Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be a bit miffed by this? (SIL)

71 replies

wineandcake · 24/04/2015 17:23

Hi everyone

Just wanted to get some insight into what I consider to be very petty on behalf of SIL but not sure if I am being petty for thinking it petty!

So my mum passed away this week after a long and tough battle with dementia. Funeral is next week and we decided it would be nice for the 4 older cousins (aged between 11-16) to read a verse each of her favourite poem, and all cousins (2 younger ones included) are going to say some of their favourite memories.

My DH sister and I have been emailing about the poem/memories just laying out who will say which part etc. In my email, I used the word "paragraph" instead of "verse" when talking about the poem. The response I get from SIL:

Hi J

Yes think that will all work nicely! DCs are just finishing up writing their memories- will send to you when done.

Cxx

p.s it's a verse not a paragraph!

Um..really? I'm not offended as such I just think it's unbelievably petty. The thing is SIL and I have never exactly seen eye to eye. We never had a big bust up or anything but we are SUCH different people and our personalities completely clash. I have a pretty dark, snarky sense of humour. She is fairly thin skinned and takes offence easily and is often mortified by darker humour. It's fine, not an issue, we're just very different. We hadn't seen each other since about 2001 but in 2012 my DB had a stroke (he's fine now) which forced us to spend more time together, and actually everything was fine. I think we were both pleasantly surprised at how easy things were between us. We haven't spoken/seen each other much since but I really feel like we're on fine terms we'll just never be BFFS.

She has always had a bit of a hang up academically though. Her family are all highly academic- (both parents doctorates, MSc herself and her brother doctorate also). DC2 is highly academic, DC1 not as much but still well above average.

My side of the family are not academic really at all. Both myself and my DB (Not her DH, other DB) are dyslexic and struggled a lot at school but I was always very arty and am now an illustrator. DB very dyslexic but has a great job working in IT. Other DB (her DH) by far the most academic out of all of us, but still "just" an undergrad in philosophy but from a RG. Neither of my parents went to uni. SIL has admitted before that her mum is an "academia snob" (Which she is) but it seems SIL has become like it too! I've always felt like she looked down on us all a bit.

It just felt like this was such an unnecessary dig and I have no idea whether to even mention it in my response. As I say I'm not offended I just think it's such a silly thing to even mention. I mean really WHY bother? Am I over thinking this? What would you all think/do in my shoes??

OP posts:
PHANTOMnamechanger · 24/04/2015 22:14

adding to the stanza theme, how about replying thus -

"thanks, I was going to say stanza but wanted to make sure you knew what I meant"

LizzieVereker · 24/04/2015 22:34

I am an appalling pedant, but I think she was extremely rude considering the subject matter of the e-mails. I doubt she meant any harm, but it was insensitive, nonetheless. I would just ignore it. I am very sorry for your loss Thanks.

StupidBloodyKindle · 24/04/2015 22:43

Rise above. Ignore. Smile and wave.
You are clearly nbu. She lives in pedants' corner and gets off on correcting people's...everyone's... emails. But clearly has no emotional iq.
You are better than this so do not bother engaging. Sorry about your mum Brew

StupidBloodyKindle · 24/04/2015 22:43
Cake
StupidBloodyKindle · 24/04/2015 22:44
Flowers
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 24/04/2015 22:57

You could always go back with a MN haiku (the art of using stylised poetry as a weapon) e.g.

Post Scripts.
Fragrant blooms hiding
Wasps inside.

That should wind her up a bit Wink

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 24/04/2015 23:14

Brilliant, Chaz - absolutely brilliant!!

angstyaunty · 25/04/2015 01:12

She sounds very unpleasant. Sorry for your loss. Flowers

grannytomine · 25/04/2015 03:40

She knew exactly what you meant, no need to correct it. YANBU

FeijoaSundae · 25/04/2015 04:28

I would reply acknowledging it, but in such a way that isn't tit for tat...

'Thanks for pointing out my error. Great, looking forward to seeing the finished product, it's going to be lovely.

J x'

I wouldn't be able to let it slide.

CheerfulYank · 25/04/2015 05:45

What the hell?! Why would she say that? Ugh. YANBU.

shewept · 25/04/2015 06:30

I am very sorry for your loss.Flowers

Yabu and yanbu it was a silly comment to make, but my bro does stuff like this and never means any offence. Since you usually get on I would let it go. It would be really petty to respond with a snarky email back.

SisterConcepta · 25/04/2015 08:06

Sorry for the loss of your mum op.
Don't reply to it - she sounds like a complete tit.

winkywinkola · 25/04/2015 08:09

It was a prattish thing to write.

Let it go. And ignore other prattish things she does. What a pita.

FusionChefGeoff · 25/04/2015 08:10

Without reading the very detailed back story I would just think absentmindedly 'oh yeah, so it is, good point' rather than take any offence.

Over thinking - but very understandable.

Charis1 · 25/04/2015 08:17

sorry for your loss.

maybe she is concerned to have the wording right in the order of service? that isn't particularly petty. order of services matter a lot to people.

OneDecisionMade · 25/04/2015 08:20

She was making a quite unnecessary point. Her corrections are best kept for her children. You're dealing with so very much that I'd leave it and ignore that completely. I'd be very tempted to make a comment to say as much - but it'd potentially create tension that you could do without at this difficult time. I'm sorry for your loss.

CombineBananaFister · 25/04/2015 08:21

In black and white it looks like a tiny thing to get bothered over but in context it's quite belittling and rude - YANBU.
There's absolutely no reason for her to put it, she's not proof reading a work document for you it's an email about your mums funeral FGS.
If this is what she has to do to feel superior then I'd just laugh it off, silly bugger. Again don't think she meant it, probably just can't help herself which does not reflect well on her.
Sorry about your mum.

PlumpingThePartTimeMother · 25/04/2015 08:26

A distant relative corrected my aunt's grammar during my grandmother's funeral. My aunt spent the rest of the day walking around muttering "Correct my grammar at my bloody mother's funeral, will you?" She's Welsh, so imagine it in that accent Grin we all laughed after a while.

Sorry for your loss op Flowers

SnowyPiglet · 25/04/2015 08:53

I would be a bit pissed off too - it's just adding to your angst, isn't it? Reply with the bit about the stanza, and/or say 'wish I had had a better educayshon!' Relatively light-hearted, but hopefully she will get the message. (Sorry for your loss, it's a horrid thing to have to deal with)

PlumpingThePartTimeMother · 25/04/2015 10:16

Reply: "Gosh, thanks for correcting my mistake! I'll have to work on improving my language skills once my mother's funeral is out of the way."

If she has any sense she'll be embarrassed.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page