Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider getting DD and iPad for Christmas?

59 replies

lollylolster · 12/12/2014 12:23

I know from other posts that iPads/tablets can be controversial but DD1 is nearly 13, mature, responsible and very tech-savvy. She would really like and iPad for Christmas, is happy for it to be an older model, second hand refurbished and if she gets that doesn’t want anything else. She also says if she’s lucky enough to get one she would happily share with DD2 (10). I think this is a very reasonable request and we can easily afford it (we have a good income).

DH is very against it. He thinks she’s too young, doesn’t need it since she has an (old) iPod and we shouldn’t be buying into all the commercialism/consumerism of Christmas.

DH seems very proud that he doesn’t have a smart phone, we don’t have a wii or an xbox or a laptop or any other tablets. Although he actually has an iPad – this was provided by his work and because of that no one else is allowed to use it (unless he needs help with something).

I’m 10 years younger than DH and work in IT. I totally get the appeal of an iPad and think she would get fantastic use out of it, whether it’s researching for homework or watching a movie (DH controls the remote for our TV).

I’m struggling with everything just now and this seems to be getting to me more than it should. I lost DM quite suddenly a few months ago (I’m an only child, dad died when I was 4 so we were very close). I asked DH to help with Christmas this year since he’s had a lot of time off work and I knew I would struggle to cope, but he refused saying I just had poor time management. So I’ve managed to get everything organised except DD1’s main present. I just can’t bring myself to spend the same amount (or more) on something else when I could actually get her the one thing she really wants, and now it’s getting closer.

I’ve tried to talk to him about it but he says he’ll get furious if I mention it again, and there’s no way I should even consider going behind his back when he’s said ‘no’.

I’m not sure if I’m maybe just trying to compensate in some way? DD’s were very close to DM who loved to spoil them at Christmas so I know that’ll leave a big gap this year so I feel it’s up to me to try & make it special? Is DH right, have I just lost all perspective?

OP posts:
OnMyWhistle · 12/12/2014 15:43

And sorry you lost your mum :(

notagainffffffffs · 12/12/2014 15:48

Dh is your problem. Not the ipad- what would your mum say?

fourwoodenchairs · 12/12/2014 15:56

My 4 year old is getting an iPad mini, if you're bad I am so much worse Grin

lollylolster · 12/12/2014 16:16

I hadn't thought what DM would say. We had a similar issue last year at DD2's birthday - she had her heart set on a pair of heelies which DH was set against (thought they were silly, she'd never wear them). We got her something else, went to DM's for birthday cake - and there were the exact pair she wanted (she loves them, wears them at every opportunity). Maybe DH thought I set that up but I hadn't, DD obviously mentioned it to DM. So in this case it's possible DM would have Santa drop off an iPad at her house (or maybe even one for each of them). She always had a big sack of presents for them of things they'd mentioned throughout the year, she was incredibly generous.

OP posts:
Topseyt · 12/12/2014 16:17

In future years just say you'll sort Christmas as usual. If he doesn't want to help out (as he seems to say) then maybe he will just leave you to it. No discussions necessary as he clearly has no idea how to be civil to you.

Butkin · 12/12/2014 16:18

DD got her ipad when she was 10 (now nearly 12) and by far the best thing she's ever owned and probably likely to own in the next few years. She gets so much pleasure out of it both for pleasure and for helping with her homework. An outstanding present for a child that age and you should buy one for her. I have no idea why your DH is so against it and to be honest he sounds an arse. I don't think you should even worry what he thinks in this situation. He's very lucky to have you and such a sensible DD..

MissDuke · 12/12/2014 16:59

Op your dd sounds lovely, and is not demanding this like we see of some very young children! So yanbu at all, he is! I agree with your last post, head over to relationships for expert advice on your marriage x

bubalou · 12/12/2014 17:25

I think it's a completely fair present for a 13 year old and don't really get the fuss your DH is making!

Our Ds has always been very techy and we got him one this year for his 6th birthday.

He has no internet access, can't buy anything without our password so no dangers there. We made sure it has a whole host of educational games that he plays on it and we limit his time.

It is awesome and a real life saver when travelling as they can watch films etc.
Smile

BsshBosh · 12/12/2014 17:36

I love the idea of getting her a laptop and a coding course.

But iPad for a sensible 13 yo is fine. YANBU.

But your DH sounds controlling and not at all respectful of your opinions and feelings.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page