthdays in what we get her.

This year, I've given up, particularly after the last couple of years of utterly thoughtless birthday (tat) presents she has given me.

Amazon vouchers it is, from now on.

Ilovetea82 · 28/07/2016 15:09

Haven't read all so don't know if it has been mentioned but could you take her shopping and get her to pick something out and do a nice lunch out while you are there?
She sounds like my granny who always complained and returned anything my mum ever got her!

Incitatus · 28/07/2016 15:42

Buy her a jar of beetroot and a dry cleaning voucher. That'll really give her something to moan about Grin

Hissy · 28/07/2016 15:43

What 'big' birthday is this? Please don't tell me it's 50?

She sounds awful!

Suggest she sort out what she'd LIKE to do and to let you know.

Then leave her to it.

Ceic · 28/07/2016 15:49

Club together and send her on a residential bake school course, eg patisserie or similar. There's severla across the UK and I bet several of them have some kind of GBBO-type course.

OR

Ask her what she actually wants, like others have said

OR

buy her the bloody goat.

toadgirl · 28/07/2016 15:53

the important thing is to call out people like this - "no, you don't like surprises, everytime someone has tried to surprise you, it's been wrong. If you want it to be a surprise, give me a list of 10 things so you'll still not know which thing you are getting

Perfect, I am taking notes. This pre-empts the nonsense. Great advice.

toadgirl · 28/07/2016 15:55

Buy her a jar of beetroot and a dry cleaning voucher
Buy her the bloody goat

Grin

Sometimes you can have fun just going for something really random and off-the-wall. You might as well have fun with this.

d270r0 · 28/07/2016 16:00

I am getting my mum a murder mystery weekend in a nice hotel- expensive but she'll love it. What about something like that? Dinner out, theatre, hotel etc.
Another thing that usually goes down well is big box of hotel chocolat chocolates, maybe with flowers.
Another thing that occured to me is a subscription to a magazine/ puzzle book/ subscription box such as graze

puglife15 · 28/07/2016 16:05

If she loves Queen how about a signed photo of Freddie Mercury?

SlimCheesy2 · 28/07/2016 16:16

I did a fantastic cooking course at River Cottage. It was £140 or so though, so might be way out of your price range unless others chip in.

But to be honest, joy sucking sounds about right. I feel like smacking some sense into her, and I am just reading about it!

blitheringbuzzards1234 · 28/07/2016 16:19

Hell on earth, your mum sounds like bloody hard work. My dad was similar (pushing up daisies now thank goodness). Why do we bother to make so much effort when it is thrown back in our faces? And what do they hope to gain by being so damn fussy?
In the end I gave up. Just sent a card. You can't please the unpleaseable and it isn't worth the effort. Have you ever told her what hard work she is even in a jokey way? Ever shouted that you'll get her nothing as she won't be happy anyway? Wasn't she brought up to say thank you for any gift? A one way ticket to the moon sounds appropriate.

LyndaNotLinda · 28/07/2016 16:22

Give her a twinned toilet

SlimCheesy2 · 28/07/2016 16:23

I do agree blithering. I had a family member like this too. He was very sour and shirty around Christmas time..... to the point that we ended up not getting anything at all for some years and gave each others's gifts in our bedroom before going down for breakfast.

Did that for a few years before finally thinking how stupid we were to tip toe around him!

Swipe left for the next trending thread