Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL has accused me of cheating on DH!

102 replies

DillyDingDillyDong · 22/04/2016 16:00

I've been losing weight and trying to get my confidence up a bit with a new hair do, new clothes, make up, nails eyebrows etc. I have felt really frumpy since DS (1) was born so thought I'd try and give myself a boost.

It's really worked and I am starting to enjoy the occasional meet up with friends which I wouldn't do before. I used to make excuses as I felt like a fat mum! DH has noticed a change in me and even though he says that he loved me the was I was I know he likes the more confident me better. I'm more like the person I was when we first started going out.

I've joined the gym and got a personal trainer, let's call him Paul. Paul called me the other day when MIL was here and I went in the other room to answer. I made plans to see him at the gym the next day for a session. I came back in and MIL had clearly been trying to listen in. She asked who it was and I just said it was someone from the gym.

This weekend a friend of mine has booked last minute flights home and has arranged a last minute get together. DH was invited too but he has plans so I said I'd stay with DS and see the friend Sunday morning instead. DH decided to call MIL to see if she could have DS for a couple of hours on Saturday while we're both out. DH came back in and said in a really serious voice "I think we need to talk."

I started to worry and he said he'd spoken to MIL and she thinks I might be hiding something and if I am I should tell him now. I was a bit taken aback and couldn't think what he meant. He must have saw my worried face because he burst out laughing and apologised but said that MIL has just told him I had lied to her about speaking to a man named Paul and arranging to meet up with him while DH was in work. She said he should get evidence of me meeting this friend as she thinks there is something going on. He obviously to,d her she was being ridiculous and she said that its the only way to explain the sudden change in appearance and all these afternoons/nights out. (I've had maybe four over the last two months)

He said that he trusts me and he knows I'm not cheating on him and that he was annoyed that she had came to this conclusion without talking to either of us first, but also said that it isn't any of her business what I get up to anyway. She said she was just worried about him and DS and doesn't want to have to pick up the pieces when I leave.

DH was angry at first, but obviously couldn't resist winding me up, and now finds the whole thing so ridiculous it's funny. I am sat here fuming that she came to that conclusion and has accused me of cheating!

Would it be unreasonable for me to call her and give her a piece of my mind?

OP posts:
SuperFlyHigh · 23/04/2016 08:04

centigrade has either been reading too many soft porn stories involving married women and personal trainers or she reads Closer/New/Take a Break and sees either:-

"Shocker I left my husband of 25 years for my hottie personal trainer who's now dumped me for a nubile 18 year old!"

OR

"Natalie Cassidy/Cher (eg) (etc) has left her boyfriend after an affair with her hot new personal trainer who coincidentally she's just released a workout video with".

OP yes MIL is jealous. I had this a few years ago when living with someone (no kids) lost weight, toned up, gym memebership and my partners mum came out with the "who are you doing all this for then? Must be someone." She also swore blind she'd seen me running round the park with my new man (member of running club I belonged to). She dripped poison into my boyfriend at our house when she came over to see us him (she lived nearby) and almost broke us up! Never again!

AnnieNoMouse · 23/04/2016 08:16

If MIL had good reason to think OP was having an affair then it would have been reasonable for her to speak to her son.
But she does not have good reason - she's mischief making.
I don't agree that OP and husband and PT now get involved in silly games - you'll just be bringing yourself to MILs level. And if my spouse wanted me to play a game of let's pretend he's having an affair, I wouldn't.

CodyKing · 23/04/2016 08:20

And if my spouse wanted me to play a game of let's pretend he's having an affair, I wouldn't

It's called humour? Lightens the situation? Not a real suggestion ........

Chippednailvarnish · 23/04/2016 08:27

centigrade the 1950's called, they want their attitudes back.

Your Mil is a shit-stirrer OP.

SharingMichelle · 23/04/2016 08:33

I don't think MIL was totally out of order. She obviously believed that something was going on, and she raised it discretely with her son. OP's DH reacted perfectly. If I were OP I'd feel a bit miffed at MIL, but I'd get over it in time assuming we had an otherwise reasonable relationship. No one is being U here (except Cent, obvs).

VioletTea · 23/04/2016 10:07

I would struggle to see the funny side tbh, especially given how controlling she has been, eg you said you had to plan your wedding in secret and she went"insane" when you wanted to move to another city?! What's it got to do with her?!

My mil is fortunately quite laidback, trusts me and wouldn't give two hoots if she overheard me on the phone to my personal trainer.
If she were to accuse me of cheating (and not even have the balls to confront me but ring up my DH) I would be beyond hurt and it would damage my relationship with her.

sparechange · 23/04/2016 10:36

Personally, I think it's very odd that Paul called you. Is this part of the service, that he nags you to book in another session?

What is odd about it? Why is it nagging?
My personal trainer calls me at the weekend to check I've been on the run I said I would. He phones or texts me after our sessions to book the next one if I have had to run back to work without having a chance to book in.
He phones or texts me before races to wish me luck and afterwards to see how I got on

Of course it is 'part of the service'. It is motivation, it is giving a shit about clients and their goals.

If you see it as something nefarious, you need to step away from the soft porn novels

KayTee87 · 23/04/2016 10:53

Your mil sounds like a bit of a nightmare op Confused

I would genuinely be so upset if my mil thought I was having an affair, I'd be hurt if she didn't trust me and even more hurt if she didn't feel that she could speak to me about it herself.

Op maybe you should call your mil to clear the air, stay calm and explain to her that you're actually very upset by the accusation and not that you have to explain yourself but you've been doing all the exercise etc. to help you feel better about yourself and in turn its making her son happy.

