Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to pander to her?

57 replies

MadHattersWineParty · 13/08/2015 13:58

My mother, who wants me to pen her a letter on why I have made her feel rubbish....

Background is, I'm nearly thirty but we've always had a tricky relationship. I feel like everything always has to be on her terms and the overall atmosphere of any family gathering is dependent on what mood she is in. I live a few hours away and she keeps in touch by sending me statements over email that might just say 'I'm looking for a new job' or, 'we are going to do the floor in the house today' or, if o haven't been responding to the above, links to online 'evidence' of the latest food that is causing her health problems. (She has no diagnosed allergies or intolerances despite numerous tests) never a 'Hi, how are you?' phone conversations are quite hard work as she talks about herself and her problems for about 90% of the time we are on the phone. When I was younger I found it really difficult to live with her as I always just felt that she just didn't like me very much. She never seems to be that interested until she can use something to sort of gain some attention or spotlight onto her, IYKWIM.

Anyway. My dad had surgery recently and I wanted to take some time off work to travel to see him and stay a few days. He's in a lot of pain and will need physio. My parents are divorced but he lives in the next town to my mum. It happened as when I was packing s few things together I got a phone call from my gran (my mum's mum, we get on well and keep in touch although I don't get to see her very often) and I mentioned I was travelling back home. My grandparents then offered to pick me up from my train and take me out for some lunch. Then they drove me to my dad's.

Now, I should have mentioned to my mum at some point that I was going to be in the area, but I really just wanted to see how my Dad was, and as my mum is usually quite busy with various things I intended to drop her a line the next day and see if she was free for a quick coffee. The visit just wasn't about her, I've been worried about my dad and just wanted to spend time with him.

Unfortunately my Gran (who my mum does not get on with) phoned my mum and told her about the lunch and how lovely it had been to see me.

So I got a message from my mum telling me I had embarrassed her by her by not knowing I was back, that she didn't know what she's done wrong, and they she now expects me to write her a letter to explain my actions. She then said she did not want to see my anyway and she'd been having a shit time recently and I'd made her feel rubbish about herself, so thanks for that. So I left it at that, apart from a message back saying I didn't want to fall out and was not a big conspiracy not telling her I was back, but in hindsight I should have mentioned it.

I don't know what to bloody do. I don't want to sit down and write such a letter. Don't know how to move forward as if I don't we will be at a stalemate. The letter I presume I I am expected to grovel a bit and sort of 'explain myself' I'm not really sure TBH.

Thanks for reading as is so long. AIBU for not wanting to write a bloody essay on the reasons why I'm a rubbish daughter?!

OP posts:
Icimoi · 14/08/2015 17:23

Ask her to write you a letter explaining why your previous message isn't enough for her.

lostinikea · 14/08/2015 17:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

AcrossthePond55 · 14/08/2015 17:32

Sounds as if you're lucky she didn't give you lines!

"I will not be mean to Mummy. I will tell Mummy my every move."

I wouldn't write any such letter. The message you sent was perfectly adequate and by responding via text you pretty much indicate that you aren't writing any such letter.

It's a stalemate. But one I feel that she will be the one to break. She isn't going to be able to remain quietly waiting for your apology letter. I'd lay bets that she'll be contacting you soon to either ask where it is or to lay a guilt trip on you.

I'm curious. Would she expect you to notify your father if you were coming to town to see her? I'm guessing not.

ALittleFaith · 14/08/2015 17:37

book link

Littlegreyauditor · 14/08/2015 18:01

There is a quote from Great Expectations which I would have to use:

"I am what you have made me. Take all the praise, take all the blame".

I would put it in writing for her if she really insisted, maybe on a postcard.

Minicaters · 14/08/2015 18:41

Don't write her anything, in any medium, no matter how brilliantly witty and/or sarcastic. She is trying to keep your relationship in parent-child when it should be adult-adult. Any response in child mode (like writing the demanded letter) entrenches you both even further in parent-child. No matter what she says, only engage in adult-adult mode. That tries to manoeuvre her out of parent and into adult, because adult-parent doesn't really work.

Writing the letter, even in a cutting and clever way, is a bit like a child apologising when told to, but in a singsong voice or something. The parent might choose to accept the apology and ignore the insurrection, or insist on a better apology, but either way the parent is in control.

Here endeth my amateur psychology.

OTheHugeManatee · 14/08/2015 18:45

My dad asks me to do something like this occasionally, confessing all my crimes to mollify my toxic stepmother. My reaction is always the same - I just ignore it and certainly don't oblige.

Seriously, this is no relationship. Your mother sounds awful. Have you considered moving away?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread