Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

sky tv and benefits

62 replies

Moomoomango · 04/04/2016 19:19

My situation : 2 children 1 disabled hubby. I'm his registered carer and we claim income support. Before I became dh carer and had kids I worked very hard often working more than one job, so not work shy (in fact looking for part time work as we speak) just the situation. We are very lucky to live in a lovely home with a large garden for the children. Children are fed and clothed and have plenty of toys / days out / activities (within budget anyway!)

Myself and dh don't go out at all, don't drink or smoke, very rarely buy clothes have relatively low maintenance lives but my dh loves football so has sky ( I would rather not have sky but that's another topic)

My sil who has a very well paid job and my brother is a self made millionaire. They live in a huge house and want for nothing. I'm pleased for them, they work hard and play hard.

A conversation came up which I was not involved in but in the room whereby they were discussing politics with my dad. All of a sudden I hear my name called and asked how much our sky bill was, I replied £X I think, and then sil said very loudly "yeah that's not right people on benefits should not have sky tv"

I felt like a sub human who didn't deserve any pleasure (Not that it's my pleasure but it's the principle)!

Aibu to think if you are entitled to benefits (such as disabled benefits or caring benefits) you should be able to have a small luxury here and there if you have budgeted and all bills are covered?

Essentially I could have the govt pay for carers and I go out to work full time but it would cost the govt far more than I get paid to provide that service. Then I would be entitled to a life of free choice?

OP posts:
KayTee87 · 04/04/2016 20:51

Also sorry your brother and his wife are millionaires and she's moaning about you having sky instead of them offering to pay for it for a family Christmas present or something. Maybe you wouldnt let them I'm not sure but still seems like the wrong way around to me!

x2boys · 04/04/2016 21:03

I assume your dh gets disability benefits ? Which are meant to make life a little easier ds2 gets dla ,and you can spend disability benefits on whatever you want tell sil to sod off.

cozietoesie · 04/04/2016 21:05

There can be a disconcerting amount of 'sniping' and 'looking sideways' which goes on in families, even seemingly close ones. It's usually done in the kitchen in my experience - as asides over food preparation or dish clearing. Looks as if you just caught some of the views she probably expresses more strongly among her own circle of friends and acquaintances.

Yipeekayee72 · 04/04/2016 21:10

your money your choice.

A lot of people I know have the full sky package and don't pay anything for it but that's for another thread!

Thisismyfirsttime · 04/04/2016 21:59

So your dad agreed with her, whilst knowing you were there and hearing it, that you shouldn't have Sky because you're on benefits? Nice one, dad! Thanks for that!

Valentine2 · 04/04/2016 22:08

Why didnt you ask her right here in front of all those people what are you supposed to do inside hem caring for your husband and essentially what does your husband do if he is bound to stay in the house due to a physical condition?

ClopySow · 04/04/2016 22:23

I can't get my head around this idea that everyone doesn't deserve the basics and a bit more. So what if sky tv is a bit of a luxury? Don't lower earners deserve a little bit of pleasure too? Or should they be making their own entertainment with a stick like t'old days?

Shite.

This channel 5 view of the world has got to go.

IAmNotAMindReader · 04/04/2016 22:34

clopysow lower earners should be up 24/7 looking for or undertaking more work. If only they worked harder they would have more money and contribute more to society, don't you know. The rich have earned their time off and little luxuries.

That type of attitude boils my piss. Its not that easy to just get another job, the difficulties involved have been discussed on many threads.

Tell your SIL how much you save the government in care fees by doing it yourself for the pittance you get and after you've finished ask if the 3 crusts of stale bread and out of date food you consume daily is too much for her taxes to bear, or would she prefer you lick the soles of her shoes clean for sustenance. Silly mare.

NeedsAsockamnesty · 04/04/2016 22:37

Whether benefits should be at a level where someone can afford Sky TV is one issue that is fair to debate. Picking on an individual for claiming the benefits that the system says they are entitled to isn't really on. The government says that's what you're entitled to, so spend it how you like

When those benefits are PIP/DLA or CA then no it is not fair to debate, not even for a teeny tiny second

GreatFuckability · 04/04/2016 22:41

What you spend your money on is none of her business. Cunt.

flythroughtheclouds · 04/04/2016 22:49

OP, I totally understand.

I don't have Sky now, but I did when I was younger because it actually saved me money as it meant I was entertained at home if you like then I found Mumsnet - not quite the same thing I know but I get you!

TheNaze73 · 04/04/2016 23:35

It's got cock all to do with her. What a hideous thing to say

New posts on this thread. Refresh page