Mstu · 23/04/2016 10:57

Centrigrade - what if either parties were gay?! - Old fashioned?! - more like sexist and totally ridiculous.

BertrandRussell · 23/04/2016 10:57

As I said earlier, if my mum thought my dp might be having an affair, and didn't tell me, or talked to him about it (!) before she talked to me I would be incredibly upset. And so would every one on here.

Tartsamazeballs · 23/04/2016 11:10

Considering my last convo with my male PT was whether my husband's 250kg leg press scream/grunts were louder than I will be in labour, I can only guess that Centigrade has an unrealistic and very romanticised idea of what happens during a PT session Grin

You're there to work out bro, not make out. Get a life!

roundaboutthetown · 23/04/2016 13:20

Oh, ffs. I don't have a personal trainer and if I did, I would be as fucking annoyed that he was badgering me as when I get reminders from the dentist, or if my hairdresser phoned up to tell me I hadn't been in for a while! Hence my comment. My dh has a female personal trainer and she has never called him - he arranges the next session at the time of the session before. So I'm not being prudish, I just think it's nagging and therefore have sympathy with the mil if she found it weird.

roundaboutthetown · 23/04/2016 14:23

And fwiw, I fail to understand why it is supposedly polite to leave a guest alone in another room while you go off to talk on the phone to someone. Surely it is more polite to ask the person to ring at another time?

corythatwas · 23/04/2016 15:55

squoosh Fri 22-Apr-16 17:41:15

"Male gynaecologists are okay, but only as long as they wear a blind fold. The blind fold does make things slightly more hazardous for the patient but you can't put a price on modesty can you?"

That explains the quality of the stitching on my fanjo after dc1 birth. Mind you, I thought she was female- still, may have been a lesbian. But at least she was modest. I have the shape to prove it.

BIWI · 23/04/2016 16:18

roundabout - my (very young, and very male) PT doesn't call me, but he texts. I see him twice a week; after the first appointment we arrange a time for the next one there and then, but then towards the time of the next session either I text him or he texts me.

It would work the same way if it was a call.

I really can't see what you think the problem is?!

TheNaze73 · 23/04/2016 16:19

I agree with centigrade Wink

BIWI · 23/04/2016 17:07

Why?

carabos · 23/04/2016 18:11

I have to say this thread has been a real eye-opener, both from my perspective as a PT client and as the DW of a sports coach. I'm gobsmacked at the suspicious minds and old-fashioned attitudes on display. Why on earth do people think that every male/ female transaction has a sexual element to it? Does anyone really buy into all that Freudian stuff these days? Hmm

BIWI · 23/04/2016 18:35

I'm Grin at the idea that my PT would find me even vaguely attractive when I'm working out at the gym!

BertrandRussell · 23/04/2016 18:49

"Why on earth do people think that every male/ female transaction has a sexual element to it"

To be fair, I think only one person on this thread does....or maybe two? Did someone else agree with her?

roundaboutthetown · 23/04/2016 19:08

BIWI - on what planet is a personal phone call the same thing as a reminder text about a prearranged appointment?! One is far more intrusive than the other - I can ignore a text until I want to look at it, but have to answer a phone call, or pay for the answerphone message, or ignore it and then not get the "reminder" (which in this case was not a reminder, but nagging someone to have a personal training session they hadn't already organised after they will already have been to an exercise class that morning, which sounds a bit obsessed with exercise to me and totally not in need of extra motivation!).

BIWI · 23/04/2016 19:21

I think you have a bit of an issue going on there, roundabout Grin

Our texts follow pretty much the same pattern of conversation as would a call - although obviously they're shorter.

And it isn't about the PT nagging someone - it's about making arrangements that suit both parties.

DillyDingDillyDong · 23/04/2016 20:01

Bit off topic but I had asked if he was free on this particular day and he wasn't but had a cancellation the day before. He called to give me first refusal for the session before sending a mass text to his other clients. Sometimes he calls, sometimes he texts. When I started with him he asked for a preference and I said that either was fine and if I didn't answer to just text.

I was sat in the room with MIL and FIL who were discussing the death of one of FIL's cousins and were arguing over whether or not they should go to the funeral. I was glad to excuse myself to answer the call! Even if they hadn't been talking I still would have taken the call in the other room as sometimes he will talk about my weight or other issues and I wouldn't want MIL listening in on that.

Also worth mentioning that DH paid for my hair and other beauty treatments when I said I was thinking about changing my hair in an attempt to help. MIL knows this, so knows I've not just gone out by myself and decided to change things but I've spoken about it with DH and it has helped with my PND.

I honestly see this as her attempt to cause a bit of drama and get between us. It's backfired of course. All she had to do if she was really worried was ask if DH knew who Paul was at the gym and he would have said he knew all about him. DH goes to my gym and knows Paul. Or even later on ask more about the gym and I may have mentioned my PT sessions to her. She heard me say something along the lines of "Hi Paul...good thanks and you?...tomorrow yes, what time are you free?...that's great thanks, I have spinning in the morning too so I will be around after that...thanks for calling, see you tomorrow."

She has form for doing things and saying she is just trying to help and isn't interfering, except that's exactly what she does.

She called this afternoon to ask if she was still having DS tonight and DH said no. She asked him if he had spoken to me about everything and he told her he had and that I thought she was being ridiculous too and that I am waiting for an apology. I've not heard anything off her.

OP posts:
roundaboutthetown · 23/04/2016 20:34

Fair enough, OP. I agree your mil was either stirring, or has serious trust issues, or both.

Chippednailvarnish · 23/04/2016 20:40

My last PT (male) also used to give me a sports massage.

Shocking or what. And my DH knew. Shock

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread